MVP Freo BF POTY - Votes vs Geelong

[Dr2Sheds]

5 - Fyfe
4 - Mzungu
3 - Johnson
2 - DeBoer
1 - Sandilands

BYB - Clarke

 

[prattsta]

5 Fyfe
4 Mzungu
3 Sandilands
2 Johnson
1 Ballantyne

Deciding who to give 1 vote to was pretty tricky.

BYB Clarke

Mellington very unlucky.

 

[cp3_jr]

5. Fyfe: Gun.
4. Ballas: Everywhere and worked his backside off all day.
3. Sandi: Dominant early and in the ruck
2. Mzungu: racked it up, ran hard, clean disposal
0.5 Clarke: Presented hard all day and finished off up forward
0.5 Deboer: Great marking and physical presence as usual

Unlucky: Barlow (was on track for 40 touches and 3 goals considering he only played les than a third of the game), Johnson (solid as the loose man), Pav & mello

BYB: Clarke

Mello very unlucky

 

[jmadrox]

5. Fyfe
4. Sandilands
3. Balla
2. Mzungu
1. Pav

BYB: Clarke!

Mello get a few more touches, and he gets it

 

[willoblue]

5. Fyfe
4. Ballantyne
3. Mzungu
2. Sandilands
1. Johnson

BYB Clarke (Mellington, very close)

 

[bfff]

5 Fyfe
4 Sandilands
3 Duffield
2 Johnson
1 Mzungu

BYB Clarke

 

[Moo]

Still can't believe how overrated Pav's performances are in these MVP threads. Do any of you people vote on the Doig by any chance?

I was tempted to give him a vote for just being in the forward line.

 

[Clay Davis]

I was tempted to give him a vote for just being in the forward line.

haha

 

[Outshined]

5. Ballantyne
4. Fyfe
3. Johnson
2. Sandi
1. Mzungu

BYB: Mellington - because everyone else has voted Clarke

 

[JunglistPosse]

5 Fyfe
4 Sandilands
3 Balla
2 Johnson
1 Mello

 

[Freo_4eva]

5 - Fyfe
4 - Johnson
3 - Sandi
2 - Ballantyne
1 - Duffield

DePig, Mayne, Ibbo all next in line

BYB - Clarke

 

[Reginald Perrin]

I was tempted to give him a vote for just being in the forward line.

Funny.

He wasn't there as much as I'd like though. Would question why he was in the backline so often if it wasn't for the fact that everybody else was there with him.

 

[HowieD]

5. Fyfe
4. Johnson
3. Mzungu
2. Ibbotson
1. Sandilands

 

[Nodgey]

5. Fyfe
4. Ballantyne
3. Sandi
2. Johnson
1. DeBoer

BYB: Clarke

 

[Bad Brain]

5: Ballas
4: Fyfe
3: Johnson
3: Pavlich

BYB: Clarke

 

[PapaJ]

Going to spread mine out, thought there were many good performances at various times:

4. Fyfe
3. Sandi
3. Pav
2. DeBoer
2. MZu
1. Balla

Ibbo, MJ all good games. Elvis, Duffman had their moments too and were good value. Lots of good players in this high quality game.

BYB: Clarke

 

[Pavs_Risotto]

5: Sandilands
4: Fyfe
2: DeBoer
2: Mzungu
2: Johnson

BYB: Clarke

 

[Geoff]

5. Fyfe
4. Pav
3. Ballantyne
2. Sandi
1. Dawson

BYB. Mellington

 

[Harry Reems]

5. Fyfe
4. Sandi
3. Mzungu
2. Johnson
1. Clarke

Ballaz - Great game but the carry on was too much to bear.

Pav, McPharlin and Broughton were below par unfortunately.

 

[Bengraham]

5. Fyfe
4. Sandilands
3. Johnson
2. Mellington
1. Dawson

 

[PapaJ]

Any last minute votes? If so get them in soon, I'll be tallying them up this evening.

 

[tacopavlich]

5. Fyfe
4. Clarke
3. Johnson
2. Sandilands
1. Ballantyne

Might be too late though xD

 

[PapaJ]

Might be too late though xD

Nah, I'll include any votes up until I post results. Even then, if I've got a bit of time and I notice them, I can add retrospectively .... to a point . It's not a big deal.

 

[jusjoshin]

5. the Cleaver (Fat Nyfe)
4. Ballantyne
3. Mzungu
2. Sandi
1. Pav

Loved Zac Clarke and Mellington

 

[estibador]

Re: the people criticising Pav getting votes

You can't have it both ways people - can't whinge that you want Pav stationed up forward and then complain if he doesn't get 30 touches and 10 clearances.

He stood up in the last qtr and won us the game in true superstar fashion by kicking two crunch goals and then sending himself to the backline where he immediately repelled Geelong's last forward thrust with a saving mark.

Easily deserving of a vote or two.