Player Watch Jack Ginnivan (Traded to Hawks 2023)

[sideswipe]

Think comments by Hine are interesting. If you can't run you can't play.

I think we traded Ginni when he had his highest value. If he stayed he wouldn't have played regularly and his market value dropped.

Problem is that we didn't trade him for his highest value.

 

[Fat Jesus]

We got the best any team was willing to give for Ginnivan.
That's the way it works right?

 

[sr36]

Problem is that we didn't trade him for his highest value.

Not sure about that. He's a slow small forward - they're not in high demand.

 

[sideswipe]

Not sure about that. He's a slow small forward - they're not in high demand.

I'm not too fussed about it, but we basically traded him to move 6 spots up the draft in the 30s. I'd call that about a bagatelle.

 

[sr36]

I'm not too fussed about it, but we basically traded him to move 6 spots up the draft in the 30s. I'd call that about a bagatelle.

Next years round 2 upgrade would be valued to be the bigger part of the trade - might not work out that way though.

 

[Chameleon75]

I'm not too fussed about it, but we basically traded him to move 6 spots up the draft in the 30s. I'd call that about a bagatelle.

when the hawks trade him to Bunnings for a makita drill it’ll look like a steal

 

[cfc19902010]

I'd say that the main difference is that Freo traded most of those players when they were coming into their prime and the club didn't want to lose them. As evidenced by the Freo list going on to be best 22 at their next clubs, not to mention the several AA's, Brownlow's, Coleman medal etc. The only player that we didn't want to go was Henry.

Half of that Collingwood list wouldn't get a game with us at full strength, yet we always think other clubs should pay more for players that we don't even want.

I mean, they even threw Poulter on there like he was one who got away!

ginnivan would definitely get a game from what I saw on Friday

 

[Jasper84]

ginnivan would definitely get a game from what I saw on Friday

Oh good, we're doing this again. Ginnivan was the sub for us in 2 finals and was swapped in the GF for Lippa. If Adams was available he was either taking Lippa or Ginnivan's spot, probably the spot of the guy who took GF week as a joke. Now we have Schultz. All the info available indicates that despite Ginnivan doing well for Hawthorn, he wasn't best 22 for us.

Edit: I didn't even include Harrison and Richards coming on this year in Ginnivan's spot

 

[cfc19902010]

Oh good, we're doing this again. Ginnivan was the sub for us in 2 finals and was swapped in the GF for Lippa. If Adams was available he was either taking Lippa or Ginnivan's spot, probably the spot of the guy who took GF week as a joke. Now we have Schultz. All the info available indicates that despite Ginnivan doing well for Hawthorn, he wasn't best 22 for us.

Edit: I didn't even include Harrison and Richards coming on this year in Ginnivan's spot

Gee

Calm down and take a breath
Ginnivan is clearly better than Richards Harrison.
You can go on until the cows come home about last year but this year he’s looking very complete and fit
He walks into our side this year if he was still on list

 

[No SPIN]

Gee

Calm down and take a breath
Ginnivan is clearly better than Richards Harrison.
You can go on until the cows come home about last year but this year he’s looking very complete and fit
He walks into our side this year if he was still on list

Ginnivan is too slow, HH won the sprint at the combine, and has more positional flexibility. I’m taking HH every time over Ginnivan.
What does Ginnivan offer over Richards?

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

What a cocky little shit. Please Port. Humble these blokes.

 

[Markfs]

What does Ginnivan offer over Richards?

he kicks goals?

 

[jmac70]

What a cocky little shit. Please Port. Humble these blokes.

I don’t think Sam would be happy with that.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

I don’t think Sam would be happy with that.

I can only put myself in the position of a supporter if he played for us..and I know I wouldn't be over the moon about this.

Definitely wouldn't fit in with Fly's 'remain humble' attitude.

I hope like hell it motivates Port to pull something out of their arse this week

 

[cfc19902010]

Ginnivan is too slow, HH won the sprint at the combine, and has more positional flexibility. I’m taking HH every time over Ginnivan.
What does Ginnivan offer over Richards?

richards and Harrison haven't even established themselves in our team .Ginny might be slow but he knows where the goals are and how to get the ball ..and hes got a lot more tricks than HH and Joe combined

 

[riddick78]

What a cocky little shit. Please Port. Humble these blokes.

He's like Toby Green, but without the talent.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

He's like Toby Green, but without the talent.

He's nothing like Toby.

Toby hasn't been caught doing lines, going out before finals or posting stuff like that on sm. He's not an attention seeker like Ginni

 

[No SPIN]

richards and Harrison haven't even established themselves in our team .Ginny might be slow but he knows where the goals are and how to get the ball ..and hes got a lot more tricks than HH and Joe combined

What tricks? And please don’t say ducking!!

 

[cfc19902010]

What tricks? And please don’t say ducking!!

kicking difficult goals is one

 

[No SPIN]

kicking difficult goals is one

lol - 1.2 goals, and HH has scored 0.90 in 11 games and Richards 0.50.in 11 games
That you even think those numbers make Ginnivan a starter in our team is laughable.

 

[cfc19902010]

lol - 1.2 goals, and HH has scored 0.90 in 11 games and Richards 0.50.in 11 games
That you even think those numbers make Ginnivan a starter in our team is laughable.

ginny would definitely get a game with us atm ..in my opinion

 

[PieBeast]

I propose Ginnivan gets put into a swear filter and is replaced by shitcampaigner

 

[sideswipe]

He's nothing like Toby.

Toby hasn't been caught doing lines, going out before finals or posting stuff like that on sm. He's not an attention seeker like Ginni

To be fair to Ginni, he hasn’t copped to an assault charge. And a pretty ordinary one at that.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[JLC]

To be fair to Ginni, he hasn’t copped to an assault charge. And a pretty ordinary one at that.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Toby was a proper bad boy. He would be one of the lads running the 'gang'

Ginni comes across as a wannabe trying to get in the 'gang'.

 

[Piesinmyeyes]

Toby was a proper bad boy. He would be one of the lads running the 'gang'

Ginni comes across as a wannabe trying to get in the 'gang

Simply
One earned a reputation for being a thug
The other has a reputation for being ultra smug.