Analysis Let's Construct Our Best 22 - Part 5: Tactical Sub

Scorpus · Mar 13, 2023

Following on from here: Analysis - Let's Construct Our Best 22 - Part 4: Interchange

Our interchange has been selected:

1. Ben Keays (89.8%)
1. Luke Pedlar (89.8%)
3. Rory Sloane (71.4%)
4. Josh Worrell (40.8%)
-------------
5. Max Michalanney (36.7%)
6. Wayne Milera (30.6%)
7. Chayce Jones (18.4%)
8. Elliott Himmelberg (14.3%)
9. Will Hamill (4.1%)
10. Zac Taylor (2.0%)
10. Ned McHenry (2.0%)

OUR BEST 22 IS

B Patrick Parnell - Jordon Butts - Tom Doedee
HB Jordan Dawson - Nick Murray - Brodie Smith

R Reilly O'Brien - Sam Berry - Rory Laird
C Jake Soligo - Harry Schoenberg - Mitch Hinge

HF Izak Rankine - Taylor Walker - Josh Rachele
F Riley Thilthorpe - Darcy Fogarty - Shane McAdam

I Ben Keays - Luke Pedlar - Rory Sloane - Josh Worrell

In 2023 the AFL has also introduced a tactical sub so time to vote for that player. But aside from that, this is the board's general consensus best 22 for the season.

Rotayjay · Mar 13, 2023

I like this thread concept because, whilst it's by no means infallible, I believe there is value in the wisdom of crowds. And this isn't any old crowd - it's a forum of Crows supporters engaged enough to have lengthy selection discussions.

spenze · Mar 13, 2023

Jeez, working on the list picked to be best 22 and it is reasonable, it makes for a very strong SANFL team

Scorpus · Mar 13, 2023

spenze said:
Jeez, working on the list picked to be best 22 and it is reasonable, it makes for a very strong SANFL team

Pending the sub selection here, indeed it is

B Chayce Jones - James Borlase - Max Michalanney
HB Will Hamill - Mark Keane - Wayne Milera

R Kieran Strachan - Matt Crouch - Jackson Hately
C Luke Nankervis - Zac Taylor - Lachlan Sholl

HF Brayden Cook - Elliott Himmelberg - Ned McHenry
F Lachie Murphy - Lachlan Gollant - Tariek Newchurch

I Tyler Brown - Billy Dowling - Hugh Bond - Andrew McPherson

Kane McGoodwin · Mar 13, 2023

I'm not picking a specific sub as I want us to rotate players as sub.

spenze · Mar 13, 2023

Scorpus said:
Pending the sub selection here, indeed it is

B Chayce Jones - James Borlase - Max Michalanney
HB Will Hamill - Mark Keane - Wayne Milera

R Kieran Strachan - Matt Crouch - Jackson Hately
C Luke Nankervis - Zac Taylor - Lachlan Sholl

HF Brayden Cook - Elliott Himmelberg - Ned McHenry
F Lachie Murphy - Lachlan Gollant - Tariek Newchurch

I Tyler Brown - Billy Dowling - Hugh Bond - Andrew McPherson

C'mon, you'd play Matty Wright over Ned

Bearded Clam · Mar 13, 2023

spenze said:
C'mon, you'd play Matty Wright over Ned

You’d play Isaya McKenzie over Murphy too!..

Bearded Clam · Mar 13, 2023

Hell.. I’d even pick Boyle over Hately…

Cromulent · Mar 14, 2023

Have a feeling that Jones is going to feature quite heavily as the Tac Sub this year.. He's versatile, hard, and quick. Perfect 2nd half fresh legs imo.

Danger_zone · Mar 14, 2023

Cromulent said:
Have a feeling that Jones is going to feature quite heavily as the Tac Sub this year.. He's versatile, hard, and quick. Perfect 2nd half fresh legs imo.

I still hope they give Jones full games this year. I know he's not popular on this board, but I believe there's a good player somewhere in there.

Cromulent · Mar 14, 2023

Danger_zone said:
I still hope they give Jones full games this year. I know he's not popular on this board, but I believe there's a good player somewhere in there.

oh, I totally agree with you. I really rate him. He's absolutely in our best 25ish players.

FR0GGY · Mar 15, 2023

Danger_zone said:
I still hope they give Jones full games this year. I know he's not popular on this board, but I believe there's a good player somewhere in there.

What?
He’s too popular on here for his output, if he was a second rounder he’d have been delisted and no one would care.

Scorpus · Mar 15, 2023

Final team is in:

B Patrick Parnell - Jordon Butts - Tom Doedee
HB Jordan Dawson - Nick Murray - Brodie Smith

R Reilly O'Brien - Sam Berry - Rory Laird
C Jake Soligo - Harry Schoenberg - Mitch Hinge

HF Izak Rankine - Taylor Walker - Josh Rachele
F Riley Thilthorpe - Darcy Fogarty - Shane McAdam

I Ben Keays - Luke Pedlar - Rory Sloane - Josh Worrell
S Chayce Jones

Also have some emergencies, the highest voted players not to be selected in the 23. Only have three of them as no one else was in strong contention for the 22

E Max Michalanney - Wayne Milera - Elliott Himmelberg

dogs105 · Mar 15, 2023

Scorpus said:
Final team is in:

B Patrick Parnell - Jordon Butts - Tom Doedee
HB Jordan Dawson - Nick Murray - Brodie Smith

R Reilly O'Brien - Sam Berry - Rory Laird
C Jake Soligo - Harry Schoenberg - Mitch Hinge

HF Izak Rankine - Taylor Walker - Josh Rachele
F Riley Thilthorpe - Darcy Fogarty - Shane McAdam

I Ben Keays - Luke Pedlar - Rory Sloane - Josh Worrell
S Chayce Jones

Also have some emergencies, the highest voted players not to be selected in the 23. Only have three of them as no one else was in strong contention for the 22

E Max Michalanney - Wayne Milera - Elliott Himmelberg

Can't we vote for emergencies?

Scorpus · Mar 15, 2023

dogs105 said:
Can't we vote for emergencies?

Did you want another poll?

dogs105 · Mar 15, 2023

Scorpus said:
Did you want another poll?

Yes please!

martyparty · Mar 15, 2023

Almost certainly, at least two of those emergencies are playing this week (Max & Berg) and a tiny possibility someone who isn’t on that list (Keane) if Butts’ shoulder isn’t right.

Cromulent · Mar 15, 2023

Scorpus said:
Final team is in:

B Patrick Parnell - Jordon Butts - Tom Doedee
HB Jordan Dawson - Nick Murray - Brodie Smith

R Reilly O'Brien - Sam Berry - Rory Laird
C Jake Soligo - Harry Schoenberg - Mitch Hinge

HF Izak Rankine - Taylor Walker - Josh Rachele
F Riley Thilthorpe - Darcy Fogarty - Shane McAdam

I Ben Keays - Luke Pedlar - Rory Sloane - Josh Worrell
S Chayce Jones

Also have some emergencies, the highest voted players not to be selected in the 23. Only have three of them as no one else was in strong contention for the 22

E Max Michalanney - Wayne Milera - Elliott Himmelberg

Time to let BigFooty take over match selection committee, methinks. Well done all.

crows dude · Mar 15, 2023

Swap Jones for Milera though

Australia v India - 4th Test Boxing Day!

Analysis Let's Construct Our Best 22 - Part 5: Tactical Sub

Who should be the tactical sub

Chayce Jones

Lachlan Murphy

Matt Crouch

Jackson Hately

Brayden Cook

Max Michalanney

Will Hamill

Zac Taylor

Tyler Brown

Ned McHenry

Luke Nankervis

Wayne Milera

Billy Dowling

Elliott Himmelberg

James Borlase

Andrew McPherson

Lachlan Sholl

Hugh Bond

Tariek Newchurch

Lachlan Gollant

Kieran Strachan

Mark Keane

Moderator

Brownlow Medallist

Pete won't eat it

Moderator

Make me an Admin!

Pete won't eat it

Premium Platinum

Premium Platinum

A noble spirit embiggens the smallest man.

Premiership Player

A noble spirit embiggens the smallest man.

From a cartel villa in Tuscany

Moderator

Sweet Kennels Proprietor

Moderator

Sweet Kennels Proprietor

Enigmachinist

A noble spirit embiggens the smallest man.

Norm Smith Medallist

Analysis Let's Construct Our Best 22 - Part 5: Tactical Sub

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account