2009 Trade Discussion- Part 7

[SM]

wait until balla plays 2 games so you have more of an idea on what to do

Then who do I downgrade to in the forward line?

 

[JDWCE]

Looking to trade out Suban but what back? I've got 200k in the bank since i just got Muston for Collins. Cheers

maybe pearce as has been promoted but there isnt many good looking back reserves thats for sure, maybe leave it as suban should play regularly

 

[carlton__09]

Ok I have traded Robinson > Muston I now need to decide my second trade.
I have 240 k in the bank.

Option 1
Suban > Mackie/ Fisher

Option 2
Hasleby > Kornes/ Salopek

Option 3
Ziebell > O'Keefe

Option 1 was my plan for a while but now that Hodge is back and Grima and Broughton are named it is not as important now. Also don't know who will be better out of Mackie/Fisher.
Option 2 seems like a bargain and I am planning on getting Bartel next week but not sure who is better and whether or not to do this trade this week.
Option 3 is because Ziebell isn't going to rise anymore in money and O'Keefe is only going up but this is for my last forward position so not sure whether to wait and get someone like Riewoldt/ Pav later.

Opinions would be great

 

[JDWCE]

Then who do I downgrade to in the forward line?

maybe just wait a week or get gia instead next week, otherwise you might as well go brown to balla caus garlett hasnt made enough cash

 

[JDWCE]

Ok I have traded Robinson > Muston I now need to decide my second trade.
I have 240 k in the bank.

Option 1
Suban > Mackie/ Fisher

Option 2
Hasleby > Kornes/ Salopek

Option 3
Ziebell > O'Keefe

Option 1 was my plan for a while but now that Hodge is back and Grima and Broughton are named it is not as important now. Also don't know who will be better out of Mackie/Fisher.
Option 2 seems like a bargain and I am planning on getting Bartel next week but not sure who is better and whether or not to do this trade this week.
Option 3 is because Ziebell isn't going to rise anymore in money and O'Keefe is only going up but this is for my last forward position so not sure whether to wait and get someone like Riewoldt/ Pav later.

Opinions would be great

1 unless you really want to cement your forward line now

 

[BluesMan]

Just as my team is looking injury free, Gilbert and NGB decide to have injurys, and motlop decides to stay out. Was gunna do zeibell to gia/didak this week but sinces hes playin im gunna have to go motlop to gia didak!
Will replace gilbert on field for grima, and NGB for warren. God my injurys never stop. Will also go robinson to muston.

So should i get gia or didak??

 

[carlton__09]

1 unless you really want to cement your forward line now

Cheers I am new to this site and have posted occassionaly and rarely do I ever get a reply so cheers.

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

Would Ellis average 90+ this year. Is he a keeper? Or is better to ignore the 40K and go with a reliable option such as Lockyer and Mackie.

 

[carlton__09]

Just as my team is looking injury free, Gilbert and NGB decide to have injurys, and motlop decides to stay out. Was gunna do zeibell to gia/didak this week but sinces hes playin im gunna have to go motlop to gia didak!
Will replace gilbert on field for grima, and NGB for warren. God my injurys never stop. Will also go robinson to muston.

So should i get gia or didak??

I would get Gia now if you are definately gonna cop a zero but if you're not wait a week or so to get Didak.

 

[JDWCE]

Would Ellis average 90+ this year. Is he a keeper? Or is better to ignore the 40K and go with a reliable option such as Lockyer and Mackie.

personally i would go ellis, average is 67 atm but its very deceiving as two of his games were when injury occured. Plus he can only get better as hawthorn find some form as well as being a high draft pick

 

[Frankie23]

Rd 11.
Robinson >>> Muston
C.Cornes >>> Lockyer

Rd 12.
Krak>>> Gia.
Suban >>> Pearce

Rd13.
Otten >>> Bartel/Ablett.
Ziebell >>> Franklin

That will leave me with 7 trades left...

 

[JDWCE]

Cheers I am new to this site and have posted occassionaly and rarely do I ever get a reply so cheers.

i know what you mean, especially this thread gets pretty hectic once the teams come out

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

I am really struggling to pick between Newman, Ellis and Gram. I think they all have room for improvement. I might lean slightly towards Newman for stability. How would you rank these three? I've already discarded Mundy and Harding (just not keen on them).

 

[quirky]

suppose i have to get muston,

10 trades - 340k in the bank

my current plan is to get muston for ziebell, that will net me about another 180k which means i'd have 520k in the bank

would you do that?

or do a piss weak downgrade from cockie, it would only get me another 50k but it would mean i would have another bench player, and i'd still have 390k in the bank, ziebell could play out the year or i could just upgrade him later

bearing in mind some of that money will be spent on an otten upgrade


goddard, cornes, mackie, drummond, adcock, houlihan, grimes
(suban, broughton)

ablett, gibbs, selwood. rich, otten, ziebell (hartlett, cockie)

cox
mcintosh (pyke, spencer)

riewoldt, s.johnson, pavlich, deledio, franklin ,higgins ,sidebottom (walker, hentschel)

 

[bombers own]

Had my trades set, but now i'm tempted to get Hodge.

Option 1-Hill+Chad--->Milburn+Fisher/Hodge+60k

Option 2-Hill+Chad--->Fisher+Hodge.

Which is the better option?

 

[JDWCE]

Rd 11.
Robinson >>> Muston
C.Cornes >>> Lockyer

Rd 12.
Krak>>> Gia.
Suban >>> Pearce

Rd13.
Otten >>> Bartel/Ablett.
Ziebell >>> Franklin

That will leave me with 7 trades left...

and you'll defintly have the money to do all that? if so id say do it and leave 7 trades for injuries

 

[JDWCE]

I am really struggling to pick between Newman, Ellis and Gram. I think they all have room for improvement. I might lean slightly towards Newman for stability. How would you rank these three? I've already discarded Mundy and Harding (just not keen on them).

Ellis>>>>>>>>Newman>Gram

 

[senrulzisback]

Thinking of doing:

Chornes --> Goddard
Dangerfield --> Muston

Next I will do Whitecross --> Kornes and M Brown --> Ballantyne

Then I will have about 125k left.

Week after I will trade Raines to a player around 330k, and trade Muston to Anthony.

My last upgrade, finishing my side, will be Sidebottom --> Didak. this will leave me 5 trades for LTI's, and make my side:
Goddard, Fisher, Enright, 330k, Hodge, Scotland, Lockyer
Gibbs, Selwood, Haselby, Priddis, Pearce, Kornes
Cox, McIntosh
Didak, Goodwin, O'Keefe, N.G.Brown, J.Brown, Franklin, Higgins

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

I went with...

Beams-->Muston
Chad-->Enright

Wasn't going to trade Chad but now that Gilbert is out I decided to do it.

 

[Notorious_29]

trades are pretty set now. with hodge named i will hold onto chad for another week to asses his injury.

trades this week

krakouer ---> ballantyne
ziebell ---> deledio

now have 180k in bank

next week (barring injuries)

chad ---> goddard
rich ---> kane kornes

 

[swans4eva]

Is anyone here not getting Muston???
Im really interested to know...

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Is anyone here not getting Muston???
Im really interested to know...

I think everyone is.

 

[Piikeyyy]

I think everyone is.

I'm not

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

I'm not

Ok, well practically everyone.

 

[twarby]

Is anyone here not getting Muston???
Im really interested to know...

i reckon 80-90 % of Dters would have him after this week..
but i reckon half of them are rushing a cow like beams/barham etc to get him which isnt the right thing to do.
im trading him for otten who i think has just about peaked