AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Calcification?
I think that'd be pretty purple glasses, while I like what I've seen any other team would rightly point to limited evidence at AFL level.
I dont know, he's playing reasonably well with flashes as a very young KPF. If I could get a young 21 year old KPF from another club who was having a few shots on goal each game, a pick in the 20s seems fine to me.
I think a pick in the 20s is overvaluing him way too much. At the end of the day, he's not much of a goal kicker. He plays a role in our team and plays it very well, but you can't sell him to another team that way. I'd say something around 30-40 is more realistic for him.
I mean that's only like 10 picks different. I'm honestly not sure what his value would be (and a big game before the end of the season could have a massive impact) but I think his age and position is a massive determinant in what he'd both worth.
Definitely wouldn't trade him but if he walks due to us not valuing him as much as other $$ then it does come into play
he will fit in nicely then
No one wants to trade him, they are just discussing what he is hypothetically worth because it's a fun exercise.
Ash Johnson has shown an ability to hit the scoreboard at AFL level.
I'd agree he has but he's 5 years older which is massive development for a "key tall" and Treacy definitely provides more in other areas such as pressure and contest.
How about Weideman, pick 37 last year. He is older but is projecting as a bad KPF. JT surely in that ballpark, not that I want him to go anywhere.
The age difference is massive though, I mean, the fact Weideman who is basically a bust at the point he was traded, went for pick 37 just adds to the idea that Treacy would go for a top 30 pick.
I like what Treacy brings for us, but by my "eye test" Johnson is a more natural eye for goal.
Yeah I know, just think you're underselling him. 20 year old (still 20 for 2 months) who get regular games are highly valued even from showing a little bit, just getting a game is a massive indication of value at his age
I, too, think Treacy's closer to Fogarty than Johnson, which is actually pretty exciting. Fogarty is looking like a young Walker, perhaps slightly less mobile but more grown-up.
