Caolan Buckley

[Flying Joey]

i cant see how you can put hurley or even edwards from sa before him?? does anbody rate him on here or what!!

 

[Salaryman]

i cant see how you can put hurley or even edwards from sa before him?? does anbody rate him on here or what!!

Good player, strong tackler, works hard defensively as well, nice kick of the footy...I have him going between 20-30 on my list. Edwards i think will go in the same bracket. Hurley i don't rate as highly as some others, will slide like Swallow did last year IMO.

 

[Thunderstruck]

He is good and solid but Edwards definitely has more natural talent. He would be right up there in terms of pure talent, just lacks size atm.

Certainly rate Buckley, I'd have him around 30-40 in the draft. Played well for westies in latter part of SANFL season.

 

[HBF]

Good player, strong tackler, works hard defensively as well, nice kick of the footy...I have him going between 20-30 on my list. Edwards i think will go in the same bracket. Hurley i don't rate as highly as some others, will slide like Swallow did last year IMO.

Nice summary Gilly

 

[coasting]

He is good and solid but Edwards definitely has more natural talent. He would be right up there in terms of pure talent, just lacks size atm.

Certainly rate Buckley, I'd have him around 30-40 in the draft. Played well for westies in latter part of SANFL season.

Edwards will probably go top 30. I think Buckley will go a bit later than that.

 

[RooDog]

Edwards will probably go top 30. I think Buckley will go a bit later than that.

tend to agree with this statement... Edwards stocks have risen dramatically recently, strong performance at draft camp, strong showing in the finals with north... also does the small things like tackle/shepard/run for a team mate well and has shown this where i know buckley can but probably hasnt shown that as well