Preview Changes/Preview – Round 10 vs Yartapuulti @ Adelaide Oval

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
has Joel Smith been playing forward in VFL? Even if he hasn't I'm keen.
He has and Smith looked quite dynamic at times. Looked to be moving well, presented at the ball up to the wings. Kicking at goal OK without being outstanding.

In and out of the games a bit, but that’s true for all the VFL taller forwards.
 
Visceral reactions

Hunter - I really like how Jayden continues to take the tackler on despite having no idea how to get past.

My first thought when I saw Hunters name was 'he better go down the ''jayden'' path with this!'

Was not disappointed.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Time to unleash Joel forward on the comp. Poor Port, they have no idea how much he's going to destroy them.
Being serious, I hope it’s either Schache or Smith to come in. Each option would give a different look to see if it works.

But Goodwin on AFL360 just flagged it will be one of Brown or Tmac to come in. Each are allegedly in good form at VFL according to Simon.
 
Being serious, I hope it’s either Schache or Smith to come in. Each option would give a different look to see if it works.

But Goodwin on AFL360 just flagged it will be one of Brown or Tmac to come in.

Yep, Id rather the Shaq Attack also.

Im not angry or surprised, just disappointed. :(
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

But Goodwin on AFL360 just flagged it will be one of Brown or Tmac to come in. Each are allegedly in good form at VFL according to Simon.

Season 5 No GIF by The Office
 
I'd go with Max 80% forward and let Grundy ruck for most of the game. Needing to bring in another tall for Petty is dumb, but it's Simon's DNA so I expect it to happen.
Don’t get this tbh. Goodwin has been incredibly flexible this year. We’re playing undersized in defence which we’ve never done before, we’re not relying on the same three clearance mids at every bounce, and we’re playing four small forwards. We 100% need to bring in a tall for Petty because right now our only talls are May, Lever, JvR and the two rucks. As we saw last week, we don’t have the timber if one of them goes down because there’s nobody to get on a long lead.
 
Don’t get this tbh. Goodwin has been incredibly flexible this year. We’re playing undersized in defence which we’ve never done before, we’re not relying on the same three clearance mids at every bounce, and we’re playing four small forwards. We 100% need to bring in a tall for Petty because right now our only talls are May, Lever, JvR and the two rucks. As we saw last week, we don’t have the timber if one of them goes down because there’s nobody to get on a long lead.

What exactly do you expect TMac and Brown to do? both useless on the long lead so it forces JVR further away from goal to do the donkey work. If a long lead is what youre after give me Schache then.
 
Let's play a tall for the sake of playing a tall is mind bogglingly silly. Both of them are absolute crap and we are giving them a game cause their tall?

As has been shown over years and years in this game having players who actually contribute not who are taller than a certain height is what matters.
 
Let's play a tall for the sake of playing a tall is mind bogglingly silly. Both of them are absolute crap and we are giving them a game cause their tall?

As has been shown over years and years in this game having players who actually contribute not who are taller than a certain height is what matters.
So don't try to exploit Ports weakness in lack of tall defenders?

Sent from my SM-S908E using Tapatalk
 
Ben Brown kicked three goals in each of his three games and brought the ball down from contests when he did not mark it. Then he got injured.

I don't see the problem with him coming back as long as he is over his injury because he does not play well when carrying an injury.

Brown should also get the best tall defender which will help JVR because playing someone with less than 10 games against the best defender each week is not a fair ask.

Whichever of Brown or McDonald gets selected and does not perform then they will be dropped that is the line in the sand Goodwin has shown quite clearly.
 
Very frustrating if we bring in one of the dinosaurs but I understand whilst Joel smith is a novel idea TMac and brown are more trustworthy in the eyes of the coaches. In reality if we lose the game I doubt it’s purely because petty is out.
Tbf Petty has been pretty shit for most of the year anyway.

Was doing his best TMac impersonation of bullying a shit team last week until he got injured

Sent from my SM-S908E using Tapatalk
 
So don't try to exploit Ports weakness in lack of tall defenders?

Sent from my SM-S908E using Tapatalk
With who? Brown who plays nothing like a tall and McDonald who sucks? What are we gonna do just pump it long in the air all game to 'exploit' them. Crap plan. Just hit up targets and use Fritsch Chandler and Pickett not crap talls just cause they are tall.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top