Most overrated player in the AFL currently?

[Corn Cobbers]

Tom McCartin is very over rated.

Not healthy to single out individuals after a disgraceful loss, whole club needs to lift

 

[WillHayward]

Far from your worst player. Heeney was appalling.

Heeney had a broken foot so at least an excuse.

 

[Sea fog]

Heeney had a broken foot so at least an excuse.

So did Lachie Neale. One played a brilliant game and did not make it an excuse, the other whinged about it after failing in another grand final. He supposedly had it in the other finals too which didn't seem to affect him. That is not to say that Heeney is overrated but he is disappointing in grand finals.

 

[Sea fog]

Grundy played well.

When the game was over. He was ragdolled by Daniher and easily matched by the second stringer Fort. In 2018 Lycett took him to the cleaners.

 

[HairyO]

Heeney had a broken foot so at least an excuse.

So did Neale.

 

[Cleansweep17]

Tom McCartin is very over rated.

WillHayward, what about Will Hayward?

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

Heeney had a broken foot so at least an excuse.

I don't think that's correct.

 

[Partridge]

Its what he did with it. He infringed against Fort all day and was only pinged once. And when he won the ball he didnt do a lot with it.

Fort was every bit as good as Grundy and did more than enough to let Brisbane's midfield dominate and the Swans midfield to atruggle.

Grndy should have destroyed Fort but didnt come close to it.

I haven't looked at any stats, but going purely by watching the game - once - I thought Fort broke even with Grundy at absolute worst. He more than did the job required for his team.

Grundy, like his team, monumentally failed on the big stage.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Grundys second half of the season has been underwhelming

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Grundys second half of the season has been underwhelming

He’s no longer in the top 6-8 ruckman.

Very very overrated player for his reputation and contract size.

Sydney are only having to pay 2/3 of it and it’s too much.

Collingwood are paying him to play against them.

 

[HairyO]

I haven't looked at any stats, but going purely by watching the game - once - I thought Fort broke even with Grundy at absolute worst. He more than did the job required for his team.

Grundy, like his team, monumentally failed on the big stage.

Absolutely. I didnt look at the stats either. I just saw Fort keeping up with Grundy which is definitely all that Fages ever would have dreamed of.

He 100% earned his medal.

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

TBH I just looked at the stats and was surprised with Brodies possessions and hit outs, I just assumed with the complete dominance Brisbane hit out centre bounces that Brodie must have been terrible..

Grundy gets a heap of scrappy/go nowhere handballs at the bottom of a pack.

Have you seen Angel Reese’s rebounding? It’s like that. A few handballs in a row into someone’s legs.

 

[JHF1870]

Grundy is no longer that fantastic but people saying he was flogged yesterday are having a laugh.

Grundy doesn't do enough around the ground.

 

[HairyO]

Grundy gets a heap of scrappy/go nowhere handballs at the bottom of a pack.

Have you seen Angel Reese’s rebounding? It’s like that. A few handballs in a row into someone’s legs.

To be fair, he also had a few handballs landing at his feet yesterday. Swans disposals on the whole were very poor.

 

[Defabs]

Not for the first time

His pathetic ruck work against Mumford who was like a retired heavyweight fighter coming back a 5th time in the 2019 PF against GWS, made me want him shown the door after that game.

 

[Pancakes]

Grundy gets a heap of scrappy/go nowhere handballs at the bottom of a pack.

Have you seen Angel Reese’s rebounding? It’s like that. A few handballs in a row into someone’s legs.

Of all the people on the planet i thought we could compare Grundy to, not once did Angel Reese come into my calculations.

But to be fair, not a bad observation.

 

[Yellow Feathers]

Heeney. Was pathetic yesterday

 

[JHF1870]

His pathetic ruck work against Mumford who was like a retired heavyweight fighter coming back a 5th time in the 2019 PF against GWS, made me want him shown the door after that game.

The final between Melbourne and Collingwood showed his shortcomings. Had several opportunities to take the game and failed every time. Think the game has gone past him.

 

[joe444]

Heeney had a stress fracture of his ankle during the finals. It got worse late in quarter 1.

Don't recall if he carried an injury or not in 2022, but the 11 possession game that day was not memorable.