Preview Changes & Pre-match Discussion - Round 11 vs. Geelong, MCG Sat 29/05 @ 1:45pm

[parano1a]

Before brown lined up for that shot my mind cast back to the Brisbane game... it’s bad that as a supporter, you’d be surprised if a professional player kicks a regulation goal with no degree of difficulty. Says it all.

I honestly would have been more confident if his sister Tarni was lining up for goal.

 

[hellfire]

I’m clearly in the minority again, but I didn’t think Tyler was that bad. He was extremely clean and creative in close... which is incredibly rare in our side. He also had a game high 28 pressure acts. Yes he didn’t do much at all in link up chains and needs to find a lot more of the ball to be a long term fixture, but I do think his sibling taints perception of him sometimes.... Callum was really, really poor... again.

 

[parano1a]

Could we play both Cox and Cameron?

It has worked OK in the past, can't see how Cox in the goal square would have been worse than de Goey was today.

 

[grayza2018]

I’m clearly in the minority again, but I didn’t think Tyler was that bad. He was extremely clean and creative in close... which is incredibly rare in our side. He also had a game high 28 pressure acts. Yes he didn’t do much at all in link up chains and needs to find a lot more of the ball to be a long term fixture, but I do think his sibling taints perception of him sometimes.... Callum was really, really poor... again.

I'm with you re: Tyler, I'd stick with him in there now

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Out : C Brown, DeGoey ( Just not giving enough. Needs a reality check)

In: Murphy, Bianco

Play Murphy forward and Bianco on a wing, and maybe playing Daicos more forward this week.

 

[LuckyLee]

OUT - C.Brown Thomas Wilson
IN - Macrae Sier Murphy


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[John Greening]

B Quaynor Roughead Murphy
HB Maynard Moore Crisp
C WHE Adams Poulter
HF Sidebottom De Goey McCreery
F Noble Cox Mihocek
R Grundy Pendlebury Daicos
INT Mayne Bianco T Brown Kelly

 

[anshell]

In Sier,Murphy.
Out.Brown,Brown.

 

[mike123]

I’m clearly in the minority again, but I didn’t think Tyler was that bad. He was extremely clean and creative in close... which is incredibly rare in our side. He also had a game high 28 pressure acts. Yes he didn’t do much at all in link up chains and needs to find a lot more of the ball to be a long term fixture, but I do think his sibling taints perception of him sometimes.... Callum was really, really poor... again.

If anything I think Callum makes Tyler look better than he is. You can't take a spot as an inside mid and only collect 13 possesions. I'm also not seeing this cleanliness he looks to make a hot potato hand pass and put someone else under pressure.

 

[Kappa]

I’m clearly in the minority again, but I didn’t think Tyler was that bad. He was extremely clean and creative in close... which is incredibly rare in our side. He also had a game high 28 pressure acts. Yes he didn’t do much at all in link up chains and needs to find a lot more of the ball to be a long term fixture, but I do think his sibling taints perception of him sometimes.... Callum was really, really poor... again.

The problem with Tyler is "he wasn't terrible" is the best we ever say about him.

He is never going to become a good AFL midfielder, and there's no where else on the ground he can play.

 

[TradeDraft]

Before brown lined up for that shot my mind cast back to the Brisbane game... it’s bad that as a supporter, you’d be surprised if a professional player kicks a regulation goal with no degree of difficulty. Says it all.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

When I saw C Brown Lining up I had no Confidence at all in him

 

[hellfire]

The problem with Tyler is "he wasn't terrible" is the best we ever say about him.

He is never going to become a good AFL midfielder, and there's no where else on the ground he can play.

I disagree, I think he has had plenty of good games, although I agree he has never had ‘great’ games. But we have no other emerging inside midfielders, so it’s a choice between investing in a young player with some good attributes, or going back to our 2018 midfield that is well past its best. I’d prefer the former.

 

[Maggie5]

In: Murphy, Bianco,
Out: Wilson, T Brown

 

[Ugene41]

I’m clearly in the minority again, but I didn’t think Tyler was that bad. He was extremely clean and creative in close... which is incredibly rare in our side. He also had a game high 28 pressure acts. Yes he didn’t do much at all in link up chains and needs to find a lot more of the ball to be a long term fixture, but I do think his sibling taints perception of him sometimes.... Callum was really, really poor... again.

T.Brown I can give some leeway to as he's still young and inexperienced and there's scope to improve. So at this stage you just need to look for signs rather than consistency, and he is showing some. Made some big tackles today, other weeks had some good clearances by hand and other weeks impacted strongly in the air.

C.Brown is a 23yo 60 gamer and should be coming into his prime. And the issue is that this is his prime. Just no upside.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Noble is in our best team, I'm not saying he is good I'm just saying there are a lot worse

He’s not close to being good. He’s an average player that needs to go if we are to progress up the ladder in the future

 

[THATSGOLD]

The problem with Tyler is "he wasn't terrible" is the best we ever say about him.

He is never going to become a good AFL midfielder, and there's no where else on the ground he can play.

His frame strikes me more of half back flanker Hes just going to be an average floater.

 

[Jen2310]

I'd say 17 disposals @ 88% efficiency. Wilson stays in.

 

[Hugg]

It has worked OK in the past, can't see how Cox in the goal square would have been worse than de Goey was today.

Or CAMERON what did he do ...goals.....?? What.... He is a going to be .....
Compare Cox and him ... Another Buckley love child..

 

[Hugg]

He’s not close to being good. He’s an average player that needs to go if we are to progress up the ladder in the future

He has a go for now. But the future is different . Murphy

 

[Hugg]

It has worked OK in the past, can't see how Cox in the goal square would have been worse than de Goey was today.

Absolutely correct....tell the selectors.
Ffs......

 

[swoop42]

Out: Thomas, C.Brown

In: Murphy, Bianco

One less small required up against a mature side like Geelong.

 

[KillerMagpies]

This says a lot about where our team is at, “There are worse than Noble!”... that guy should not be distributing off half back.

 

[KillerMagpies]

B Quaynor Roughead Bruz
HB Murphy Moore
C WHE Daicos Poulter
HF Pendles Checkers Sidebottom
F Cameron DeGoey McReery
Foll Grundy Crisp Adams
INT Wilson Noble Bianco Thomas

No.
More.
Browns!!!

 

[KillerMagpies]

B Quaynor Roughead Bruz
HB Murphy Moore
C WHE Daicos Poulter
HF Pendles Checkers Sidebottom
F Cameron DeGoey McReery
Foll Grundy Crisp Adams
INT Wilson Noble Bianco Thomas

No.
More.
Browns!!!

I forgot Mayne on the HBF!

 

[stevebbb]

Outs: JT, B1 and B2
Ins: Murphy, anybody and anybody

Though I'm expecting no changes, because we almost beat a top 4 side, and Bucks will ramble all week about "intent"