Search results for query: *

Did M Gardiner play?

Sorry for jumping on your site,but watching last nights game,couldnt get over how much he reminded of his uncle?Peter who played for Rich? and Oakleigh who I watched often in my younger years,Tall rangy left footer CHF ,kick a goal from a mile out ,but miss an easy one,a typical Cloke hard at...

Rix and Fiora ,good fit for Melb ,take what we can get Birss was in good form when dropped,WHY ask our super coach cause I am stuffed if I can work out how some,Fiora,can get a game ahead of him

Best mark I have ever seen was by Trevor Barker,at moorabbin against Hawks,1980?,on radio on way home H Beitzel said best he ever seen,unfortunately there was no footage,but 1 step then standing on opponents shoulders in goal square Great player that Barker guy

D Baldock I Stewart T Lockett T Barker R Harvey Ditterich Winmar Burke unlucky

I was there that day,although we lost and JF got reported,everyone was in awe of that kick ,whenever he got the ball regardless where on the field after that the cry went up HAVE A SHOT RIP

his dog sh*t on RL lawn,Fiona picked it up!

Drop Sidebottom,Bob Pascoe Don Discher Allan Morrow are 3 that spring to mind

2 old sayings-Got to be in it to win it--Finals are funny games.Love your optimism

IMO rl has a defensive mindset ,which we needed to get more into our game,but he seems to have taken the team TOO far down this track ,and now we need to get the balance right,dont think he is capable of turning it around now.Simple fact is few if any have actually improved under rl playing this...

My pointis that Slattery actually impeaded fev in mid air and did not have eyes on the ball .Fev free kick ? Sure it was a sickening blow,hope the boy is allright,as i have not got a replay at hand only going from memory,would be interested to hear umpire interputation as to why its a free ,if...

Can someone please explain why a free kick was awarded to essendon when fev flew for the mark ,surely the ess player went back and jumped into him ,taking away any chance of marking the ball,couragous yes but really he interfeared with the player who only had eyes on the ball in a marking...

No more re cycled players.thankyou ,unless you got a Ablett etc

IMO reportable...no free kick...yes?If afl are saying all head contact is reportable why do we see players coming off each week under blood rule ,usually head face region yet most dont result in reports,its getting confusing,

Sorry mate may have got it wrong,but if the cap fits.hey

very very frustrating

played good football against poor and tanking sides,so we were good enough second half last year ,but not good enough now,WHY?

RL now saying we lack youth and enthusiam,,would have though he fitted these requirements

At least the coaches can do something about it ,we cant .Whether they know what to do ,thats debateable

YO YO back in the ones next week dropped week after, up and down like a YO YO, really all you can go on is what they show on the ground ,fair enough vfl but why he and Birss where dropped ???

Though he was ok today ,do agree i think he is not quite there yet ,plenty of upside with him but good hands very good kick for big man.IMO

Armitage bog,Birss very good as well,just goes to show how big a joke RL is.if fiora runs out there tonight that will mean we really are the laughing stock of the comp.

Anyone who has played any football knows what can happen once they cross the white line ,soft no,mentally soft yes gut running prepared to make a contest etc yes soft

Your not telling me something i dont already know,Although wouldnt agree about Plugger,anyway we dont want any more following the saints at least is good for the skin,makes it thicker,good luck.......except this week

Never said i was upset with the decision,but we are always being told head contact is a no no,and you must admit he certainly didnt have eyes on the ball,last week i wrote how i though Murphy[footscray]didnt deserve to be rubbed out and he was imo goodes was worse than murphy,remember we played...

please take the THREE of them back,all duds

protected species

Yes we evolved into a finals side under GT,now we have evolved into a very average side under RL.Facts are facts

Got to admire your enthusiam,but really RL is still trying to work out how our guys play or how to play them,surely we didnt get him to take us backwards and that is what has happened

Who on our list have improved under RL?-not many if any .Dont believe GT is the answer but this is some of the worst football i have seen from a saints side for many years,no one can argue with that.I have sat on the fence over RL now i have seen enoughRemember this is a top 4 side pre season...