Certified Legendary Thread 4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

[Run n Spread]

We have all seen the same footage and we all have eyes.

It makes no sense that you would change your view because people on the internet tell you not to trust what you see.

Inconclusive vision stick with umpires call is my decision

 

[1990crow]

Shout out to Carey . Shored up his spot as keeper batsman.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Pfft. He did that years ago.

 

[Borisdog]

Shout out to Carey . Shored up his spot as keeper batsman.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yeah, kept well up to the stumps for Boland and Marsh.

I also liked very much how he organised the close in field when Lyon was bowling with everyone in short.

I am now prepared to consider him as an alternate Captain.

 

[grumbleguts]

Just got home and watching the replay.
That Jaiswal dismissal in slo mo was not out. A ridiculous decision on review. This test was plagued by non lbw calls of which Jaiswal was a beneficiary today but no way could you over turn that. Cost India the series. Shameful umpiring/ not that bit icc processes.
No way that was conclusive and if a flatline snicko and no hot spot it's simply a not out going with umpires calll
Indian fans at the ground every right to be pissed off

Jesus, your therapist has a lot of work to do. They showed the ball tracking deflection, and Jaiswal has admitted he hit it. So explain again, how the right decision is a poor one?

 

[philreich]

You could power the world with Indian tears

The good news to come out of this for India is the fact that Jaiswal will live a long life, as he'll never catch a cold.

 

[sabso]

Nah next captain is marnus

 

[cats_09]

 

[Pakenhamsaint]

Inconclusive vision stick with umpires call is my decision

I was 3 pints in and could see it deviated.

I'm 10 in can still see the same

 

[Black Diamond]

Inconclusive vision stick with umpires call is my decision

If these same posters tell you the last wicket was taken by Cummins and not Lyon will you believe that too?

 

[Borisdog]

Inconclusive vision stick with umpires call is my decision

Yep.

It was the hand of God.

Give it up mate. If you couldn't see that ball change path then we can't help you any further.

 

[ABAB]

A bizarre admission if true. Even accepting the recklessness of telling Pant he is allowed to go big in a hail mary attempt at a win, surely once that wicket falls you have to protect the wicket of your last recognized batsman.

And then you publicly admit such stupidity, as if it is going to make you look better?

Clearly they change strategy after Pant got out but we bowled well and took wickets. Both Reddy and Jadeja didn't get out to poor shots, Jaiswal was probably tired and saw a chance to score.

 

[Run n Spread]

Your tears make it even sweeter Vindaloo style if you think your dirty nation was robbed.

Keep crying sook.

You are a ****ing idiot.
I'm literally sunburnt and awaiting a unbiased opinion.
To a decision which influenced the result.
And you are a racist campaigner for calling out a dirty nation.

 

[TigerCraig]

Oh, f* yeah. Pleeeaassseeee, do it!

 

[Borisdog]

Nah next captain is marnus

There go all the reviews inside of 5 overs.

 

[grumbleguts]

My other half is also Indian, and her family are utterly embarrassed by the way the majority of their supporters act.

My other half is Mekeo, but I speak Hindi and most of the Indians I speak to are equally embarrassed.

 

[The hands of stone]

western royboy Adelaide Hawk PhatBoy can a decent cricket poster watch the replay of the Jaiswal dismissal.
it was given not out and over turned on review
your verdict not out/inconclusive and umpires call/ overturned and out?
I'll happily accept their call

OK, I'm going to try to give you a pretty reasoned response even though you didn't tag me .

It's the latter . Watch the replay a few times and use your experience playing ( if you did ) . It's a classic off the glove deflection from a hook/pull shot down the leg side.
It probably even glanced the the splice on the way through .
Watch the trajectory of the ball from contact to the keeper .
It slows up at point of where it did/would make contact from the glove.

It's not unusual that he may not have felt this . The gloves now around the thumb are pretty solid so even a half decent contact with him swivelling around as the ball come past may not register with him.

100% no doubt he was out .

 

[sabso]

There go all the reviews inside of 5 overs.

He’ll have a better review record than pope

 

[Stig O'Hara]

This is spiralling into the abyss.

How about everyone takes a deep breath.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Not sure if it’s been mentioned here yet, but Rohit said in the press conference that the team strategy was to go for the win in the last session, hence Pant and Jaiswal teeing off. Absolutely idiotic stuff, basically asking to get the sack with tactics like that when they were no chance of getting those runs.

Don't think that's what he meant

They wanted to position themselves into a position where they could go for the target in the final session.

But they didn't because they started slowly, lost three wickets in a clump before lunch and we bowled too well.

Pant's shot selection was all on him. Chasing the runs had gone by that stage.

 

[Borisdog]

I was 3 pints in and could see it deviated.

I'm 10 in can still see the same

Nice work.

Me too. Missus just asked for help with dinner. Sliced open finger, go and sit down you pissed idiot.

 

[Mr Meow]

Test cricket continues to embarrass itself

Something's continuing to embarrass itself...

Edit: should've kept scrolling before posting

 

[The Tilt]

Inconclusive vision stick with umpires call is my decision

The point is that basically everyone else thinks the vision was conclusive. You disagree - ok.

 

[Gough]

How about we all be cool?

 

[Black Diamond]

Don't think that's what he meant

They wanted to position themselves into a position where they could go for the target in the final session.

But they didn't because they started slowly, lost three wickets in a clump before lunch and we bowled too well.

Pant's shot selection was all on him. Chasing the runs had gone by that stage.

This is fair. He was clearly rattled and talking word salad after the game.

His interview with Isha, he sounded like Kamala Harris.

 

[HK_Hawk]

Are you guys marnus Labaschagne with these opinions and appeals? **** me. Starc angled across there was no deflection a joke. You guys are on drugs

Yep, that’s right, AND… we got away with it. We cheated and won. EAD!