Fully agree, my tongue in cheek comment was more because I still consider him injured until he can prove otherwise. He's in his 8th year and hasn't played a game of AFL since 2019, which was the end of a 3 year run which still only yielded 41 games. The most games he's ever played in a season...
For me it's all guns blazing time... I think Sydney are a formidable unit and we would be best to revert to our more usual structure.
I have to say that I like what Jimmae pointed out about Walsh playing more outside on Sunday. He looked much better than he has recently, so happy to plonk him...
Nail, head.... This is something I really don't like about us humans, our ego's are our biggest obstacle. Apportioning blame only serves our own ego's.
and yet I noticed that you didn't vote for Newnes (whom is in your very own best 22) in the Mids vote.... did you even vote for him in the forwards?? Reason I point this out is because you repeatedly tell EVERYBODY that Newnes, Gibbons and Newman will all play if fit....
Your stubbornness is intolerable, why can't you jist stick to the task at hand. That is to pick a consensus best 22, not who you know* will be in the team come rnd 1. Lighten up a little and give others some space to have an opinion.
We have 21 players picked, we pick the last player based on...
Yes, without reading the thread again (time poor and shocking memory😜) I may have been responding to someone's suggestion (Arr0w?) to only vote on the players with the highest votes but were left out... Does that make sense I'm a bit delirious lol
Wholeheartedly agree, Phillips is definitely a temptation but I think that replacing Levi is paramount. I believe that many under value his worth in terms of structure and versatility. TDK should be our long term ruck, Pitto is our reserve. We really need a ruck forward in the mould of...
I agree, should be open to all players, that way we can get the right balance for OUR team. Example, if all of Charlie, Harry, Levi, and Jack find spots in OUR team then we don't want the next highest if it happens to be say Mitch McG...
Just my thoughts, I know I don't have a lot to say around...
Seems to have a lot to work with, however do you think this type of player would be a priority for our list..?
Sounds like a Tigers type player, we could use someone like that but is the price too high..?
100% agree post is spot on. Picked the same players for exactly the same reasoning. Just on Thomas, yes he played well last year but seriously never want to see him exiting HB with a dinky check side because he has no left.
For those that are a little superstitious, I got very excited when I read both of these bluemours. They each had either exactly 108 likes or "108 others like" which to many millions is an extremely auspicious number... Just saying maybe it's an omen man.....
Maybe not such bad news after all...
Blue becomes local hero in Irish Gaelic game - http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-09-26/blue-byrne-becomes-local-hero-in-irish-gaelic-game
Seems like it's all legit and approved by the club..
Anyone got a handle on where Mitch Maguire might get picked up? Looks like the type of player that could impact for us straight away playing forward and midfield.
Mitch Maguire
The competition's MVP leader before voting was closed off to the public, Maguire is a standout candidate. Described...
I don't understand the logic of your thinking here. It's not like we're missing out on anything, in fact I see it as an advantage because we get a top 5 draft pick 1 year early.
You say next year we may be bottom 3, I say the benefits of getting the player early outweighs the possibility of...
Was going to write almost the same thing, the only thing I would add is that because of the point you made his value to us increases. Similarly his value to GC would be greater because they really need a big mature body in their forward line.
Normally, I think yes his value would be similar to...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.