Brownlow Medal 2009 (Part 1)

[senrulzisback]

Re: Brownlow Medal

18 Votes
Gary Ablett

14 Votes
Nick Riewoldt

11 Votes
Chris Judd
Scott Pendlebury
Leigh Montagna

10 Votes
Brendon Goddard

9 Votes
Lenny Hayes
Bryce Gibbs
Steve Johnson
Leon Davis
Adam Goodes

8 Votes
Nick Dal Santo
Paul Haselby
Jonothan Brown
Matthew Boyd
Brad Sewell
Aaron Sandilands

7 Votes
Sam Mitchell
Jason Akermanis
Warren Tredrea

6 Votes
Matthew Richardson
Jimmy Bartel
Jarrad McVeigh
Joel Selwood
Danyle Pearce
Justin Koschitzke
Mark LeCras
Bernie Vince
Jason Winderlich
Patty Ryder
Chad Cornes
Dane Swan
Paul Chapman

5 Votes
Nathan Foley
Scott Thompson
David Hale
Andrew Swallow
Daniel Giansiracusa
Travis Boak
Tarkyn Lockyer
Brett Kirk

4 Votes
Josh Fraser
Cameron Ling
Jarryd Roughead
Rhyce Shaw
Adam Selwood
Darren Jolly
Jed Adcock
Shaun Higgins
Brent Moloney

3 Votes
Jack Riewoldt
Simon Goodwin
Kade Simpson
Mitch Clark
Simon Wiggins
Adam Cooney
Daniel Motlop
Justin Sherman
Luke Power
Chris Knights
Brendan Fevola
Leigh Harding
Lindsay Gilbee
Brian Lake
Domenic Cassisi
Brent Harvey
Tyson Edwards
David Wirrpunda
Daniel Kerr
Dean Cox
Gary Moss
Taylor Walker
David Mundy
Marc Murphy
Ryan O'Keefe
Travis Johnstone
Daniel Jackson
Paul Duffield
Martin Mattner
Brent Stanton

2 Votes
Jude Bolton
Angus Graham
Colin Sylvia
Kurt Tippett
Andrew Mcleod
Angus Monfries
Michael Doughty
Sam Gilbert
Leigh Brown
Kane Cornes
David Mackay
Brad Ottens
Troy Selwood
Michael Firrito
Joel Corey
James McDonald
Brad Johnson
Dustin Fletcher
Shaun Burgoyne
Josh Drummond
James Kelly
Ryan Crowley
Matthew Lloyd
Drew Petrie
Brady Rawlings
Hamish McIntosh
Joel Bowden
Cyril Rioli
Alan Didak
Simon Black
Shannon Byrnes
Josh Hill
Shane Tuck
Matthew Pavlich
Steven Salopek
Brendon Fevola
Matt Priddis

1 Vote
Matt White
Shane O'Bree
Cameron Mooney
Peter Burgoyne
Daniel Bradshaw
Alwyn Davey
Nathan G Brown
Courtenay Dempsey
Brendon Whitecross
Ted Richards
Paul Medhurst
Jarrad Waite
Matthew Stokes
Jordan Lewis
Sam Fisher
Nick Stevens
Jobe Watson
Clinton Jones
Adam Schneider
Farren Ray

Updated for Round 10.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Round 10 Brownlow votes Running Total:

16: Montagna

14: Ablett

12: Dal Santo, Judd

11: Hayes

10: Mitchell, Goddard, SJohnson

9: Tredrea, JSelwood

8: Bartel, Gibbs, Goodes, Swan

7: Chapman, Haselby, Winderlich, Pendlebury

etc

Special Edition next week with Club Leaderboards etc for the half way point.

 

[pigeon26]

Re: Brownlow Medal

So i am guessing not many are interested in my group count idea

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

So i am guessing not many are interested in my group count idea

Maybe next year from the start. Too hard now imo. Be good to see how everyone goes this year though.

 

[Nicko_]

Re: Brownlow Medal

am interested in the limited amounts of votes given to bombers players here.

bombers are sitting 5-5 after 10 games with a % of around 94%, not too bad. so going from that you could make an assumption that the votes in bombers game could be around 28-32 bombers-opposition, however going from two of the above lists after rd 10, bombers players polled 23 votes in one and 21 votes in the other, is this a reflection that Essendon work better as a team with the opposition having standout performances? or some other factor?

 

[Roos34]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Black is starting to warm up, over the last 5 weeks he should of been in the votes and the umps love him. As i backed him at the start this is how i see him so far this year

Rnd6-2
rnd7-2-3
rnd 8-2 sherman should get 3
rnd 9- mite sneak the 1 ahead of drummond
rnd10- 2-3 depending on how umps see richs game, rich deserves the 3 in this game.

9-10 votes at this stage with ablett, judd, montagna leading the charge. Brad sewell will also be right up there at this stage.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

I just can't find places to give Black votes.

Gave him 2 in RD 8. Don't think he deserves any from the last game (did have a good 2nd half though). Definitely none in R9 imo. None in R6. 2 in R7 (just over Power).

I have him on 4.

 

[Subaru Impreza]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Leon Davis @ 126.00 seems a good bet to me. The games where collingwood have won, he has been top 3 at least for sure

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

am interested in the limited amounts of votes given to bombers players here.

bombers are sitting 5-5 after 10 games with a % of around 94%, not too bad. so going from that you could make an assumption that the votes in bombers game could be around 28-32 bombers-opposition, however going from two of the above lists after rd 10, bombers players polled 23 votes in one and 21 votes in the other, is this a reflection that Essendon work better as a team with the opposition having standout performances? or some other factor?

Just looked at my votes. I've given 26 to Essendon.

 

[Hu$tler]

Re: Brownlow Medal

They won't win it thought what's the point.

Judd would be leading, then Ablett, Selwood, Montagna (not sure how umps are with him) and Goodes would be around abouts.

 

[senrulzisback]

Re: Brownlow Medal

They won't win it thought what's the point.

Judd would be leading, then Ablett, Selwood, Montagna (not sure how umps are with him) and Goodes would be around abouts.

Ablett would be leading even if he didn't poll in his last two games.

 

[bradfooks]

Re: Brownlow Medal

after 10 rounds i have:

Ablett 18
Mitchell 16
Dal Santo 15
Montagna 13
Judd 13
Gibbs 11
Hasleby 11
Stanton 10
Black 10
Goddard 10
Cross 10
S Johnson 9
Hayes 9
S Thompson 9
R Shaw 9
Bartel 8
Goodes 8
Akermanis 7
Winderlich 7
Kirk 7
K Cornes 7
Swan 7
Chapman 7
J Selwood 7
Pendlebury 7
Tredrea 7
Gilbee 7

This is by looking at the stats and remembering who played well. Tell me if any one is too high or not on list.

 

[Wiggo34]

Re: Brownlow Medal

What do you guys think of Leon Davis for the charlie?

i got him for the win $20 @ $101 paying $2020 and place $35 @ $26 paying $910

 

[Roos34]

Re: Brownlow Medal

after 10 rounds i have:

Ablett 18
Mitchell 16
Dal Santo 15
Montagna 13
Judd 13
Gibbs 11
Hasleby 11
Stanton 10
Black 10
Goddard 10
Cross 10
S Johnson 9
Hayes 9
S Thompson 9
R Shaw 9
Bartel 8
Goodes 8
Akermanis 7
Winderlich 7
Kirk 7
K Cornes 7
Swan 7
Chapman 7
J Selwood 7
Pendlebury 7
Tredrea 7
Gilbee 7

This is by looking at the stats and remembering who played well. Tell me if any one is too high or not on list.

i would think selwood be higher, you have black right, marc nurphy rite up there, gilbee hasnt done much this year

 

[bradfooks]

Re: Brownlow Medal

i would think selwood be higher, you have black right, marc nurphy rite up there, gilbee hasnt done much this year

With J Selwood it was hard to give votes because Ablett has 3 most games then came S Johnson or Chapman with Bartel and Corey taking the two/one votes. Maybe he could have a few more votes but even when they won there was a standout from the opposition who could of stole votes.

Can anyone tell if they gave votes to opposition in any Geelong game this year as i did and want to know if i was justified.

Could people tell how many different guys have got the 3 votes in the St. Kilda games as I have 4. There could 6 peoople who could have a 3 vote game. Very consistant team effort. Geelong's votes hogged by Ablett

 

[bradfooks]

Re: Brownlow Medal

atm

Ablett: 13
Sewell: 11
Joel Selwood: 9
Leigh Montagna: 9


No Dal Santo
hes soft
and dosen't work hard for his disp

Ablett has more votes for sure he has been the best player in 5 or 6 wins. Dal Santo was our best player in the first 4 weeks but has dropped off since. He is right up there for sure.

If you have Montagna on 9 what about the rest of the votes from our wins. There are 60 votes and 50-54 votes would be ours meaning that someone must be in double figures.

 

[banta]

Re: Brownlow Medal

atm

Ablett: 13
Sewell: 11
Joel Selwood: 9
Leigh Montagna: 9


No Dal Santo
hes soft
and dosen't work hard for his disp

no judd too??

how do people think votes will go for the Brisbane VS Kangaroos and/or Hawthron VS Adelaide games on the weekend.. looks like scotty thompson is hitting some of his form from last year after a slow start.

 

[the_big_sav]

Re: Brownlow Medal

i woulda thought north vs bris would go

3. rich
2. adcock
1. black

black was very quiet in the first half but helped brisbane jump away in the 3rd and control the game in the last. adcock and rich for their 4 quarter efforts but rich was best on ground easily

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

i woulda thought north vs bris would go

3. rich
2. adcock
1. black

black was very quiet in the first half but helped brisbane jump away in the 3rd and control the game in the last. adcock and rich for their 4 quarter efforts but rich was best on ground easily

Don't have my votes with me, but pretty certain I gave Mitch Clark votes. 2 or 1. Unsure. Rich definitely deserved the 3, can't remember if I gave Clark/Adcock/Black the 2/1 .

 

[Big Nasty]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Champion data has Ablett leading with 17 votes, Montagna 2nd with 14 votes, and Leon Davis 3rd with 11 votes. That's all they named.

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Champion data has Ablett leading with 17 votes, Montagna 2nd with 14 votes, and Leon Davis 3rd with 11 votes. That's all they named.

I would have thought Selwood, Hayes, Dal Santo or Judd would be ahead of Davis. However, Davis has been very good this year.

 

[blues4flag]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Perhaps to place. None of them will win it.

Personally, I have:
Murphy - 3 (could be more)
Hayes - 8 (could be more or less)
Watson - 4 (others rate highly, I think he wouldn't be much more then 4 at this stage).

I've got Murphy between 9-11, depending on the Judd factor (about the same). Seems the bookies would agree as he's now 9th favourite at Sportsbet.

Am shocked that Gibbs is hovering between 8-11 for most. I've got him 4-5 at this stage - 3 vs. the Lions and 1/2 vs. the Bulldogs. Looks like most have been voting based on stats which is fair enough but Gibbs' stats haven't been indicative of his impact thus far this season.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

I've got Murphy between 9-11, depending on the Judd factor (about the same). Seems the bookies would agree as he's now 9th favourite at Sportsbet.

Am shocked that Gibbs is hovering between 8-11 for most. I've got him 4-5 at this stage - 3 vs. the Lions and 1/2 vs. the Bulldogs. Looks like most have been voting based on stats which is fair enough but Gibbs' stats haven't been indicative of his impact thus far this season.

In fairness to me that was written two weeks ago. I hav Murphy on 7 now.

The odds aren't designed by the bookies btw, they are mainly in relation to punter's betting.

Gibbs has been good in a few of our wins, which is why I think he has quite a few votes (8-9 imo).

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Champion data has Ablett leading with 17 votes, Montagna 2nd with 14 votes, and Leon Davis 3rd with 11 votes. That's all they named.

Makes me feel better about having Montagna so high.

ChampionData are usually fairly spot on, they predicted Bartel in 07. Not sure about last year.

 

[blues4flag]

Re: Brownlow Medal

In fairness to me that was written two weeks ago. I hav Murphy on 7 now.

The odds aren't designed by the bookies btw, they are mainly in relation to punter's betting.

Gibbs has been good in a few of our wins, which is why I think he has quite a few votes (8-9 imo).

Probably should've checked the date.

I can't see Murph polling any votes in our losses to date however I think he's a chance at polling 2/3 in all our wins bar the Collingwood game. I had him best on vs. Richmond, Bulldogs and West Coast and second to Gibbs against the Lions.

Judd, I can see polling in a couple of our losses. Will be shocked if he doesn't poll 1/2 vs. the Bombers and Freo. Against the Hawks he was brilliant, but I think Fev's 8 goal haul will mean he misses out. I have him with 3 and 2/3 against the Pies and Eagles, 1 vs. the Lions.