List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[cakewalk06]

A year 10 drop out but I had a great footy career, lol

As long as you were a chick magnet as well that is a massive win in my book

 

[manicpie]

As long as you were a chick magnet as well that is a massive win in my book

I had better luck at school

 

[cfc19902010]

26-30 is fair

Some of the calls in here for pick 12 are ridiculous. I'd like to hear the uproar if we were using pick 12 to recruit him in

Yes but he’s contracted and we are the seller so the purchaser has to pay more to dislodge

 

[SchuPie]

I think 12 for Noble + F1 is a possibility.

I would hope F1 = at least 12 (not including Noble)
(Or picks ~19+20)

 

[rdangelo]

Yes but he’s contracted and we are the seller so the purchaser has to pay more to dislodge

Or you can let him go in twelve months for pick 44

 

[MooreDaicos]

Or you can let him go in twelve months for pick 44

Contracted till 2026

 

[manicpie]

Or you can let him go in twelve months for pick 44

So be it. They're the ones that want him now

 

[Go Woods]

And these people will be annoyed once trade week starts and GC are offering pick 38.

They know what they can do with that suggestion.....

 

[Go Woods]

He's not staying. Nor will the club force him too. The deal will be done.

For pick 20 at least.

 

[Jen2310]

I would hope F1 = at least 12 (not including Noble)
(Or picks ~19+20)

Yeah would have to be a little more


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mick F]

Trading can also be hit and miss. It’s not like trading in a 30 yo guarantees you a premiership either. We have a bad record of trading first round picks for players

Cameron has been a fine pick up. But we have traded in a few gumbies over the years.

 

[AmericanMustard]

I think 12 for Noble + F1 is a possibility.

I still think this is a terrible outcome. I’d rather just take 20 or whatever it is or tell Gold Coast to deal with it

 

[Mick F]

pre trade picks are done.

Fremantle will be a team to watch in October, with the Dockers holding picks 9, 10 and 16 as they target the likes of Richmond pair Shai Bolton and Liam Baker.


Gold Coast also has three first-round picks - 6, 12 and 20 - as they look to bring in Daniel Rioli and John Noble during the trade period.

The draft order could still change before the trade period begins on October 7, with free agency compensation picks yet to be decided by the AFL.


The likes of Josh Battle, Harry Perryman and Isaac Cumming are among the free agents expected to find a new home in October, which would trigger compensation for their current clubs.


The Free Agency window runs from October 4-11, with the trade period to start on October 7 and finish on October 16.


The 2024 Telstra AFL Draft will be held on November 20-21.

Your club's draft picks as of September 29, 2024​

Adelaide: 4, 25, 42, 60
Brisbane: 18, 56, 69
Carlton: 11, 31, 62, 65, 68
Collingwood: 33, 48, 51
Essendon: 8, 28
Fremantle: 9, 10, 16, 27, 63
Geelong: 15, 35, 53, 71
Gold Coast: 6, 12, 20, 26, 38, 46, 74
Greater Western Sydney: 14, 34, 49, 52, 70
Hawthorn: 13, 30, 67, 73
Melbourne: 5, 37, 45, 50, 61
North Melbourne: 2, 22, 40, 58, 64
Port Adelaide: 36, 54
Richmond: 1, 21, 29, 39, 41, 47, 57, 66, 72
St Kilda: 7, 24, 43
Sydney: 17, 19, 55
West Coast: 3, 23, 59
Western Bulldogs: 32, 44

Indicative Draft Order as of September 29, 2024​

ROUND ONE​
1	Richmond
2	North Melbourne
3	West Coast
4	Adelaide
5	Melbourne
6	Gold Coast
7	St Kilda
8	Essendon
9	Fremantle
10	Fremantle (tied to Collingwood)
11	Carlton
12	Gold Coast (tied to Western Bulldogs)
13	Hawthorn
14	Greater Western Sydney
15	Geelong
16	Fremantle (tied to Port Adelaide)
17	Sydney
18	Brisbane
19	Sydney (North Melbourne assistance package selection)
20	Gold Coast (North Melbourne assistance package selection)

ROUND TWO​
21	Richmond
22	North Melbourne
23	West Coast
24	St Kilda (tied to Adelaide)
25	Adelaide (tied to Melbourne)
26	Gold Coast
27	Fremantle (tied to St Kilda)
28	Essendon
29	Richmond (tied to Fremantle)
30	Hawthorn (tied to Collingwood)
31	Carlton
32	Western Bulldogs
33	Collingwood (tied to Hawthorn)
34	Greater Western Sydney
35	Geelong
36	Port Adelaide
37	Melbourne (tied to Sydney)
38	Gold Coast (tied to Brisbane)

ROUND THREE​
39	Richmond
40	North Melbourne
41	Richmond (tied to West Coast)
42	Adelaide
43	St Kilda (tied to Melbourne)
44	Western Bulldogs (tied to Gold Coast)
45	Melbourne (tied to St Kilda)
46	Gold Coast (tied to Essendon)
47	Richmond (tied to Fremantle)
48	Collingwood
49	Greater Western Sydney (tied to Carlton)
50	Melbourne (tied to Western Bulldogs)
51	Collingwood (tied to Hawthorn)
52	Greater Western Sydney
53	Geelong
54	Port Adelaide
55	Sydney
56	Brisbane

ROUND FOUR​
57	Richmond
58	North Melbourne
59	West Coast
60	Adelaide
61	Melbourne
62	Carlton (tied to Gold Coast)
63	Fremantle (tied to St Kilda)
64	North Melbourne (tied to Essendon)
65	Carlton (tied to Fremantle)
66	Richmond (tied to Collingwood)
67	Hawthorn (tied to Carlton)
68	Carlton (tied to Western Bulldogs)
69	Brisbane (tied to Hawthorn)
70	Greater Western Sydney
71	Geelong
72	Richmond (tied to Port Adelaide)
73	Hawthorn (tied to Sydney)
74	Gold Coast (tied to Brisbane)

2025 DRAFT SELECTIONS TRADED​

	IN	OUT
Adelaide
Brisbane
Carlton
Collingwood
Essendon
Fremantle
Geelong
Gold Coast
GWS Giants
Hawthorn
Melbourne
North Melbourne
Port Adelaide
Richmond
St Kilda
Sydney
West Coast
Western Bulldogs

2024 Draft Value Index​

Round One	Round Two	Round Three	Round Four	Round Five
Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​
1. 3000	19. 948	37. 483	55. 207	73. 9
2. 2517	20. 912	38. 465	56. 194	74. -
3. 2234	21. 878	39. 446	57. 182	75. -
4. 2034	22. 845	40. 429	58. 170	76. -
5. 1878	23. 815	41. 412	59. 158	77. -
6. 1751	24. 785	42. 395	60. 146	78. -
7. 1644	25. 756	43. 378	61. 135	79. -
8. 1551	26. 729	44. 362	62. 123	80. -
9. 1469	27. 703	45. 347	63. 112	81. -
10. 1395	28. 677	46. 331	64. 101	82. -
11. 1329	29. 653	47. 316	65. 90	83 -
12. 1268	30. 629	48. 302	66. 80
13. 1212	31. 606	49. 287	67. 69
14. 1161	32. 584	50. 273	68. 59
15. 1112	33. 563	51. 259	69. 49
16. 1067	34. 542	52. 246	70. 39
17. 1025	35. 522	53. 233	71. 29
18. 985	36. 502	54. 220	72. 19

2025 Draft Value Index​

Round One	Round Two	Round Three	Round Four	Round Five
Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​	Pick/Pts​
1. 3000	19. 796	37. 297	55. -	73. -
2. 2481	20. 757	38. 277	56. -	74. -
3. 2178	21. 721	39. 257	57. -
4. 1962	22. 686	40. 238	58. -
5. 1795	23. 653	41. 220	59. -
6. 1659	24. 621	42. 202	60. -
7. 1543	25. 590	43. 184	61. -
8. 1443	26. 561	44. 167	62. -
9. 1355	27. 533	45. 150	63. -
10. 1276	28. 505	46. 134	64. -
11. 1205	29. 479

4	48. 102	66. -
13. 1080	31. 429	49. 86	67. -
14. 1024	32. 405	50. 71	68. -
15. 973	33. 382	51. 57	69. -
16. 924	34. 360	52. 42	70. -
17. 879	35. 338	53. 28	71. -
18. 836	36. 317	54. 14	72. -

​

Hence why McRae indicated we didn’t have the trade capital to be chasing Petracca and Houston.

 

[Matt_352]

I think 12 for Noble + F1 is a possibility.

For Noble and F1 id be wanting 12 and 20. :/

 

[Apex36]

I’m now at a point where I don’t want Houston because of how damn good he is I just want him because of how much it’ll piss off Seedsfan!

Congratulations you’ve reached my level of pettiness

 

[MooreDaicos]

I still think this is a terrible outcome. I’d rather just take 20 or whatever it is or tell Gold Coast to deal with it

Agree, otherwise they get noble for a packet of chips. I wouldn't do that deal.

 

[thommo_legend]

Tom Morris on the news just said it's down to North and Carlton for Houston

 

[Tadpole]

I want him just for the name. Imagine being able to scream out “kick it Faulkhead!”

I don't however want the guy coming through in the next few years with the also unfortunate name of Wes Walley. I heard he goes missing in games frequently.

 

[Stronzatello]

Houston won’t be coming to Collingwood. It’s Carlton or north, as per tom Morris on 9 news. We were never keen nor should we be. We will be seeking to stockpile some picks and atone for last year’s disaster!

 

[manicpie]

Tom Morris on the news just said it's down to North and Carlton for Houston

I thought Barrett was just talking shit. can't see us giving up everything for Dan.

 

[Tadpole]

Should get some Tomorrow

Trade Radio is back

I'd rather poke my eyes out with a rusty nail than listen to that.

 

[Apex36]

26-30 is fair

Some of the calls in here for pick 12 are ridiculous. I'd like to hear the uproar if we were using pick 12 to recruit him in

Reading comprehension is important. Literally nobody has said Noble is worth pick 12. It has been widely reported though that the club are targeting pick 12 and Noble could be a part of that.

It’s not that hard. And 26-30 is fair if Noble wasn’t a best 22 player under contract. In that case slight overs is generally the norm which is around pick 20.

 

[Harry O]

So you all disagree yet can’t come up with anything to support your stance. Then get angry and personal. Perhaps you should reflect upon yourself

Josh Dunkley ?

 

[Jen2310]

Well that was a fun 12 hrs haha

 

[Apex36]

I think 12 for Noble + F1 is a possibility.

That would be an awful deal for us