Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Billy Dowling - Re-Signed to End of 2026

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

So you think his kicking is an issue or am I reading that wrong?
He doesn’t have a Dawson type kick, but is better than a Laird or Berry; basically, he is on par with the majority of top line mids in the comp. I posted a quote from my recruiting mate on the previous page, he called him a ‘great user’.
 
He doesn’t have a Dawson type kick, but is better than a Laird or Berry; basically, he is on par with the majority of top line mids in the comp. I posted a quote from my recruiting mate on the previous page, he called him a ‘great user’.
Yep better than Berry (and definitely better than Keays), still a bit hit-or-miss though, IMO. That said, he gets good depth on his kicking, which is a good trait to have, especially when it comes to pushing forward-of-centre
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

He doesn’t have a Dawson type kick, but is better than a Laird or Berry; basically, he is on par with the majority of top line mids in the comp. I posted a quote from my recruiting mate on the previous page, he called him a ‘great user’.
I definitely wouldn’t call him a ‘great user’

More a work in progress

If he was a great user and also close to the the leading ball winner around Australia he’d be going top 25 IMO

He’s not quick but his repeat running is v good which makes up for a lot of it
 
I definitely wouldn’t call him a ‘great user’

More a work in progress

If he was a great user and also close to the the leading ball winner around Australia he’d be going top 25 IMO

He’s not quick but his repeat running is v good which makes up for a lot of it
That was a direct quote from an SA recruiter, they watch a lot more vision than any of us. Talent was quite even after the top 12-15; someone like Rowston went inside 20 after being rated a 40+ selection. I think we can all agree though that he is above the level of players like Berry and Keays, which is where the mind of people go if you say his kicking isn't fantastic.
 
That was a direct quote from an SA recruiter, they watch a lot more vision than any of us. Talent was quite even after the top 12-15; someone like Rowston went inside 20 after being rated a 40+ selection. I think we can all agree though that he is above the level of players like Berry and Keays, which is where the mind of people go if you say his kicking isn't fantastic.
Yep just saying what I’ve seen and I’ve seen him play live and also on stream

Have also heard people say same thing so there are differing opinions

Not all recruiters think he’s a great user

Yes he’s a better natural kick than Berry and Keays although Berry is improving
 

Remove this Banner Ad

That was a direct quote from an SA recruiter, they watch a lot more vision than any of us. Talent was quite even after the top 12-15; someone like Rowston went inside 20 after being rated a 40+ selection. I think we can all agree though that he is above the level of players like Berry and Keays, which is where the mind of people go if you say his kicking isn't fantastic.
Re Rowston - I’d have Dowling over Rowston
 
Yep just saying what I’ve seen and I’ve seen him play live and also on stream

Have also heard people say same thing so there are differing opinions

Not all recruiters think he’s a great user

Yes he’s a better natural kick than Berry and Keays although Berry is improving
Fair mate, appreciate your opinion as you have seen a bit of him too. Time will tell! At least his base is at an above average level and should improve in the AFL system.
 
Fair mate, appreciate your opinion as you have seen a bit of him too. Time will tell! At least his base is at an above average level and should improve in the AFL system.
Yep and as I said if he didn’t have any weaknesses he would have gone in the 1st round comfortably , so we get a discount for it and he can work on all parts of his game

Great to have such a prolific ball winner ( inside and out ) on our list
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Nankervis, Dowling and Cook can all become the big bodied mids we are after . All are different types also .


Firstly, I rate Cook and really hope he steps up this year but if he doesn't learn to go when it's his time he will be found out very quickly. He was as soft as I've ever seen a footballer in the SANFL final series.
 
Too smart to be a bust, footy IQ is really high. His disposal due to his decision making is elite, rarely wastes a disposal in general play, extremely composed

He doesn’t have a Dawson type kick, but is better than a Laird or Berry; basically, he is on par with the majority of top line mids in the comp. I posted a quote from my recruiting mate on the previous page, he called him a ‘great user’.
Well that's interesting, because in reality his kicking is actually one of the question marks. I'll take my info from someone at St Peters:

1669816802280.png
 
As I said, I'll take my info from someone actually involved with his footy, not a highlights clip.
Your post with no indication of the person making the comments , indicated “ he understands Dowling is a good Capt” …. so whoever it is, isn’t that close

Also, in school footy, your kicking depends on the movement in front of you …. which being a lowly school, isn’t surprising 😛

That was my go too excuse
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Billy Dowling - Re-Signed to End of 2026


Write your reply...

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top