For me this is by far the most concerning thing. He hasn’t learnt a thing from his first stint as coach. Most coaches the 2nd time around have learnt from their previous mistakes. Not our Brad, he doubles down on the older guys and chips the younger ones
Be very interesting to see if any young...
I can’t imagine anyone giving up anything of value to get weed.I’d be staggered if anybody enquires about him at all
If weed hasn’t played until now with all our injuries down back this season, it’s pretty clear Brad doesn’t rate him imo.
Even if he is playing good footy in the VFL, there is...
If that team selection doesn’t tell you that Brad isn’t the right man for us, I don’t know what will
Weed is a guarantee to be delisted in a few weeks. But yep, let’s put him in over a kid in Hayes who could really use a taste of senior footy
Shiel really hasn’t been playing that well. He is good when he has the ball, but his defensive effort when he doesn’t have the ball is as poor as it’s always been
To play Shiel just to hopefully get a slightly better draft pick over a young kid is just the sort of shortsighted view that the...
True. But why wouldn’t you have Shiel play majority up forward and Hobbs play the majority of his minutes in midfield
One guy won’t be at the club next season, the other is a very talented youngster who has a big future at the club
If Scott picks weiderman over Hayes to play against Sydney, it’s time to axe Scott. Would be the ultimate short term fix over long term development
He has had a lot of bad team selections since coming over, but that would take the cake
There is no possible reason you would pick weed over Hayes
Brad Scott has killed this kid
Playing him as sub, sometimes only brining him on for 20min at the end
Playing him up forward
Neither of which he is suited for at all
He is a jack viney type. Put him at the centre bounces and watch him shine
Absolutely staggers me that we are playing Shiel...
All the best for the future Dyson. Thank you for your service. Buts it’s a no in terms of giving him a farewell game for me.
Give him a lap of honour before the game, do something cool for him. But to bring him in for a farewell game after not playing VFL just sends a horrible message
I reckon the only chance he has of still being coach in 2026 if he does a proper rebuild like hawthorn did. And clearly communicates with the fans want his plan is and how it will be done
If he tries to do the same thing next season as he has done the previous 2. We won’t get enough wins to...
That’s a great call!
I can’t imagine how bad things would be without Zac.
His teammates have cost him any chance of being AA captain and Brownlow medalist
He is just a superstar, it’s his defensive effort when he doesn’t have the ball that I love the most.
He has picked a team all year to win here and now.
He has had almost no eye on development or the future all season, he has had no selection integrity since he walked in the door
How many players have actually improved since he has come to the club?
How many players have stagnated or gone...
Please stop pushing this guy as sub and as a forward. He is a midfielder. He will do the grunt work and defensive stuff that most of the other mids refuse to do
Out: Shiel.he won’t be here next year, no idea why we keep playing him. A midfield of parish,Shiel and Merrett has never worked no matter how many times we try it
Cox,laverde,Menzie
In: Hobbs into the starting team and takes Shiels spot. Hayes to replace laverde,saad to replace Menzie ,tsatas...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.