2013 Player/s X versus Y

[rocker_oz33]

Kyle Martin v Tom Mitchell? Cant decide who to bring in. I am bringing in Hrovat next week after the bye

Seeing that Hrovt only got 60 points V port I'm not sure about him anymore.As already said in these threads KMartin mature age player and Mitchell also spend few seasons at the swans V's hrovt first year rookie also boyd and cooney to come back.
OR wait a week and see how they go martin on the bubble next week while mitchell will be bubble boy after hes bye.

 

[DeeWong6996]

Travis Cloke at 450k or Andrew Walker at 500k or any R13 forward. Playing the ladder leader in R12 and a squib in R13 so that's the reasoning behind that.

 

[Krujan]

Travis Cloke at 450k or Andrew Walker at 500k or any R13 forward. Playing the ladder leader in R12 and a squib in R13 so that's the reasoning behind that.

I'm going Cloke, Pies have an easy block of games coming up over the next 7 weeks (with only 2 tough games) where as Carlton have 4 tough games coming up.

 

[toxic]

Travis Cloke at 450k or Andrew Walker at 500k or any R13 forward. Playing the ladder leader in R12 and a squib in R13 so that's the reasoning behind that.

If Walker plays tonight then Walker EASILY

 

[esorhali]

Bring in SJ or Nic Nat?

 

[toxic]

Bring in SJ or Nic Nat?

Stevie JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ

 

[DT_35]

Nic Nat will destroy us this week. 50 Hitouts & 5+ goals

 

[The Bear]

Heppell or Hibberd?

 

[LukeH]

Hope you went Heppell Bear - Hibberd getting more attention now so will have to learn to deal with that over the next few weeks.

It's time to bid adieu to JOM for me, A Swallow, Swan or S Mitchell to complete my starting midfield? Other 7 are: GAJ, Pendlebury, Watson, J Selwood, JPK, Fyfe & Dangerfield. Swan's hit rock bottom price wise, Mitchell racking it up at half-back but might cop a rest later on, and North tend to come good as the year goes on.

Not too fussed about byes or overall (am sitting top 2/3 in all my leagues), as Round 13 I'm already stuffed with 13 absences, and only Kommer along with the aforementioned JOM to axe who have R13 byes.

Any guidance appreciated.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Hope you went Heppell Bear - Hibberd getting more attention now so will have to learn to deal with that over the next few weeks.

It's time to bid adieu to JOM for me, A Swallow, Swan or S Mitchell to complete my starting midfield? Other 7 are: GAJ, Pendlebury, Watson, J Selwood, JPK, Fyfe & Dangerfield. Swan's hit rock bottom price wise, Mitchell racking it up at half-back but might cop a rest later on, and North tend to come good as the year goes on.

Not too fussed about byes or overall (am sitting top 2/3 in all my leagues), as Round 13 I'm already stuffed with 13 absences, and only Kommer along with the aforementioned JOM to axe who have R13 byes.

Any guidance appreciated.

If looking at Swan, do it after round 13 unless you don't mind the carnage.
Another suggestion: Michael Barlow

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Hope you went Heppell Bear - Hibberd getting more attention now so will have to learn to deal with that over the next few weeks.

It's time to bid adieu to JOM for me, A Swallow, Swan or S Mitchell to complete my starting midfield? Other 7 are: GAJ, Pendlebury, Watson, J Selwood, JPK, Fyfe & Dangerfield. Swan's hit rock bottom price wise, Mitchell racking it up at half-back but might cop a rest later on, and North tend to come good as the year goes on.

Not too fussed about byes or overall (am sitting top 2/3 in all my leagues), as Round 13 I'm already stuffed with 13 absences, and only Kommer along with the aforementioned JOM to axe who have R13 byes.

Any guidance appreciated.

Cotchin or Deledio are good options to next week.

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Minson or NN?

 

[Patty Healey]

Minson or NN?

NN

 

[tracygrimshaw]

NN

keeping in mind NN will have one less game than Minson (Nicholls will take Minson's place this week)

 

[Zach Package]

O'Meara to Fyfe this week v JPK after his bye.

Will cost roughly the same and have similar averages after Kennedy's crap outing this week.

Take the fallen uber gun in kennedy? or take fyfe's weak finals run (and another week of him in the team)?

 

[stevebbb]

this is for next week, but i'm thinking about it already lol
my final spot in defence
a lot of things to consider... their scores this week, their run home, injury/rest concerns, POD %

Duffield, Ibbotson, Hanley, Malceski, Hurn, Thompson, Burgoyne, Hartlett
some of the players in the list aren't even worth considering, but i'm putting them all out there

thoughts?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Cotchin or Fyfe?

Who would you predict to score more for the remainder of 2013?

 

[toxic]

Cotchin or Fyfe?

Who would you predict to score more for the remainder of 2013?

Strangely Fyfe

 

[KardiniaPark]

Strangely Fyfe

I'd say Cotchin. $70K cheaper than the start of the year, the bye will do him the world of good. I'm expecting 120 from here on in. I still worry about Fyfe getting injured. I've also gone Barlow ahead of him.

 

[Jmac2225]

Griffen v Mitchell v any premo.

Already have GAJ, Pendles, Cotch and Fyfe

 

[toxic]

I'd say Cotchin. $70K cheaper than the start of the year, the bye will do him the world of good. I'm expecting 120 from here on in. I still worry about Fyfe getting injured. I've also gone Barlow ahead of him.

I already have Barlow (god bless his soul) but Freo's run is gold - Fyfe is a goal kicking mid, reckon both will basically end up averaging the same from here in but Fyfe's finals run is good -
But there will always be the Fyfe getting injured tag attached

 

[Feerits Elf]

Cotchin v Barlow?

If Barlow - 12 scores from Barlow, or 11 from Kieren Jack (plus a score from Staker/BenKen this week)?

 

[tracygrimshaw]

I will probably have 20 players playing, so who to put on the field this week?

Swan and tMitchell (bye)
or
bGoodes and O'Meara

 

[toxic]

I will probably have 20 players playing, so who to put on the field this week?

Swan and tMitchell (bye)
or
bGoodes and O'Meara

Goodes and Omeara will outscore Swan - is there a reason you cannot get them all on the field and then you automatically get the best 2 scores

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Goodes and Omeara will outscore Swan - is there a reason you cannot get them all on the field and then you automatically get the best 2 scores

The option is to trade O'Meara to Swan and Laird to tMitchell (Goodes becomes my D7 and would be loopholed with whoever).
Because I have 20 players, O'Meara and Goodes might not score anyway (however Macaffer, kMart and Staker are my other low end players this round) and Swan is almost certain to get a decent score against the Dogs which would be in place of whatever O'Meara gets..

I think I will probably not trade this week (Swan and Laird are set to increase by the same amount this week), as I think the security of having 20 players will outweigh the difference between Swan and O'Meara's score (~30 points?) and so I can probably get Swan next week (or rd14) for essentially the same price.