Game Day 2023 Round 15 Discussion - Have You 18 players !

[WaynesWorld19]

Can someone explain why a player only gets reported IF it's an opposition player ...teammates excempted ....strange

 

[HotPiesWithSauce]

Not that bad, the KO was from the head swinging due to the jaw clip, he'll be back after missing one I reckon

 

[Ed_Gein]

Damn.... Was going to bring in J.Cameron last week, but went with Coniglio forgetting he had the bye this week. As it turns out, I'm better copping the 0 there than the -4 Cameron is currently on...

 

[swindle]

This scaling shit is ridiculous lol, surely they could just pause the scores...?

 

[Duckworthy]

Rd16 trades thread not open yet?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Straight swap to HH I guess, or just hold. Dunno, that's next weeks problem.

You didn't want this, in a week that was already tough ......hope Cameron is OK ....we all hope that

 

[kyri]

Of course none of my league opponents have Jezza..

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Can someone explain why a player only gets reported IF it's an opposition player ...teammates excempted ....strange

Are you suggesting Rohan get's reported for that?

Was a complete accident.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Viney ded now to.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

You didn't want this, in a week that was already tough ......hope Cameron is OK ....we all hope that

Correct, I did not want one of my players to get knocked out on -3

 

[Nelso]

Have Melbourne been at the pub all day?

Not switched on at all.

 

[Raveneyes]

Didn't think Clarry would be beating Jezza and Kozzie this deep into the 1st quarter. Great effort!

 

[Duckworthy]

Rohan freeing up some space in the forward line for himself…

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Are you suggesting Rohan get's reported for that?

Was a complete accident.

I think it was a reference to the fact that whether the opposition player is concussed or not seems to have a huge impact on whether or not someone is suspended or walks free.

See Mansell on Aish vs Hayward on Wardlaw

See Sicily on Luggage vs Zerrett on some Blue.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Are you suggesting Rohan get's reported for that?

Was a complete accident.

Yes ....if the opposition player did it, you'd hear about it all next week ....and he'd get 3 weeks

But a teammate does exact same ....and there's nothing to see here ?

Don't you think that's strange ?

 

[TheDoor]

Stop dropping marks Stewart

 

[SC_Power]

Yes ....if the opposition player did it, you'd hear about it all next week ....and he'd get 3 weeks

But a teammate does exact same ....and there's nothing to see here ?

Don't you think that's strange ?

Interesting, does the rule book specifically state “opponent” or not?

 

[HotPiesWithSauce]

Can someone explain why a player only gets reported IF it's an opposition player ...teammates excempted ....strange

I think only because there's zero doubt that it was unintentional

I wouldn't be surprised though if the MRO could question it if it was crazy reckless, or if a player punched out his own teammate or something

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Interesting, does the rule book specifically state “opponent” or not?

An opposition player .....careless act, must get it out of football
A Teammate .....play on, everythings fine ...just a footy accident

We're trying to explain, an opposition player can also just have a footy accident

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Yes ....if the opposition player did it, you'd hear about it all next week ....and he'd get 3 weeks

But a teammate does exact same ....and there's nothing to see here ?

Don't you think that's strange ?

It's not the same thing if it's opposing players contesting the ball though.

 

[Duckworthy]

Back in Pluggers day he would have knocked Rohan out and said never get in my leading lane again you flog

 

[gutsroy]

Absolutely catastrophic trade-in, really

Will be low 300s if / when, we get a negative score in a week where we're all scrambling to get the 18 together.
All good and no point clutching pearls, but comfortably the worst trade in I can recall in recent times.

 

[cznsnowy91]

Stewart going at 20%

 

[Ingy]

Haha. My only player for the night is gone after 10mins

1/-4

Yep me too lol.

I traded Gawn out and Jezza in.

SC gods are such malevolent barstards

 

[Sherman41]

How is Petracca on 18 from 7 touches, going at 57% DE with 4 turnovers.

KOTD