Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. ScrappyDo

    Preview 2024 AFL Season, Round 17: St Kilda saints v Sydney Swans, Sunday 7th of July 3:20pm AEST, Marvel Stadium

    I think he's just having a down year. Over did it in the off-season too. With Max out we might see a bit of last year come out again.
  2. ScrappyDo

    Preview 2024 AFL Season, Round 17: St Kilda saints v Sydney Swans, Sunday 7th of July 3:20pm AEST, Marvel Stadium

    Windhager is king of the kids but Wardlaw is a bit of a freak and we're highly unlikely to get someone like him. Our youth core is highly driven and will self perpetuate if given the right support. Pou requires a slightly different lens, being still very young and a long way from physically...
  3. ScrappyDo

    Discussion The Random Discussion Thread

    Funny that. Most Aussies under 50 these days couldn’t wipe their own arses if they tried so maybe they're on to something we don't know about..
  4. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    POTY. If we had league average for kicking into the goal post then we'd hve 2-3 more wins. League average accuracy would be another 2-3 wins again. We are not so far off as is being made out.
  5. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    You'd want a fair amount than 1 end of first round. Tough **** for Steele, he's contracted on big money so it would want to be a game changing deal for us.
  6. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    Yes but not all at once. Pou I'd leave another week till he backs it up.
  7. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    I just think the rest happens when we can offer a good product. Until that happens it's little value making a fuss about it.
  8. ScrappyDo

    The Way out? of this mess

    Membrey seems cooked, but it's probably mentally. The rest will be ok.
  9. ScrappyDo

    Preview 2024 AFL Season, Round 17: St Kilda saints v Sydney Swans, Sunday 7th of July 3:20pm AEST, Marvel Stadium

    It harder matters who's called up, we're completely cooked now. Against Sydney I'd rather Cordy and Membrey to insulate the kids from a spanking.
  10. ScrappyDo

    The Way out? of this mess

    With this recognition, why are you now so dark on Lyon. Senior players: Crouch - best clearance player, out injured Membrey - senior KPF, cooked Ross - cooked Jones - cooked Doogs - injuries Jweb - 7 weeks suspension Stocker - injured Wood - x weeks injured Butts - x weeks injured...
  11. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    Yeah, look. Even when playing better footy we bombed every marquee game opportunity so that's neither here not there. We haven't attracted a top end player since Sammy and Gtrain, so that's nither here nor there also. If we're not a competitive top 8-10 side, well of course we wont play finals...
  12. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    I agree to some extent with this, but l want to ask what do you mean by "turn it around"? Is it win/loss, game style, vibe or all of the above? I'm running on the assumption we don't attract a real meaningful trade target and will only have organic growth to really on.
  13. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    It's a bloody hard call. I'd say if he says he's happy then we put a 1 year extension in front of him. If he doesn't sign it, trade.
  14. ScrappyDo

    Autopsy Round 16, 2024: St.Kilda v Port Adelaide

    Haven't watched the game and not gonna. But. Our old crew in Ross, Membrey and Jones have gone off a cliff so didn't play. Our FB is injured and didn't play. Our FF apparently has a saw knee and is in a slump. Our wonderkind Chito is all out of sorts. Reality is that our team is in pretty poor...
  15. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    The fact we didn't ask for compo after losing Paddy, Hugh, Robbo, Koby in 18 months was poor by us. There was another IIRC.
  16. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    I absolutely agree with this strategy. The AFL will set their dogs on us but we should scream louder each time. If they get properly vindictive and screw us with fixturing or FA compo then we scream louder again and say "see l told you all so". Then we scream louder again.
  17. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    I wasn't aiming at him, he just took it personally is all. Nor was it arrogant. Kenty at the utmost.
  18. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    $750k were the reports at last contract renewal. Media are full of shit.
  19. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    Jesus you really are unhinged at the moment. Go on, tell us what standards you're gonna hold the club to, then let us know how you got on with it after you're done. Make sure to post a training report while you're at it. You go get'm tiger!!
  20. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    Mitch has burst speed for sure. He's also clocked up big distances when played in the middle. Put him in there and leave him to learn.
  21. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    This may be so but we've been a side with no backbone for a generation and building that is bloody hard work. They're drafting their arse off and taking the heat for losses whilst installing fight in those that can hack it. The piont being it puts us in with a shot one day and it's now or never...
  22. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    He was supreme in 2 seasons. Just fell to bits
  23. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    Billings had more talent than 95% of other players.
  24. ScrappyDo

    The Way out? of this mess

    But they told us this would happen. That's why people accept it. Because they said it would happen.
  25. ScrappyDo

    The Way out? of this mess

    I just can't see it happening. I think there's a big question mark over Lenny stepping back and what exactly BJ and Harvey are bringing to the table, but the real question is who can we get? But is it the assistants or RTB? Or the players?
  26. ScrappyDo

    The Way out? of this mess

    We've been soft rebuilding anyway. King Stocker Henry Sharman Hammer Byrnes Nas Windy Chito Pou Wilson Garcia Schoonamonster Heath Keeler JVE Hotton* Collard Hastie McLennan Allison* Irish Hall That's a lot of youth right there. Obviously we need more top end but you can't say they're not trying.
  27. ScrappyDo

    The Way out? of this mess

    We'll get nothing for Membrey. End of 3rd round at best but odds on he retires if he doesn't stay.
  28. ScrappyDo

    The Way out? of this mess

    I dunno, there's not much more backwards to be had. Of the players mentioned, none have had much contribution this year. If next year Pou finds his feet and there's growth from the 2nd year players it'll be on par but I'm happy to see the old guard moved on at this point. Actually, today we...
  29. ScrappyDo

    News 2024 St.Kilda Media Thread

    Wow. What incredible intellect that must have taken.
  30. ScrappyDo

    List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread

    I'm no fan but we'd be mad to trade him. He's still young and he actually wants to play at StKilda so its a matter of finding a way to keep him out of his shell. I don't understand why the coaches aren't making changes to how he plays but now even the media are catching on to what we've been...
Back
Top