Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[Wingnut19]

For new members, these ‘ITK’ posters get about 2% of things correct. I can think of a number of big name players that were ‘done deals’ over the years none of which have eventuated. Just a warning….

Haha spot on

 

[CHUBBSS]

The only reason I see us being into McKay is so we can drive the price up and then pull the rug out from under them and cancel the offer.

 

[Topiary]

Haha spot on

Don’t worry Wingnut, you won’t need to put up with me any longer.

 

[triple treat]

I’m having another go at a hypothetical
Brockman and Dogs 2nd rounder to Eagles
Pick 19 to Hawks
Pick 3 and pick 19 to Roos
Pick 2 to Hawks on traded to GC with future 1st
Pick 5 and and B King to Hawks

 

[Hodgey 15]

So if Ahhhhhh has his way I should not make any contribution. So best I shut up.

Maybe it's not you who should shut up Tops.

On SM-S906E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The hands of stone]

Can someone give me the likelihood of us getting the GWS pick for a salary dump odds? Think all our efforts need to be going into this.

I don't we should be giving up next years first for the Suns first pick. Still a young list and inconsistent. Don't think we will make finals next year even though we are having a decent run home.

I'd be really happy with Watson, another first rd pick, McCabe and try and find another hidden gun.

Its well in play but has a fair way to go .

Put it this way , no one could say we havent been really proactive .

 

[cryptor]

I’m having another go at a hypothetical
Brockman and Dogs 2nd rounder to Eagles
Pick 19 to Hawks
Pick 3 and pick 19 to Roos
Pick 2 to Hawks on traded to GC with future 1st
Pick 5 and and B King to Hawks

Ew, no thanks.

 

[SammyC]

Unlike some I like Gresham. Like him more with Chad likely out for 12 months and/or gone. Costs us nothing but cap space…

 

[FB19]

I think Riccardi will cost too much now we don’t have much draft capital and to be honest, if Kozi continues his form and Ramsden develops into the 2nd/3rd forward and relief ruck, then I think we need to pursue other areas. Breust in a year Chad and Brockman likely dons we need mid to small forwards and several.

Trade 1 salary dump
Haynes and tigers r1 for cap space and f3
To GWS
Trade 2 enable suns first
Tigers r1 to Dees for their r1 and Freo r2
Trade 3 get suns first
Dogs r2, freo r2 and hawks f2 to suns for suns r1 and crows r3

As things stand
2023: Haynes, 3, 4, 15, 45, 51
2024: f1, f4

Feels too ambitious but not that far off happy to take suggestions to refine?
Edit:
Forgot about brockman the pick we get likely 34/38 could either go to dees or suns to balance out those trades. Or if we don’t need to then

Trade 4
Lohmann to hawks for pick we get for brockman

 

[Colloquy]

I just don't rate the King brothers.

Give me a cheap hard working Mihochek anyday of the week over a skinny push about.

Arrr I agree but don’t say that to loud people in here.

 

[perrdan86]

I’m having another go at a hypothetical
Brockman and Dogs 2nd rounder to Eagles
Pick 19 to Hawks
Pick 3 and pick 19 to Roos
Pick 2 to Hawks on traded to GC with future 1st
Pick 5 and and B King to Hawks

Don't mind it. Adding King + pick 5 and McCabe would be a nice trade/draft period. Shane Watson probably wouldn't be there at 5.

 

[tl92]

Don't mind it. Adding King + pick 5 and McCabe would be a nice trade/draft period. Shane Watson probably wouldn't be there at 5.

Shane Watson at CHF? Did have some broad shoulders

 

[Thrashor]

I’m having another go at a hypothetical
Brockman and Dogs 2nd rounder to Eagles
Pick 19 to Hawks
Pick 3 and pick 19 to Roos
Pick 2 to Hawks on traded to GC with future 1st
Pick 5 and and B King to Hawks

Eagles can get Brockman via the PSD so we have zero leverage there.

 

[WireHawk]

So if Ahhhhhh has his way I should not make any contribution. So best I shut up.

I, like many fellow Hawk fans on here I'm sure, look forward to and respect your contributions. Keep posting
whatever insights you have about potential recruits. Things do indeed change, but I for one really appreciate your
news.

 

[Braidz]

Shane Watson at CHF? Did have some broad shoulders

Don't mind it. Adding King + pick 5 and McCabe would be a nice trade/draft period. Shane Watson probably wouldn't be there at 5.

 

[Braidz]

Arrr I agree but don’t say that to loud people in here.

One of them kicked 6 today. Which was the final margin. But yeah. They are rubbish

 

[H00t]

One of them kicked 6 today. Which was the final margin. But yeah. They are rubbish

Problem is even when they have a big game with 6 goals they also end up with only 8 disposals total.

Don’t get me wrong they are talented but really need to get involved a lot more to influence games.

 

[perrdan86]

Don't mind it. Adding King + pick 5 and McCabe would be a nice trade/draft period. Shane Watson probably wouldn't be there at 5.

** Its a shame Watson probably won't be available at pick 5.

 

[H00t]

I think the big problem if we get McKay is we end up way too top heavy and will struggle when the balls on the ground in our defence or coming in quickly.

We have a lot of defenders that look great when the balls coming in high and slow. And McKay will add to that but not help us where we struggle which is when the ball is hitting the deck or the opposition mids get on top.

 

[derp de derp]

For new members, these ‘ITK’ posters get about 2% of things correct. I can think of a number of big name players that were ‘done deals’ over the years none of which have eventuated. Just a warning….

Things change, it’s all fluid this time of year

 

[Burtman]

I think the big problem if we get McKay is we end up way too top heavy and will struggle when the balls on the ground in our defence or coming in quickly.

We have a lot of defenders that look great when the balls coming in high and slow. And McKay will add to that but not help us where we struggle which is when the ball is hitting the deck or the opposition mids get on top.

Really? I think the high long ball is one of our weakenesses. Naughton, Jamarra and lobbe looked dangerous with nearly all the highballs, with naughton taking some cracking grabs. We’ve been torn apart by a few key forwards over the years who can take big contested grabs

 

[smish]

Don’t worry Wingnut, you won’t need to put up with me any longer.

Please don’t stop sharing your info Tops!

 

[Books]

Don't mind it. Adding King + pick 5 and McCabe would be a nice trade/draft period. Shane Watson probably wouldn't be there at 5.

Watson will be out LBW for 4.

But not before a review.

 

[BIGHAWK23]

who pissed in ahhhhhh wheaties this morning

Keep sharing Topiary , nothing better than seeing a little update occasionally

 

[FB19]

Aren’t there mechanisms here for those
Lacking a basic grasp of the meaning of threads and whose definition of intestinal fortitude is posting their corporate resilience training certification to LinkedIn to mute the ITK posters and avoid challenging content?