List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[JuniorB]

Neither is pinning your hopes on Lord, who’s nowhere near being a certainty to make it.

If we were going to have to trade for him, we might just as well draft one this year and not have to come up with trade capital.

 

[HoraceStrasbork]

Noooooo
Please god noo
Noooooo

 

[mumblingpie]

Getting bit confused as to what direction fly is taking, he does realise that we are an old team doesn’t he

 

[Scodog10]

Scodog10 … care to explain why ??

I mean you know why! A KPP cut after only two years in the system without debuting is just a waste of a list spot. Best case scenario for him and Collingwood is 2023 Eyre.

 

[HoraceStrasbork]

Neither are any good. That’s like saying drinking piss is better than eating shit.

 

[Matt_352]

Getting bit confused as to what direction fly is taking, he does realise that we are an old team doesn’t he

Probably thinks we are capable of contending again next year, I agree with that. Need to strike the right balance.

 

[JLC]

If we were going to have to trade for him, we might just as well draft one this year and not have to come up with trade capital.

In the whole tenure of Hine dawg how many tall forwards that he has recruited have kicked four goals in a final? Lord showed that he is pretty agile and clean below his knees. Lord is plug n play.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Getting bit confused as to what direction fly is taking, he does realise that we are an old team doesn’t he

Who is more likely to replace our older players in 2026?

A late pick raw 18 year old who may or not make it. Or a 25 year old who has proven himself at AFL level?

I know which I would prefer.

 

[Fat Jesus]

Neither are any good. That’s like saying drinking piss is better than eating shit.

I've been drinking piss most of my life. Go ahead though Stronz and eat shit.

 

[manicpie]

Neither are any good. That’s like saying drinking piss is better than eating shit.

They've both played more AFL than us. That should be respected not spoken about like they're sub human.

 

[sr36]

Neither are any good. That’s like saying drinking piss is better than eating shit.

Footy clubs need a Tommo and a Macca. Is it happening Stronza?

 

[magpies42]

They've both played more AFL than us. That should be respected not spoken about like they're sub human.

Anybody that is paid and underperforms is ridiculed. Footballers are not immune.

 

[Stronzatello]

I've been drinking piss most of my life. Go ahead though Stronz and eat shit.

Hahah that’s a good one Jesù!!

 

[Stronzatello]

Footy clubs need a Tommo and a Macca. Is it happening Stronza?

Chance. I knew the stringer mail. Club is keen on brining on Tomlinson but it’s not a high priority just yet.

 

[sr36]

Getting bit confused as to what direction fly is taking, he does realise that we are an old team doesn’t he

Filling holes for free and thus leaving us our recruiting chips for longer term prospects. Fine by me. It's the way to go. Not sure if Tomlinson is the man, but we might get to find out next year

 

[manicpie]

Anybody that is paid and underperforms is ridiculed. Footballers are not immune.

I know but to class them as shit and piss is a bit harsh. Could've just called them spuds. I'm old school and if you're not prepared to tell that to a person's face, then you shouldn't say it. I'm not doubting anyone has underperformed

 

[HoraceStrasbork]

They've both played more AFL than us. That should be respected not spoken about like they're sub human.

 

[manicpie]

View attachment 2122632

looked like Scrote at first

 

[domus]

Getting bit confused as to what direction fly is taking, he does realise that we are an old team doesn’t he

In reference to what? Sorry, I'm late to this thread.

 

[swoop42]

Our tall defensive stocks look like the weakest link in our chain for season 2025 IMO.

Outside of Moore, you've got the bluest of blue collar options in Frampton and the still unknown quantity of Dean and Eyre who may or may not be on our list next year..

In the medium tall stocks we've got Howe, Maynard and not much else that is yet proven.

Tomlinson has played 185 career games and his opportunity at Melbourne has been impacted due to the presence of May, Lever, McDonald and Petty.

He'll cost nothing in terms of trade, little in salary and will provide experienced depth in an area of need.

While a strong case could be made for taking a midfielder should we gain pick 12 from the GC (I wont complain if we do), if you take a look at our list we're really in need of Tomlinson and 1 or 2 KPP prospects taken at the draft with the likes of Johnson and Kreuger unlikely to make the grade and Reef still in line to be de-listed.

Hopefully a Perryman, McGuane and a FA signing or two across this season and next can take care of our midfield needs in the short to medium term.

 

[jmac70]

In reference to what? Sorry, I'm late to this thread.

Are you happy that we are in the mix for Perryman?

 

[asongofnightsandliars]

Do we take Tay Adams back from Sydney? So long as it's for almost nothing

On SM-A146P using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[HyPIEcrite]

Our tall defensive stocks look like the weakest link in our chain for season 2025 IMO.

Outside of Moore, you've got the bluest of blue collar options in Frampton and the still unknown quantity of Dean and Eyre who may or may not be on our list next year..

In the medium tall stocks we've got Howe, Maynard and not much else that is yet proven.

Tomlinson has played 185 career games and his opportunity at Melbourne has been impacted due to the presence of May, Lever, McDonald and Petty.

He'll cost nothing in terms of trade, little in salary and will provide experienced depth in an area of need.

While a strong case could be made for taking a midfielder should we gain pick 12 from the GC (I wont complain if we do), if you take a look at our list we're really in need of Tomlinson and 1 or 2 KPP prospects taken at the draft with the likes of Johnson and Kreuger unlikely to make the grade and Reef still in line to be de-listed.

Hopefully a Perryman, McGuane and a FA signing or two across this season and next can take care of our midfield needs in the short to medium term.

Where is someone like Jakob Ryan at? Don’t get to see much VFL. Is he just not coming along?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Do we take Tay Adams back from Sydney? So long as it's for almost nothing

On SM-A146P using BigFooty.com mobile app

As if he'd come back to the Pies with his tail between his legs.

Particularly as he has 2 more years on his contract with the Swans.

 

[sr36]

Our tall defensive stocks look like the weakest link in our chain for season 2025 IMO.

Outside of Moore, you've got the bluest of blue collar options in Frampton and the still unknown quantity of Dean and Eyre who may or may not be on our list next year..

In the medium tall stocks we've got Howe, Maynard and not much else that is yet proven.

Tomlinson has played 185 career games and his opportunity at Melbourne has been impacted due to the presence of May, Lever, McDonald and Petty.

He'll cost nothing in terms of trade, little in salary and will provide experienced depth in an area of need.

While a strong case could be made for taking a midfielder should we gain pick 12 from the GC (I wont complain if we do), if you take a look at our list we're really in need of Tomlinson and 1 or 2 KPP prospects taken at the draft with the likes of Johnson and Kreuger unlikely to make the grade and Reef still in line to be de-listed.

Hopefully a Perryman, McGuane and a FA signing or two across this season and next can take care of our midfield needs in the short to medium term.

I'm with you - 185 games and most of them in pretty good teams. I think he'll bre more than depth and be best 22 if we get him. Plus I like Moore playing deepest which is what will occur with Tomlinson, but couldn't happen with Billy.