http://gty.im/2212564020
Geelong claimed a thrilling three-point win over Collingwood at the MCG on Saturday night, but the Round 8 contest will be remembered as much for its drama and controversy as its high-quality football.
The Cats prevailed 13.12 (90) to 12.15 (87) in a tense, see-sawing match that ended with Jack Crisp—playing a record-breaking 245th consecutive AFL game—missing a potential match-winner after the final siren.
However, it was the final minutes that sparked fierce debate. With just over two minutes remaining, Collingwood’s Bobby Hill was penalised for tripping Geelong’s Shaun Mannagh in what many viewed as a contentious call. The resulting free kick led to a goal that helped shift the momentum decisively in Geelong’s favour.
Adding fuel to the fire, the AFL later admitted that a key goal from Geelong star Jeremy Cameron earlier in the match should not have stood. The ball had clearly gone out of bounds before Cameron’s shot, but the play was not called dead by the boundary umpire.
Ollie Dempsey provided a legitimate highlight for the Cats with a spectacular mark over Steele Sidebottom that’s already being labelled a “Mark of the Year” contender.
In the aftermath, Geelong’s Bailey Smith made headlines for off-field antics—caught on camera mocking his former club, the Western Bulldogs, and flashing a controversial hand gesture in the rooms.
Despite the controversy, both teams delivered a game of finals-like intensity. Collingwood had more scoring shots but failed to capitalise, with inaccuracy in front of goal proving costly.
The loss is a blow to the reigning premiers, while Geelong cemented themselves as a serious contender.
As debate over umpiring continues to swirl, so too does discussion over the balance between performance, personality, and respect in the modern AFL. For all the brilliance on display, it’s the drama that will linger longest.
