Bigman’s Training Reports

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

How far do I need to go back to get to one of the great Bigman training reports? LOL.

All the training reports are threadmarked

 

[AFC979810]

Thanks

I don't remember who you are. Sorry.

Its okay.

It seems that you have a bit of a memory problem. You forget that Tom Mitchell was 3rd in the B&F in his clubs premiership season and finished 4th in the Norm Smith within 6 months and declared that nobody in the AFL rated him.

At this point, I am just glad you can remember your login details

 

[cleanhands]

No.

If you think its the right thing to not derail threads - then stop derailing threads.

If you think derailing threads is okay (which you do by constantly doing it), then don't tell others to stop derailing threads when it suits you.

Thats the hypocrisy.



Huh? Haven't we been arguing on this forum for years? This comment is another example of you doing conversational boxing and keeping score in your head. Its probably one of the reasons Marco kept telling you lies.

 

[George Kramer]

No.

If you think its the right thing to not derail threads - then stop derailing threads.

If you think derailing threads is okay (which you do by constantly doing it), then don't tell others to stop derailing threads when it suits you.

Thats the hypocrisy.



Huh? Haven't we been arguing on this forum for years? This comment is another example of you doing conversational boxing and keeping score in your head. It’s probably one of the reasons Marco kept telling you lies.

So you don’t consider a thread created for one poster who makes the effort to go every trainin and reporting back for everyone’s benefit, deserves to be treated a little bit different than other threads which 9 out of 10 derail?

It’s why I created the thread in the first place, so it’s a place for his reports to go.

Ever consider that Bigman might think what’s the point and stop?

Yes we argue on topics, can’t recall interjecting myself into conversations you’re having with other posters to take pot shots.

Anyway, my post wasn’t meant to act as a reason for further derailment. If you’d like to continue, go for it.

 

[1970crow]

Lol, so even if it’s the right thing, because I made comment then screw everyone else. I didn’t realise I had such an impact on you and Salty, good to see you’ve bonded through me though.

The enemy of my enemy......

 

[BRL121]

That was definitely Gallucci when we drafted him.

Tomorrow's Heroes: Jordan Gallucci leaps into contention

Tomorrow's heroes: Jordan Gallucci's combine jump hits the heights

www.afl.com.au

View attachment 2208227

Well, they got all that wrong!

 

[Mostyn]

Top 10 player at a clubs best and fairest in a year they finished is a list clogger....

Love to know your thoughts on our playing list....

Averaged 12 games a year the last three years then delisted as a 26 year old.

Maybe list clogger is harsh, but good players don't get delisted at 26, just as theyre hitting their peak.

 

[skittlebrew]

Like to hear Schoenberg has been leaving no stone unturned. Critical year for his footy career, and it sounds like he's not gonna let it go without a fight.

Bodes well for him

Real pity he was injured at an opportune time to have a proper crack. Now we have more midfield depth with Peatling and Draper. Berry not finding a new home hurts his chances. Would likely have to really out perform what we have previously seen from him to get another contract but who knows when it comes to crom list management.

 

[El Doederino]

Its okay.

It seems that you have a bit of a memory problem. You forget that Tom Mitchell was 3rd in the B&F in his clubs premiership season and finished 4th in the Norm Smith within 6 months and declared that nobody in the AFL rated him.

At this point, I am just glad you can remember your login details

I think the last thing Bigmans thread needs is a derailment on the merits of the player his last club sold off for Cooper Stephens and a couple 3rd round picks.

 

[Betts are off]

Real pity he was injured at an opportune time to have a proper crack. Now we have more midfield depth with Peatling and Draper. Berry not finding a new home hurts his chances. Would likely have to really out perform what we have previously seen from him to get another contract but who knows when it comes to crom list management

Schoenberg has enough tools and tricks to play midfield at this level IMO. But you're right, list management has made a challenge for him to hold his spot on the list.

It's not insurmountable, but Harry will need to make the most of every opportunity. No more fringe 22 performances, get a spot and don't give it back!

 

[Redleg Crow]

No signs that was the case as a junior, but then again wouldnt have had the money for it at that point.

IMO he was treated pretty shite by Don Pyke. Dropped after getting concussed in the Showdown.

Then dumped by the club after a year out injured. The AFL is a harsh business. But given he's now playing in the MPFNL, hard to say the Crows were wrong to dump him.

 

[Redleg Crow]

I see we're at the "Milera could have been good" part of the pre-season discussion.

I'll also admit for those wanting to argue it is just injuries, that I was the bloke who after 11 games started a thread worrying about him. Feel like my vibe compared to CC has held up.

 

[spenze]

Its the Zak Butters thing, had he not gone so well at Port we probably wouldn't hear too much about Ned.

He was predicted to go around that spot, but he just didnt work out.

 

[FR0GGY]

All the training reports are threadmarked

You can go straight to them

Can you threadmark the fights too?

 

[FR0GGY]

Its okay.

It seems that you have a bit of a memory problem. You forget that Tom Mitchell was 3rd in the B&F in his clubs premiership season and finished 4th in the Norm Smith within 6 months and declared that nobody in the AFL rated him.

At this point, I am just glad you can remember your login details

Looks like you’re as good at remembering as George is keeping score!

 

[1990crow]

Can you threadmark the fights too?

Is there a live score somewhere?

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Can you threadmark the fights too?

Click on any page and you'll find them

 

[FR0GGY]

Do people actually come for the training reports?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Is there a live score somewhere?

Some go for countless rounds, some are just sparring & there are few TKO's...

 

[George Kramer]

Looks like you’re as good at remembering as George is keeping score!

Yeah I thought that was ironic.

Not the first time he’s brought up a posters opinion from years ago, he must catalogue them.

I wasn’t going to raise it but now that you have

 

[AFC979810]

Looks like you’re as good at remembering as George is keeping score!

Sure am Frog. But I don't pretend that people like me!

 

[AFC979810]

I think the last thing Bigmans thread needs is a derailment on the merits of the player his last club sold off for Cooper Stephens and a couple 3rd round picks.

You are right. Bigmans training report doesn't need anymore posts about a guy whose own club rated him the 4th best player on their list in a premiership year and was so influential he was close to winning a norm smith.

 

[AFC979810]

So you don’t consider a thread created for one poster who makes the effort to go every trainin and reporting back for everyone’s benefit, deserves to be treated a little bit different than other threads which 9 out of 10 derail?

It’s why I created the thread in the first place, so it’s a place for his reports to go.

Ever consider that Bigman might think what’s the point and stop?

Yes we argue on topics, can’t recall interjecting myself into conversations you’re having with other posters to take pot shots.

Anyway, my post wasn’t meant to act as a reason for further derailment. If you’d like to continue, go for it.

So hang on... you asked me two questions, which presumably you want answered. But then at the end of the post say you don't want further derailment.

 

[AFC979810]

Yeah I thought that was ironic.

Not the first time he’s brought up a posters opinion from years ago, he must catalogue them.

For someone who is constantly against the derailment of this thread you sure do continue adding to the derailment of the thread.

I love a good search function and sure I remember posts from years ago. Been on this forum for 16 years.

I wasn’t going to raise it but now that you have

Rules for thee, but not for me.

I wasn't going to derail this thread further, but now that you have

 

[Flip Side]

Half back flankers are seagulls playing one of the easiest roles on the ground. They're a dime a dozen. It's why someone that looks like an absolute spud playing mid/forward can go back there and look good.

If that is so, you’d think Crouch would be able to play half back?