List Mgmt. 2023 National Draft prospects

[soreplums]

What did the bombers trade for pick 9?

 

[stormskye]

What did the bombers trade for pick 9?

Another trade!​

The Bombers have moved up a spot in the draft order.
Essendon has traded picks 11 and 31 to Geelong in exchange for pick 10

 

[soreplums]

Another trade!​

The Bombers have moved up a spot in the draft order.
Essendon has traded picks 11 and 31 to Geelong in exchange for pick 10

Interesting

 

[stormskye]

A 29 pick first round… drafts a shambles. North concessions, academy picks.

 

[danielnajdek]

A 29 pick first round… drafts a shambles. North concessions, academy picks.

Yep it's becoming a joke with the Academies. Getting basically 4 freebies is a load of crap.

 

[Bogsey]

I have really liked Logan Morris from the start of the year. I'd love the pies to land him tomorrow or Archer Reid!

 

[jc37]

My hopes for tomorrow bag one of
Schoenmaker, Morris, Reid or Murphy.

Then have something Hine likes at our 3rd pick

 

[Pendles!]

Reckon clubs may have doubts he plays as a mid at AFL level, and maybe more of a flanker. Also didn't seem to have a great champs when put against the best kids his age. I also noticed his rookieme draft profile has endurance as average, so I reckon his 2km tine may have been disappointing as well.
Few things there but you don't get to this stage of the draft without some things to work on. Seems a good kid who'll give himself the best chance.

Nice summary. I agree, as to why I asked.

 

[Markfs]

I was elated when we picked him but after considering the careful analysis of BF, I realise we have a dud....and I will be bagging him endlessly next year... rinse and repeat...

 

[magpies42]

Surely we take a KPD at 37.

That’s not how it works, you take best available, unless you’re trading up or down the draft order. What’s the point drafting a tall if they are not good enough to make the grade. Would you rather a Dane Swan late pick or a McCarty nobody.

We have a need in just about every position on the field. Best available is what we will take.

 

[live fast pieyoung]

there used to be a limit on how many picks you could use for points

its total bs that gold coast could trade down all their points to picks at the end of the draft

i understand theres academy picks, but its supposed to be balances by picks being used for points

instead it means our picks of 19 and 33 become 25 and 37. ridiculous .

 

[barrackers]

there used to be a limit on how many picks you could use for points

its total bs that gold coast could trade down all their points to picks at the end of the draft

i understand theres academy picks, but its supposed to be balances by picks being used for points

instead it means our picks of 19 and 33 become 25 and 37. ridiculous .

With less players being taken and zone selections pushing picks out third & fourth round picks don’t hold as much draft value yet the points they carry hasn’t changed. Reckon they need to tweak it, certainly remove points from fourth round picks and possibly have third round pick points cease once the pick is traded.

 

[Soups]

Highlight of the night for me was the young kid who was on the screen before the draft started when Browny was doing his interview

 

[manicpie]

Of all the teams to pick Moir, it had to be Carlton, fmd, I really hate them now

 

[manicpie]

there used to be a limit on how many picks you could use for points

its total bs that gold coast could trade down all their points to picks at the end of the draft

i understand theres academy picks, but its supposed to be balances by picks being used for points

instead it means our picks of 19 and 33 become 25 and 37. ridiculous .

The concessions this year to shit sides has just been ridiculous. This obsession with having an even comp is ruining the talent pool, as the numbers dwindle, kids will turn to other sports. I'm over the whole thing

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

Of all the teams to pick Moir, it had to be Carlton, fmd, I really hate them now

Carlton will turn him into a spud. Its what they do to talented players who are not certainties.

 

[manicpie]

Carlton will turn him into a spud. Its what they do to talented players who are not certainties.

God I hope so, the thought of this kid next to curnow is very scary if Ashton decides to get serious

 

[Hardas]

Of all the teams to pick Moir, it had to be Carlton, fmd, I really hate them now

So, you only hated them before?
I already really, REALLY hated them, so I'm not sure where I go with this new reason to hate them more.

 

[AmericanMustard]

29 picked in the “first round” this competition is beyond a joke

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Then have something Hine likes at our 3rd pick

We're not using a third pick unless something crazy happens. Hine confirmed this directly yesterday.

I think it would have had to involve a trade, and that didn't happen, so we won't be using the later pick.

 

[Apex36]

If we’re basing tonight on last year we’ll get a slider with our first and Morris with our second.

Halfway there!

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Highlight of the night for me was the young kid who was on the screen before the draft started when Browny was doing his interview

 

[NMBB]

Clubs can trade and do deals and pick up sliders and smokeys and swap points etc etc... but they ain't getting OUR COACH!

 

[whiskeytown]

That’s not how it works, you take best available, unless you’re trading up or down the draft order. What’s the point drafting a tall if they are not good enough to make the grade. Would you rather a Dane Swan late pick or a McCarty nobody.

We have a need in just about every position on the field. Best available is what we will take.

Best available for Collingwood is what matters That would be Ollie Murphy or Logan Morris… and potentially address a long term KPP list need with those players

Or we arbitrarily take ‘best available’ mid and end up with another mid like Rantall or Goodyear who were only chosen because of their running ability

… and who will languish in the VFL til they are delisted

Best available… without taking into account positional need… is just lazy recruiting imo

 

[Mkcaptain]

Best available for Collingwood is what matters That would be Ollie Murphy or Logan Morris… and potentially address a long term KPP list need with those players

Or we arbitrarily take ‘best available’ mid and end up with another mid like Rantall or Goodyear who were only chosen because of their running ability

… and who will languish in the VFL til they are delisted

Best available… without taking into account positional need… is just lazy recruiting imo

It's a fair point, but you can pick for need and end up with McLarty or McMahan.

If we'd gone best available in the McLarty year apparently we would have gone Tom Stewart but the coaches wanted a genuine KPP.