Remove this Banner Ad

Delisted Adrian Dodoro - On leave Aug ‘24. Parted ways Nov ‘24. Lodged a dispute with FairWork. Paid out. Gone. #putoutyourjackets

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

It's all starting to make sense now....................
Yeah at the end of the day you have to build a list that can compete for 23 rounds plus finals, even and especially when injuries hit. It may be masterful accounting to hide the shit in the footnotes, but it's not masterful list management to cherry pick the few good bits as evidence of success and ignore the rest.

Like I get that people had a lot of faith, including me, in the 2013-2015 list build that coulda woulda shoulda and ultimately did not achieve even a finals win. And if he wants to make excuses for Dodoro on that basis, that's at least understandable even if a lot of people here don't like it and want blood.

But what I find really concerning is that even at board level, we're cherry picking evidence of success. If you're trying to delude yourself and pander to confirmation bias, selective appreciation of the evidence is your first step.

Take the damned blinkers off and look around.
 
This is going to go well.:p

Should be sacrificed but he gets a pass because he has been half decent and not a total **** up and it was not his fault the Saga killed off his last build.
 
This is going to go well.:p

Should be sacrificed but he gets a pass because he has been half decent and not a total duck up and it was not his fault the Saga killed off his last build.
talking about "a flag in 2-3 years" makes me very nervous that they plan to abandon the rebuild and blow all our cap space/draft picks on bringing in blokes like degoey and burn out having peaked at a 6th place finish 😬
 
He's untouchable... I think I'm done with this club for awhile.
Or is it the same code when the president of a club says the coach is safe mid season ?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Or is it the same code when the president of a club says the coach is safe mid season ?
I hope you're right but it's the same stuff we hear about Adrian even when we're going (somewhat) well. I had no faith they'd have the balls to sack him before Brasher's interview with Whateley, this just confirmed my suspicions.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.


  1. Is our list management up to the standard of the best clubs? If not, how can this be rectified?
  2. Our coaching group, while good on paper, does not appear to be getting the most out of these players this year. Why?
  3. Is our development of players up to the mark, and if not, how can we lift this? Andy McGrath, the No.1 draft pick, is a case to ponder given his relative stagnation, compared to his perceived capability.
  4. Are there any cultural issues – deep-seated factors unique to Essendon (coterie groups, past players, messiah complex et al) – that hinder the club and team performance, even slightly?
Posting this in here as well, because it is relevant.

Dodoro seems to have a few too many blind spots in general. Under Hird we were a bit slow through the midfield and now we're a bit small. He can find talent undoubtedly and that's great but we consistently ignore big bodies at the draft and we struggle to attract them through trades and free agency. We have a shit tonne of general forwards on the list but with Menzie now we really only have the two crumbing small forwards.
 
with Menzie now we really only have the two crumbing small forwards.

Hard work when you have 2 x crumbing small forwards retire in the space of 6 months, and know you've got F/S potentials coming up.

The bigger midfielder hole is more of a place to have a dig at list management than a dearth of small forwards
 
Hard work when you have 2 x crumbing small forwards retire in the space of 6 months, and know you've got F/S potentials coming up.

The bigger midfielder hole is more of a place to have a dig at list management than a dearth of small forwards
I'm not putting heaps of criticism there, it was more "we have x amount of small/medium forwards and yet only 2 are genuine crumbers" sort of thing
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Delisted Adrian Dodoro - On leave Aug ‘24. Parted ways Nov ‘24. Lodged a dispute with FairWork. Paid out. Gone. #putoutyourjackets

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top