Opinion Matthew Nicks: Adelaide's Coach (Part 3) - The Biggest Loser

Is Matthew Nicks the right coach for Adelaide?

  • Firmly yes (I love what I'm seeing)

  • Leaning yes

  • Can't decide either way

  • Leaning no (but don't sack him yet)

  • Firmly no (he should be sacked)


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

You mention I’m not original so new. Then I correct you. Then you say it doesn’t matter but mention you have been here longer along with some weird justification implying that I may have changed username a couple of times so hiding something. You’re the winner man. Take the prize. 🏆
You were the one who bagged another poster because you were on BF longer like it gives you more credibility.... when posting quality has nothing to do with the time you joined BF!

If you want to be genuine, let us know what username(s) you previously went by.

Why did you feel the need to change usernames? Why hide from your posting history?
 
You were the one who bagged another poster because you were on BF longer like it gives you more credibility.... when posting quality has nothing to do with the time you joined BF!

If you want to be genuine, let us know what username(s) you previously went by.

Why did you feel the need to change usernames? Why hide from your posting history?

clearly its a current suspended posters account, or someone who switches between two or three accounts. Who else writes this way.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

You were the one who bagged another poster because you were on BF longer like it gives you more credibility.... when posting quality has nothing to do with the time you joined BF!

If you want to be genuine, let us know what username(s) you previously went by.

Why did you feel the need to change usernames? Why hide from your posting history?

**** sake. The other poster implied I was new. I mentioned I wasn’t in comparison to them.

It’s like being on trial in here.

AC07
AC09
Jezlobba

I think that’s it. One is a username I like the others are favourite players at the time. T.Edwards and then VB now Thilthorpe.

Hope that checks out for you lot. What evidence would the court like to prove it? Man this is hard work. 😓

1732707371583.png
 
Last edited:
Ok I get the whole professional development thing but why wasn't this done when our season was over during the finals? Why now during pre season when he should be here to lead the group?
Should have been done when he was appointed. Complete waste of money and will only benefit another club when we sack him and he's appointed as an assistant elsewhere. That's if any club will take him which is debatable.
 
You were the one who bagged another poster because you were on BF longer like it gives you more credibility.... when posting quality has nothing to do with the time you joined BF!

If you want to be genuine, let us know what username(s) you previously went by.

Why did you feel the need to change usernames? Why hide from your posting history?


He was Baccs himself up 😃
 
Last edited:
You mention I’m not original so new. Then I correct you. Then you say it doesn’t matter but mention you have been here longer along with some weird justification implying that I may have changed username a couple of times so hiding something. You’re the winner man. Take the prize. 🏆
As you may have noticed there's a heap of perma haters in here. They pretend to be all data driven and unbiased but they're full of it. Best thing to do is just ignore them and let them echo chamber in their little club. There's a fair swag of us who disagree with them but we all have lives so you won't see as much from us as you do from them. Welcome aboard.
 
As you may have noticed there's a heap of perma haters in here. They pretend to be all data driven and unbiased but they're full of it. Best thing to do is just ignore them and let them echo chamber in their little club. There's a fair swag of us who disagree with them but we all have lives so you won't see as much from us as you do from them. Welcome aboard.
Wasn’t it you who posted recently that if you just take off our two oldest players we drop back down to one of the youngest teams?
Conveniently ignoring what happens if you do the same for all teams?
You are the king of cherry picking.

Haters? In case you haven’t been reading the last few years the majority of posters are not a fan of nicks for obvious reasons.
Theres pretty much Wayne and this other bloke left now that disagree.
 
Wasn’t it you who posted recently that if you just take off our two oldest players we drop back down to one of the youngest teams?
Conveniently ignoring what happens if you do the same for all teams?
You are the king of cherry picking.

Haters? In case you haven’t been reading the last few years the majority of posters are not a fan of nicks for obvious reasons.
Theres pretty much Wayne and this other bloke left now that disagree.
Most of us are haters of perennially missing finals & losing most games.

Since when has it been unreasonable to expect your club to have a winning culture?

Says more about those who are happy to accept mediocrity which i never have been able to sit back & accept.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

As you may have noticed there's a heap of perma haters in here. They pretend to be all data driven and unbiased but they're full of it. Best thing to do is just ignore them and let them echo chamber in their little club. There's a fair swag of us who disagree with them but we all have lives so you won't see as much from us as you do from them. Welcome aboard.
If you watch a team have a long period of no success, it's just normal to come to the conclusion that they don't know how to succeed. Don't need a database for that. Just a functioning brain.
 
As you may have noticed there's a heap of perma haters in here. They pretend to be all data driven and unbiased but they're full of it. Best thing to do is just ignore them and let them echo chamber in their little club. There's a fair swag of us who disagree with them but we all have lives so you won't see as much from us as you do from them. Welcome aboard.
The amusing part of this is you’re the one who is data driven who spends considerable time creating spreadsheets and datasets to try and prove points that fall flat. Gees imagine if you didn’t have a life like us what you could come up with.
 
Wasn’t it you who posted recently that if you just take off our two oldest players we drop back down to one of the youngest teams?
Conveniently ignoring what happens if you do the same for all teams?
You are the king of cherry picking.

Haters? In case you haven’t been reading the last few years the majority of posters are not a fan of nicks for obvious reasons.
Theres pretty much Wayne and this other bloke left now that disagree.
He didn’t really did he?

Carmo say it ain’t so, I rely on your data, I’d hate it if I’ve been fooled this whole time
 
Most of us are haters of perennially missing finals & losing most games.

Since when has it been unreasonable to expect your club to have a winning culture?

Says more about those who are happy to accept mediocrity which i never have been able to sit back & accept.
Goddam right about that!
 
As you may have noticed there's a heap of perma haters in here. They pretend to be all data driven and unbiased but they're full of it. Best thing to do is just ignore them and let them echo chamber in their little club. There's a fair swag of us who disagree with them but we all have lives so you won't see as much from us as you do from them. Welcome aboard.
Cut It Out GIF by Mashed
 
Is going to Harvard going to teach Nicks:

A) How to structure to not concede from opposition kick ins?
B) Maximise our scoring opportunities from our kick ins?

He's been in charge five years now and we're still crap at both!
 
Is going to Harvard going to teach Nicks:

A) How to structure to not concede from opposition kick ins?
B) Maximise our scoring opportunities from our kick ins?

He's been in charge five years now and we're still crap at both!
Likely effects are:

1. Harvard makes some money off its reputation

2. Nicks gets some new cliches for his pressers

Main risk is that Nicks gets a little extra confidence in his own judgement, because he’s a Harvard man now.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Matthew Nicks: Adelaide's Coach (Part 3) - The Biggest Loser

Back
Top