Search results for query: *

Without Pendles being best on ground by a mile in the last quarter in the last Grand Final AND his organising the side on field, we don't win (he was 35 at the time) Don't care how he is ranked by the biased usual suspects who are the same trolls in every Collingwood thread, he is the best Pies...

The 2nd half of the season was a write off,. we were picking from 26 players at one stage for a few rounds and the rest of the forward line was decimated. When Cox and Elliott came back we beat the premiers who had everything to play for, probably should have beaten the Swans but lost by a point...

He had a poor year? That is your opinion. He was good when we most of our forward line back which is why he was head hunted. Very happy to have him in the side. We are lucky we dont have a great list destroyed by a terrible team culture and coach like the demons though. Fancy having the best...

Bingo You also need a coach with a great game plan where the players buy in.

He probably isn't but he was crucial in the centre bounces as a clearance player.

you lost against the pies because you were way too defensive. when the shackles were released it was too late lol Long may be stay .

Well one is subbed as tactics for the future, and the other is subbed because he is too slow. so yes there's a difference

I watch them every week , i would like to think i am an unbiased observer who has a clue. What i really think about the blues is that they should win the premiership with their list, but they have a moron defensively minded coach who doesn't want to take risks and holds them back. Not...

point is if he was rated as at least a b grade player by your own club he would never be dropped.

But but but Hewitt still got dropped and started sub. still confused that he is best 22 in that case..

but was Kennedy taking Hewitts spot? i am confused...

whos spot is Jagga taking?

complete garbage analysis. There are so many more factors to a season.

uhh it means you are using different sample sizes. So he got a few possies early in the season. great. didnt help you in the end did he

he also got subbed off a lot when we were ahead to save himself cos of his age ,. good tactics, worked out in the finals dont you reckon?

he played 15 games vs 26 lol good one Walshy

well one finished 4th in a best and fairest in a premiership year. and the other one... at least he is getting a decent pay cheque..

A borderline best 22 player is never better than a c grader if he cannot get a game every week in a side that finished 8th

Lipinski McReery Cox (but he is there for our structure and will never be dropped) Sidey is now but is worth playing for his experience. Howe Frampton Markov WHE From the 2023 team Adams and Noble were also C graders

lets not forget they also lost that game

this has been your problem since you hit rock bottom lol you guys just cant see it

We have heaps, Maybe 10 or so from the premiership side but they do their job. We have a few D and E players too.

Hewitt for one. I could find players in all sides that had one of those games. But fact is he is borderline best 22 in a team that won 13 games last year. so C grade

Fancy recruiting players who don't fit the side. I know. lets go through the draft and pick some more

getting a lot of possessions is pretty meaningless unless he does something with them

he started sub and was borderline best 22 a lot of the season. Sounds like a C grade player to me.

Pies a lock for top 4 (hard to win a premiership no matter how good you are). Blues 4 to 8

Wow the 7 sides that finished above them last year must be full of a plus graders

Out Gallagher in Walsh , not many players recent players in there though is there...

is Hewitt in the best 22?