Carlisle is asking 700k apparently...
List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc
- Thread starter HARKER
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Pick 2 in the PSD.
He is CHB. He's better than Rowe and Jamo only has a couple of years left, max. By the time he's gone, Giles, Jaksch and co will be ready to move on up.
- Apr 16, 2008
- 10,766
- 31,031
- AFL Club
- Carlton
If we did get Carlisle, I could definitely see Jaksch going forward permanently and if we did get Weitering, maybe we trial him forward also. Think I read somewhere he dominates at both ends?
Jaksch to me looks like a far more natural forward. He might be a good 1 on 1 defender, but he looks ordinary with the ball.
When he's in the forward line he can win the ball and kick a goal instead of finding a target
- May 2, 2015
- 1,337
- 4,054
- AFL Club
- Carlton
We should have money in the cap with Warnock, Judd, Yarran and Henderson going. Point is when your a bottom side rebuilding you should have money in the cap. Our player cap expenditure needs to better reflect our position. Id be surprised if we go after Carlisle, especially at 700k
- Sep 14, 2010
- 4,005
- 10,122
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
Is Menzel on the way out? Dogs would be one of many clubs interested. I'd say we'll be reluctant to let go of any of our starters, but something like Hrovat and our second round pick could be offered. Not sure on Menzel's value at all though.
Also re Kreuzer, dogs definite interest. Look for us to offer upwards of 500K on a 4 year deal. Not sure whether thats enough to get you band 1 compo (Possible pick 2 or 3).
Also re Kreuzer, dogs definite interest. Look for us to offer upwards of 500K on a 4 year deal. Not sure whether thats enough to get you band 1 compo (Possible pick 2 or 3).
- Jun 25, 2011
- 2,738
- 4,944
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
Some peeps on here pinning a lot on a KPD that has rarely been seen out of a moon boot.
Hearing Kreuzer possibly not signing has made me crap my pants*
*Metaphorically.
*Metaphorically.
Wouldn't Freo have a look at Henderson? Mcfarlin and Pav both at the end.
Re Carlisle, do not want ant of the taint of the EFC doping program near the CFC. They can all **** off.
If SOS took pick 3 for Kreuzer, would he dangle it at GWS for Patton? Could we work Treolar into the deal with Hendo chucked in?
Just spit balling here.
Re Carlisle, do not want ant of the taint of the EFC doping program near the CFC. They can all **** off.
If SOS took pick 3 for Kreuzer, would he dangle it at GWS for Patton? Could we work Treolar into the deal with Hendo chucked in?
Just spit balling here.
PuffDragon89
All Australian
- Mar 15, 2014
- 878
- 546
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Minnesota Vikings, Man City
Tutt on 2 year deal, not 3 years 
Was an impressive game and hope is there that he can be more than just a list clogger. Biggest strengths are his endurance and speed, something we're lacking right now...build on disposal and tackling efficiencies.
Was an impressive game and hope is there that he can be more than just a list clogger. Biggest strengths are his endurance and speed, something we're lacking right now...build on disposal and tackling efficiencies.
Not a bad ball there. Hendo for Patton and #3 for Trealor.
Get to work on a ruck replacement if you can?
- Jan 17, 2013
- 8,170
- 9,544
- AFL Club
- GWS
We wont be taking Henderson.
- Thread starter
- #6,763
Exactly. What for?
They need defenders. Tim Mohr isn't AFL quality....Phil Davis is injury prone and Patful is 30 years old. They'll be in the finals next year, so need defenders now. Why WOULDN'T they take that?
Menzel signed a contract last year. Not on the table but, apparently, we're having a fire sale.
Your second round pick seems too low, though I do like Hrovat. Not sure too many fans here would even be happy with a 7 pick upgrade from 20 --> 13 if we exchanged picks.I would guess Kreuzer would be on $450K per year currently, so that seems a little low were he to switch clubs.
So we should target Stringer and Bonts as soon as they are out of contract with a big $ offer.
- Sep 14, 2010
- 4,005
- 10,122
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
Hrovat was a pick 21 in 2012, so add that to our second rounder (30ish) and you've got a pretty decent package to work with. H's no slouch either. Rated by the vast majority of our supporters as a good player, with exceptional leadership abilities but we've just got too many coming through that are similar, with Honeychurch, Dale, Webb, Mclean etc. He's at his highest point value wise right now. Would fit well alongside your big bulls in Bell and Cripps, with his tidy disposal, pace and smarts around the ground. Massive upgrade on Tutt, Buckley, Curnow and a few of your other 16-26 ranked players.Menzel signed a contract last year. Not on the table but, apparently, we're having a fire sale.
I would guess Kreuzer would be on $450K per year currently, so that seems a little low were he to switch clubs.
Kreuzer has been offered close to 550k by the dogs on a 4 year contract, so I'd assume we're banking on the fact he'd be keen to jump on the bandwagon just as it starts to kick off with our young fella's.
I think it would. I cant imagine frawley being on much more than that
We should offer Kreuzer 5 years at 750k+ :|
- Sep 14, 2010
- 4,005
- 10,122
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
Very true, mate. Very true.
Menzel to PTA or Adelaide, 1st rounder to Brisbane, Aish to CFC.
That's terrible
Stop please I'm already dead
- Status
