Search results for query: *

I know I was beneficiary so this may not hold weight but I think it adds unnecessary complication for something that rarely happens and it's just luck of draw, it was still a risk as a) O'Donnell is a crap forward and often these moves result in defender kicked nothing anyway and b) when Keith...

GC won't be playing finals, only 4 home games left all against decent opponents in Collingwood Brisbane Port and Melbourne and can't win away

He came 4th in best and fairest last year, was hardly ordinary. This year he has fallen off cliff so bad I don't even see how anyone takes him with his contract unless we punt him as salary dump, but it's clear he can't play in this side anymore.

I wish he was a zero sum footballer, he has been a negative liability for 8-9 weeks now

ODonnell x3 McNeil x2

5 Bont 4 Treloar 3 Darcy 2 Dale 1 Jones 3 Darcy 2 Sanders 1 JUH

Darcy JUH Gallagher Treloar Daniel

5 L. Jones 4 Bont 3 Treloar 2 JUH 1 Richards 3 JUH 2 Sanders 1 Frejah

Richards x3 Garcia Scott

5 Treloar 4 Richards 3 Naughton 2 Harmes 1 Darcy

So he has played every game when not injured in 2 and a bit years, plays one as sub and that is your argument that he is not in best 22 and would have had same opportunity? That has got to be the weakest argument and use of fact gymnastics I've seen in a long time. Maybe we can get Crisp as he...

How has he not been in Collingwood's best 22? he has played pretty much every week since he arrived there

Should never see another game where Bont Libba Treloar take every centre bounce, hasn't and doesn't work as is predictable and wears them down using same combinations all the time, must continue to be mixed up with Macrae Richards Garcia Cody Sanders Gallagher

5 Dale 4 Naughton 3 JJ 2 Treloar 1 Macrae

Naughton West Vandermeer x3

It's St Kilda so it's not like a winning score is going to be big with the way they play, 11-12 goals will probably win this.

5 JUH 4 Libba 3 Darcy 2 West 1 Treloar

Makes much more sense, they had Sanders on big screen as sub before. Agree he has been ordinary this year

Sanders sub, weird selecting 9 defenders, 8 assuming Williams plays on wing is still 1 too many

Vandermeer Williams English Weightman JUH

Macrae should play next week, good chance to find some form against bunny side with midget slow midfielders. Out Daniel In Garcia or Harmes

5 Libba 4 Bont 3 Jones 2 Treloar 1 Darcy 3 Darcy 2 Sanders 1 Gallagher

Update to Vandermeer Williams Bont English Naughton

Vandermeer English Bont Naughton Weightman

5 Treloar 4 English 3 Naughton 2 Vandermeer 1 Williams

Darcy JUH Naughton Weightman Vandermeer

5 Bont 4 Libba 3 Weightman 2 Jones 1 Richards

dogwatch can you add me into your spreadsheet :)

JUH Naughton Darcy Weightman West

Hey dogwatch forgot about this last week, put me in thanks