MVP 2025 P.A Ranked player of the year

[JHF1870]

I wanted to do this last year but I got busy but I wanted to rank our best player on total performance for the year and not via a 321 or 54321 voting system. This way we get an opportunity to identify how good the players season was and compare over seasons.

The basis is that I am going to rank every player for each game out of 100. I'm still compiling the game for Collingwood and rewatching the game and for reference. Connor Rozee will get 70/100 as the best player, and Lachie Jones will get 2/100 for turning up. 100 would be for an outstanding game, and obviously the requirements would be different for each playing position. We aren't going to expect Aliir to get 30 disposals to have a standout game.

I'm happy to collaborate results to even out any biases that I may have but really would need people to take this seriously as I'm aware of the strong opinions here over certain players.

If anyone is interested in investing time into ranking the players AND takes it seriously then I'll take and average the rankings each week into my spreadsheet.

If that's you, then feel free to send me a table of player scores from each game. It's not too late, but I'm happy to take rankings as they come.


Obviously the game last week was poor and hence the low starting point for our best player.


Let me know your thoughts on this.

 

[EskimoPAFC]

Cool idea, but it will be a lot of work in what will likely be a painful season to sit through. Definitely won't be participating as I dont even intend to watch any Port games this year unless we rid ourselves of the muppet early, but I'll check back in to see results for sure. Could possibly be interested for 2026, at least in a feedback sense.

 

[Peninsula Boy]

That is definitely a better way of grading the players than 5, 4, 3, 2, 1.

I've thought about it myself but you can tell overall who has a great impact and you generally don't need to put a number to it.

Plus I don't have the time.

 

[Duck Farmer]

I think it will be 10 times better if you rate the players out of a 1000.

 

[JHF1870]

Here's my results up to round 6

Each game is a 10-1 voting system. AFL Votes is for both teams each game, average is my impact score.

POTY (Round 6)	PAFC POTY	AFL vote	AVG
Connor Rozee	42​	17​	60.67​
Jason Horne-Francis	36​	6​	57.50​
Ollie Wines	32​	9​	48.42​
Zak Butters	29​	13​	74.50​
Jordon Sweet	24​		44.75​
Kane Farrell	21​		45.75​
Jase Burgoyne	20​	6​	41.92​
Aliir Aliir	20​	1​	43.08​
Willem Drew	18​	4​	44.42​
Willie Rioli	16​		37.75​
Mitch Georgiades	15​		41.33​
Miles Bergman	14​		40.33​
Travis Boak	11​		42.40​
Jackson Mead	7​		35.08​
Darcy Byrne-Jones	6​	1​	31.00​
Christian Moraes	5​		29.00​
Sam Powell-Pepper	5​		36.42​
Lachie Jones	4​		34.70​
Ollie Lord	3​		26.67​
Joe Richards	1​		32.40​
Josh Sinn	1​		28.17​
Jack Lukosius			10.75​
Esava Ratugolea			32.38​
Jeremy Finlayson			31.00​
Ryan Burton			30.25​
Ivan Soldo			16.50​
Joe Berry			16.70​
Rory Atkins			21.00​
Tom Cochrane			15.17​
Logan Evans			25.13​

 

[JHF1870]

After Round 7

	POTY (Round 7)	PAFC Votes	Average of Total	AFL Votes
1​	Connor Rozee	50​	60.93​	17​
2​	Jason Horne-Francis	45​	58.43​	9​
3​	Zak Butters	39​	72.00​	17​
4​	Ollie Wines	39​	50.14​	9​
5​	Jordon Sweet	24​	43.07​
6​	Jase Burgoyne	23​	42.21​	6​
7​	Kane Farrell	23​	45.43​
8​	Willem Drew	22​	44.71​	4​
9​	Mitch Georgiades	21​	42.50​
10​	Aliir Aliir	20​	41.71​	1​
	Willie Rioli	16​	37.00​
	Miles Bergman	14​	37.71​
	Travis Boak	11​	42.40​
	Sam Powell-Pepper	10​	38.07​
	Jackson Mead	7​	34.71​
	Darcy Byrne-Jones	7​	33.00​	1​
	Christian Moraes	5​	27.50​
	Lachie Jones	4​	32.83​
	Ollie Lord	3​	30.00​
	Joe Richards	1​	30.50​
	Josh Sinn	1​	24.93​