Search results for query: *

Wouldn't that prevent us from trading our F1 next year ...(unless we get another second in from somewhere)

It's quite clear that you're going to spin every Richmond trade into what Richmond wanted all along regardless of outcome.

You said he was living in FAIRLY land.

In all the Richmond fans hypothesis, if we don't take Shai Bolton we DEFINITELY miss finals. And Shai would have taken us over the top. Such fabricated scenarios to suit your selling points. It's like a car salesman telling you the car you buy from him will definitely get you laid.

So you admit Peter Bell is fair?

Doesn't really help progress the trade though ...does it?

Based on the above what do we do for just Bolton - if Baker gets to West Coast?

Pick 20 probably...practically a second rounder as it is

Then he nominated. Do you think we REALLY want him after he chose West Coast?

"We're not trading next years firsts". Wouldn't even mind offering 10&11 for Kossie.

We should trade 10 with Melbourne..Leave 11 and 18 on the table...and see how the landscape changes.

I have no doubts that's what has happened. A Bit Dusty was conjecturing that two years he stated he was very happy and he didn't want to move ever..and I was just responding with that there are a number of factors that can influence a player's happiness at the club 18 months after signing a big...

Was Damien Hardwick there at that time? And McQualter? Wouldn't be the first time a player has wanted out over a coaching setup change.

So would I

Of course Freo know this. So do Richmond. As much as I wouldn't mind adding another Brayshaw/Cerra scenario to our list I think the chances are this gets done. It's just haggling and I just hope we walk away happy.

You speak in definitives as if you're some sort of yellow and black Nostradamas. We were half a win outside finals this year with one of the youngest teams in the comp. Most of those young players have just signed long term deals and we should (notice how I don't insist) be a better team next...

....where he wont go anywhere?

Not when we finished half a win out of the eight and you finished half a win out of .....nope...still 18th

Good idea....if you had it. Pick 1 or 6 are still an option at the moment

and there's a lot of noise about Knobel extending

So ... it's not up to both teams to get it done? If, as speculated, Bolton wants to live in WA and not return to Richmond that's a discount compared to if he was perfectly happy there. He's got a 4 year contract (which we know are rarely worth the paper their written on but we'll play along)...

He came 9th in the B&F ...which isn't where he'd want to be but its still better than half the team. He wasn't the only one to have a down year in 2024. I think we've yet to see the best of him

I don't think the Jury's still out at all. I was concerned in his first 3 games. Think he's proven the doubters wrong. He's not a full time ruck and when he gets played there (when Darcy's crook) you know we're not getting to see the best of him.

Luke Jackson? Jeremy Sharp? Jordan Clarke? James Aish? Chad Warner?

I hope he's not offered. I could see him getting offered as steak knives and talent is talent. You are in a rebuild after all.

You want draft picks....for players. Knobel is a ruckman with a huge upside. Way ahead of the curve for his position. I don't want him to go but I daresay you couldn't pick up as good a ruckman in the draft. And he's only 19

I generally avoid talking to Eagles fans.

Thing is.... we won't know the intricacies of any deal. We won't be made aware of any salary covered ...or not ...so any deal is going to make the fans of one of the two sides ...unhappy. Long and the short of it is...I would hope 11 & 18 would be enough but if it's more I'll assume were in a...

Not sure you need to be worried about that. Let's hope Yze finds a way upwards eh?

Think that's a bit spensy docker911