Toast 2024 All Australian: congrats Jesse & Lachie for AA selection; & Binga on AA Squad selection

Giant Strides · Aug 26, 2024

AA SQUAD REVEALED: Lions, Dockers dominate, big Pie named

Brisbane and Fremantle are the best represented clubs in the 44-man All-Australian squad

www.afl.com.au

2024 AFL ALL-AUSTRALIAN SQUAD: Noah Anderson, Harris Andrews, Nick Blakey, Marcus Bontempelli, Andrew Brayshaw, Zak Butters, Darcy Cameron, Jeremy Cameron, Jordan Clark, Sam Collins, Patrick Cripps, Charlie Curnow, Nick Daicos, Bailey Dale, Massimo D’Ambrosio, Brent Daniels, Joe Daniher, Errol Gulden, Isaac Heeney, Jesse Hogan, Max Holmes, Jason Horne-Francis, Max Gawn, Dan Houston, Jeremy McGovern, Harry McKay, Zach Merrett, Dylan Moore, Lachie Neale, Cam Rayner, Luke Ryan, Caleb Serong, James Sicily, Jack Sinclair, Harry Sheezel, Tyson Stengle, Adam Treloar, Chad Warner, Jake Waterman, Jacob Weitering, Lachie Whitfield, Tristan Xerri, Hayden Young, Dayne Zorko.

Brent Daniels
Never previously All-Australian
Never previously squad member

Jesse Hogan
Never previously All-Australian
Never previously squad member

Lachie Whitfield
2018 All-Australian

Squad members by club

5 - Brisbane, Fremantle
4 - Carlton, Sydney
3 - Geelong, GWS, Hawthorn, Port Adelaide, Western Bulldogs
2 - Collingwood, Gold Coast, North Melbourne, West Coast
1 - Essendon, Melbourne, St Kilda
0 - Adelaide, Richmond

Orange Agent · Aug 26, 2024

Tom Green stiff not to be in the squad. Too many fwd in it, has Joe Daniher really been that good?

Colonial · Aug 27, 2024

Congrats to all 3.

dlanod · Aug 27, 2024

Orange Agent said:
Tom Green stiff not to be in the squad. Too many fwd in it, has Joe Daniher really been that good?

Similar number of shots as Jesse while playing as a backup ruck and up the field - Joe's had a fantastic year but just gets shits on by the media because he dared leave Victoria because he didn't want anything to do with said media.

The only real knock on Joe vs Jesse (or any of the other three KPFs) has been his conversion but he's also been playing that more versatile role and taking harder shots as well. If they were picking an actual team I'd take Jesse as the Coleman winner, Joe as a ruck/forward, and any of the other three. I doubt Joe gets picked though.

Orange crush · Aug 27, 2024

dlanod said:
Similar number of shots as Jesse while playing as a backup ruck and up the field - Joe's had a fantastic year but just gets shits on by the media because he dared leave Victoria because he didn't want anything to do with said media.

The only real knock on Joe vs Jesse (or any of the other three KPFs) has been his conversion but he's also been playing that more versatile role and taking harder shots as well. If they were picking an actual team I'd take Jesse as the Coleman winner, Joe as a ruck/forward, and any of the other three. I doubt Joe gets picked though.

I’d take Harry over Joe …. Both as flakey as all **** though

SouthernGiant · Aug 27, 2024

I think Hogan and Whitfield make the 22

JC100 · Aug 27, 2024

dlanod said:
Similar number of shots as Jesse while playing as a backup ruck and up the field - Joe's had a fantastic year but just gets shits on by the media because he dared leave Victoria because he didn't want anything to do with said media.

The only real knock on Joe vs Jesse (or any of the other three KPFs) has been his conversion but he's also been playing that more versatile role and taking harder shots as well. If they were picking an actual team I'd take Jesse as the Coleman winner, Joe as a ruck/forward, and any of the other three. I doubt Joe gets picked though.

Its the reasons why Toby should have been in the squad. His season was as good as any other small forward but down on his 2023 and he missed shots at goal that would have made it look a lot better

Adam Giant · Aug 27, 2024

Going from AA captain to missing the 44 man squad must be quite a blow for Toby.

Let’s hope it lights a fuse under him and he comes out and dominates the finals series.

Giant Strides · Aug 29, 2024

Congratulations to Jesse Hogan and Lachie Whitfield for your selections in the 2024 All Australian team. Commiserations to Brent Daniels, you deserved to be there but they like putting midfielders in your position instead, however making the squad was a good reward.

Ichabod Noodle · Aug 29, 2024

Whitfield should have been on the park, not the pine.

But at least he was there, I suppose.

And once again, the Rising Star went to a guy in his third year - debuted Round 6, 2022

Giant Strides · Aug 30, 2024

The selected team is a bit of a joke with just one small forward, and a bunch of midfielders in the remaining spots. No real team is selected that way.

Orange crush · Aug 30, 2024

Giant Strides said:
The selected team is a bit of a joke with just one small forward, and a bunch of midfielders in the remaining spots. No real team is selected that way.

They really need to set a framework

Adam Giant · Aug 30, 2024

Ichabod Noodle said:
Whitfield should have been on the park, not the pine.

Gee I think he was lucky to make the squad at all. The selection is always a bit of a joke anyway, they pick a bunch of extra midfielders and shoehorn them into wing or half forward slots. Not to mention there’s always a lag between players getting media attention and being named in the AA team.

Orange crush · Aug 30, 2024

Adam Giant said:
Gee I think he was lucky to make the squad at all. The selection is always a bit of a joke anyway, they pick a bunch of extra midfielders and shoehorn them into wing or half forward slots. Not to mention there’s always a lag between players getting media attention and being named in the AA team.

Glad you ain’t a selector AG, ffs, Lachie was elite

SouthernGiant · Aug 30, 2024

Adam Giant said:
Gee I think he was lucky to make the squad at all. The selection is always a bit of a joke anyway, they pick a bunch of extra midfielders and shoehorn them into wing or half forward slots. Not to mention there’s always a lag between players getting media attention and being named in the AA team.

So who should have made the team from the Giants?

Adam Giant · Aug 31, 2024

Orange crush said:
Glad you ain’t a selector AG, ffs, Lachie was elite

Good player but makes a lot of errors. Selectors get caught up in the disposal count which he always excels at.

Adam Giant · Aug 31, 2024

SouthernGiant said:
So who should have made the team from the Giants?

Hogan obviously and I think Daniels probably deserved a spot on a half forward flank or the bench. Buckley maybe over McGovern.

Don’t think anyone else has really had an ‘elite’ year which is what this team should be recognising.

Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2025 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join

Fantasy Footy leagues open! Sign up now for 2025.

Toast 2024 All Australian: congrats Jesse & Lachie for AA selection; & Binga on AA Squad selection

Moderator

Squad members by club​

Norm Smith Medallist

Premium Gold

Moderator

Norm Smith Medallist

Debutant

Club Legend

All Australian

Moderator

Norm Smith Medallist

Moderator

Norm Smith Medallist

All Australian

Norm Smith Medallist

Debutant

All Australian

All Australian

Toast 2024 All Australian: congrats Jesse & Lachie for AA selection; & Binga on AA Squad selection

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account

Squad members by club