ppl here really harsh on Smith. Every player's dream to win premiership. Who is closer to the trophy, who's in better position to win it in next 3 years, Dogs or Cats? have your say
and I am not sold on him chasing big money, chasing longer contract, or get no spot in our mid. He's only 24 yo.no...
We dont
Buss draft doesn't show we value, tend of being forced. stock is bare and aging. He might be KPF/ruck one day, who knows
Jones is good but old, and yeah he came cheap. I doubt we'd trade him in from Blues shall he accepted the COVID jab policy
Naughton is prime example, top10 defender...
Does the club really value KPD position in Bevo era? Can't see this changes anytime soon. Resigning both of them is to make sure we have enough (quantity) but not quality. 3 talls at the back show the evidence that no confidence in our KPD stocks to intercept mark
I'm not sold on persisting Keath+Bruce. Gardner is on the borderline. JOD is not KPD, at least not ready yet. Same bracket as Busslinger, not next year. I'm about to see what he can bring up in AFL level
Cheap stopgap, that reminds me that someone said here we're keen on Tomlinson
Not promising...
Defender trade rumors are circulating but don't see us in the mix. I'd be very disappointed if we don't upgrade KPD stock this trade. Jones 33, and can't expect another season with Gardner, Keath and Bruce
I feel for buku. Only 1 game but he just way far off. JOD is already ahead of him as 3rd defender and soon buss. Lobb is certainly back next game and darcy not too far. He’d end up as young, tried several postion team finally gave up.
There is always doubt we'll win/not, but in all uncertainties I have no doubt that Bevo will not strike the poor innocent whiteboard with his leftie today
Godogs
2021 vs 2023: core players basically same (give and take). Those 3 disastrous weeks due to Bruce ACL
I kind of tempted to think we performed really well due to shorter quarter time in 2021, which makes our brand of footy sustain 4 quarters week in week out. Our ball movement's much better and...
Was the reason GC packed up Bowes+pick 7 to create cap space for him and Rowell to re sign next year?
You never know but hard to see we can snatch him though
In all seriousness, I do think we have a good combination of age/experience in all areas now with the inclusion of Jones/Lobb
Too old in defensive, but again high expectation we get top young KPD in the next few drafts
Mid: prime age, Bont/Mcrae/Treloar+Libba+Baz/Westie definitely not against...
Since Cats won the premiership, the prime age for premiership window is shifted much higher. So we're definitely in the window...no excuse then next year and lets keep Martin for that sake
TOB played 3rd tall in few games last season, behind Gardner,Keath/Cordy. Biggest problem was Keath's form dipped far and Cordy...you know. If Keath fits and fires on all cylinders, then combination of Jones, Keath and Gardner would be quite solid. Khamis,Darcy,TOB are depth. Really hope we got...
We might pay over for Lobb and paid under for Dunks, so what...big deal. With Lobb+Jones IN, I can see better team balance to start with
+ draft hand
1st round (11) small forward / KPD
2nd round (21 or 30) KPD / small forward
F1 , so 2 1st round next year
1 more senior assistant coach please...
what is his value now I am wondering :think:?
Sammy said 2 1st round picks
Brisbane said 1 picksh & chips
BF said PSD - ZERO
Mike said???
My said - I follow consensus of BF experts
buckle your seatbelts boys, we gonna have a fun ride. Honestly GC should really poke into this saga. Higher chance to get the deal done. Dunks would prefer GC rather than PSD North or West Coast I suppose, they're pretty much in the same bracket ladder positions though
He's as 1st option for our defense tells how shambolic this area is. He can be very serviceable with alike of Darcy Moore stand beside. Fingers crossed to get genuine KPD with leadership but my fingers feel so numb been crossed too long waiting
who cares about the result, season cooked. if we drag through this, it just extends life for another week, next 3 weeks would be horror. Main attraction tonight to see Bruce 1st game after long laid down, Khamis back at D50, life without Naughton, twin towers Sweet English men, and until which...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.