List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[TradeDraft]

Fake website. Next story down says that Travis cloke is dead

Was very easy after a real quick look that it was just Fake

 

[jmac70]

Report: Collingwood Secure GWS Giants Star Harry Perryman now joins team

In a significant boost to their 2025 AFL campaign, Collingwood Football Club is poised to secure the services of GWS Giants utility Harry

realsport4u.com

Why post a fake site?

 

[HoraceStrasbork]

Unfortunately Ginni seemed to value commitment to the cause and professional standards at about a half eaten packet of chips.

What’s everyone’s fixation with chips all about ? Surely there’s some folk who like toasted pita bread

 

[Moore of the Same]

Any chance we're looking at Matthew Kennedy? Good size, could fit into our midfield.

 

[Apex36]

Report: Collingwood Secure GWS Giants Star Harry Perryman now joins team

In a significant boost to their 2025 AFL campaign, Collingwood Football Club is poised to secure the services of GWS Giants utility Harry

realsport4u.com

Ah yes, the well established and trusted realsport4u. A true staple of any genuine sporting news.

 

[adammania9]

F1 + Noble should be fair for 12 & 20. Every chance that our first in 12 months is a top 10 pick… and they’re also getting a strategic win from this

I don’t disagree but for GC to take it, we’d have to add in something extra. Considering the strength of this draft, and the fact that future picks hold less value due to the time it takes to use them, our future first might only be worth pick 20 in this draft.

 

[Scodog10]

Oh you can approach the negotiations like that no probs. But I wouldn’t expect to be walking away with 12 for Noble and I doubt that’s your genuine expectation either.

That is my expectation if Rioli goes for 6. The difference in the two is marginal and unless it’s something like us slinging pick 50 with Noble I’d rather we keep him than tying in our future 1st or taking 20 which winds up at around 27.

Don’t get me wrong he’s not worth 12, but that probably pushes to 17 which is about right for a dashing half back they’ve targeted with 2 years to run on his contract. With no prospect of Houston keeping Noble is fine by me.

 

[Apex36]

It was on Facebook so probably fake.

It’s clickbait. Headline says we’ve secured him but the article says we’re front runners and refers to Twomey etc.

 

[lyfsux]

Fake website. Next story down says that Travis cloke is dead

And the thing that pissed me off was that I went searching to see if it was true

 

[MooreDaicos]

I'd like to see...

Our 3 picks for Lions F1st pick
Noble, our F1st for Suns 12+20...............or.................(Noble, our F2nd for Suns pick 12)

We end up with

12, 20, F1st Richards pick............................................12, 2xF1sts, Richards pick

Trade Lions F1st for Tigers F2nd+F3rd (current 3rd) or (another clubs picks)

Sound good or have I stuffed it up? I'm tired

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Oscar Faulkhead has been delisted by GC. Very good player who probably won't get a game in their midfield.

That does make it harder for him to get minutes, yes.

 

[PiesHateU2]

No flag, no BNF, no all Aus and didn’t play 100 games for two top 10 picks. If that was the return we got from the draft picks you’d say they were a bust

Only reason Ads didn't play 100 games for us is because we forcibly offloaded him in an attempt to fix our woeful salary cap situation. There is no parallel universe in which he can be considered a bust. If I recall correctly, he led our Brownlow votes one year and gave it a real shake. Was /is also a genuinely good human. I loved Adam Treloar as a Pie

 

[PiesHateU2]

Like I said "Schrodinger's draft picks" vs a known quantity

WTF is Schrodinger?

 

[jmac70]

Only reason Ads didn't play 100 games for us is because we forcibly offloaded him in an attempt to fix our woeful salary cap situation. There is no parallel universe in which he can be considered a bust. If I recall correctly, he led our Brownlow votes one year and gave it a real shake. Was /is also a genuinely good human. I loved Adam Treloar as a Pie

Please don’t start this up again!

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Someone needs a proof reader for that article lol the writer has no clue

Benefactors when he meant beneficiaries.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Report: Collingwood Secure GWS Giants Star Harry Perryman now joins team

In a significant boost to their 2025 AFL campaign, Collingwood Football Club is poised to secure the services of GWS Giants utility Harry

realsport4u.com

You just have to read beyond the headline to see that it’s all recycled stuff we already know, and the headline is fabricated clickbait.

 

[Ugene41]

Even if Houston is not on the agenda, I'd be looking at Noble + F1 + 33 for 12 and 20 and taking those picks to the draft.

We shouldn't need to package pick 33 with that

 

[FromTheBoundaryLine]

 

[rdangelo]

Reading comprehension is important. Literally nobody has said Noble is worth pick 12. It has been widely reported though that the club are targeting pick 12 and Noble could be a part of that.

It’s not that hard. And 26-30 is fair if Noble wasn’t a best 22 player under contract. In that case slight overs is generally the norm which is around pick 20.

You take 20 every day of the week but don't be surprised if we take 26 or low 30s.

 

[soreplums]

1st I heard of that Website

According to that website we secured Perryman on a 38 million € transfer and we are mourning the tragic passing of Travis Cloke…. Without his name mentioned, only photos of him.

 

[FromTheBoundaryLine]

Report: Collingwood Secure GWS Giants Star Harry Perryman now joins team

In a significant boost to their 2025 AFL campaign, Collingwood Football Club is poised to secure the services of GWS Giants utility Harry

realsport4u.com

Collingwood secure, Collingwood set to secure, Collingwood poised to secure, Collingwood front runners to secure ………………

 

[adammania9]

We shouldn't need to package pick 33 with that

We’ll need to. Future picks aren’t worth as much as current picks

 

[Jen2310]

We’ll need to. Future picks aren’t worth as much as current picks

They are when the suns have a couple academy prospects in 2025

 

[adammania9]

They are when the suns have a couple academy prospects in 2025

The Suns will be dealing pick 12 most likely, and there’s no shortage of clubs that will be interested. I’d love to get 12+20 for future first and Noble but I think other clubs can put up better offers.

Let’s say Noble is worth bang on pick 20 and that’s being generous to us, this draft is supposedly very good so pick 12 this year will be worth more than pick 12 next year. Also naturally clubs are in the business of building a list right now as opposed to in the future, so the time factor also devalues future picks.

If we’re on track to get Houston, the Suns won’t do the trade because with Houston we should be a top 4 side next year. If no Houston, we might be more likely but I still can’t see it. The Suns could deal that pick to Carlton and trade for Noble separately. Pick 12 is the most valuable commodity in the two club’s trade discussions.

The Suns also don’t need to bank the points right now for Uwland. They’ve got 12 months to figure it out.

 

[TradeDraft]

According to that website we secured Perryman on a 38 million € transfer and we are mourning the tragic passing of Travis Cloke…. Without his name mentioned, only photos of him.

Saw that and gave me a Laugh