1st Test Border Gavaskar Trophy November 22-26 1350hrs @ Perth Stadium

Who will win?

  • Australia

    Votes: 31 83.8%
  • India

    Votes: 5 13.5%
  • Draw

    Votes: 1 2.7%

  • Total voters
    37
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

I know others may disagree but IMHO if there needs to be a scapegoat for this performance then I’d be axing Smith before Labuschagne.

Smith is older and we need to regenerate the team, his form has been as bad if not worse than Lab over the past 18-24 months, and he’s done the #4/opener/#4 shuffle which I think was all quite selfish and done primarily to preserve his place in the team.

He’ll always be a legend but the time has come.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

😂 never thought the day would come.. he averaged 63 for so long… in free fall now.. sad but not unusual for a mid 30s legend.. probably didn’t help him tweaking shit in his peak trying to make the T20 side.
Yeah.

Average has plummeted. Gets caught on the crease all the time.

Done.
 
Smith should of went when they decided to move him to opener. Sad to see him go out like this. These cricketers are always insanely selfish and stay in the side far too long because they know the selectors are soft *****
 
Cummins is a shit captain though i think.

so not that massive.

What other captain is letting Marnus do what he did yesterday with the ball?


Not even saying it's wrong but just would shock me to see them drop him as skipper 1 test in given the record he has/
 
Just enjoy Head, Marsh should provide some entertainment too.

marsh is getting sized up right now by Bumrah.

Might not be around long.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Smith should of went when they decided to move him to opener. Sad to see him go out like this. These cricketers are always insanely selfish and stay in the side far too long because they know the selectors are soft *****
Speaking of openers, is weird the selectors seem to not even consider it a specialist position for some time. Putting Finch in even though he'd never opened in FC, McSweeney in despite never opening in FC, putting Smith up there in a hail mary when he started struggling.

I don't think Harris is up to Test level, but he is an opener and I think would do a better job of at least seeing off the new ball even if he didn't make many runs ala Geoff Marsh, which should be a priority as opposed to just chucking anyone in without any regard to how opening in a Test is a specific skillset (unless you're pummeling a second tier attack).
 
Not even saying it's wrong but just would shock me to see them drop him as skipper 1 test in given the record he has/

As soon as Cummins starting his eco warrior shit he should have been turfed as Captain.

Worry about cricket - no one cares what else you do.
 
As good as Smith is and he is a champion, in a stronger era of Test cricket, I reckon he'd have his work cut put against the likes of Wasim Akram, Waqar Younis, Curtly Ambrose and Courtney Walsh.
 
I know others may disagree but IMHO if there needs to be a scapegoat for this performance then I’d be axing Smith before Labuschagne.

Smith is older and we need to regenerate the team, his form has been as bad if not worse than Lab over the past 18-24 months, and he’s done the #4/opener/#4 shuffle which I think was all quite selfish and done primarily to preserve his place in the team.

He’ll always be a legend but the time has come.
Should drop them both. I’d rather a 15 run average from a new player than from 2 of our supposed greats
 

Remove this Banner Ad

1st Test Border Gavaskar Trophy November 22-26 1350hrs @ Perth Stadium

Back
Top