"Head is sacroscant" my arse. If it was the other way round, there's no doubt Zuth would have copped the week.
On top of the missed 50, that's just insulting.
-
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
MRP / Trib. MRP and Tribunal - 2024 - Finals Week 1
- Thread starter Chief
- Start date
- Tagged users None
"Head is sacroscant" my arse. If it was the other way round, there's no doubt Zuth would have copped the week.
On top of the missed 50, that's just insulting.
Sttew
Brownlow Medallist
Agree. No harm done to Zuthrie and it makes no difference to me if Banfield is suspended or not. But if he can get away with a "dog-act" caught on camera with just a paltry fine, what message does that send out? The AFL condones dog acts if no harm is done?
Nope, missed the first half and it's not in the highlights, hence the question.
Just saw the Sam Wicks footage that got him banned for 4 games.
A bit rough.
To me it looks like the player he concussed was already concussed from the head collision with the other swans player.
Even the tackle wasn't that bad as they just collapsed in front of him and he had to fall over the top. What else could he do? Evaporate into thin air?
The only thing that makes it look anything remotely bad is his arm around the player.
Pretty harsh In my opinion anyway.
A bit rough.
To me it looks like the player he concussed was already concussed from the head collision with the other swans player.
Even the tackle wasn't that bad as they just collapsed in front of him and he had to fall over the top. What else could he do? Evaporate into thin air?
The only thing that makes it look anything remotely bad is his arm around the player.
Pretty harsh In my opinion anyway.
Michael Christian and sanctioning players from a team playing Collingwood.
Name a more iconic duo...
Edit: Oh never mind, it's VFL. Even more of a crapshoot.
Last edited:
So when it's AFL it's a conspiracy but when it's VFL it's just because the whole system is bad.
Michael Christian doesn't make decisions for the VFL, as far as I'm aware.
Chief
~ Shmalpha ~
- Thread starter
- Admin
- #1,085
The AFL advises the Tribunal will sit tonight, Tuesday August 13, after Taylor Duryea, Western Bulldogs and Jye Caldwell, Essendon have challenged their sanctions via a written submission with the outcome to be communicated, Wednesday August 14.
Once again, the MRO deciding that apparently its ok to tunnel an opponent.
But you can get fined for having a melee with yourself
Chief
~ Shmalpha ~
- Thread starter
- Admin
- #1,089
The GIANTS will challenge defender Lachie Ash's one-match suspension for rough conduct at the AFL tribunal.
Ash was charged with rough conduct for his tackle on Docker Hayden Young in the second quarter of the GIANTS' win on Saturday afternoon.
The incident has been graded as careless conduct, medium impact and high contact, with Ash offered a one-match suspension.
The GIANTS have confirmed they will challenge the suspension a the AFL tribunal on Tuesday night.
The GIANTS’ win over the the Dockers saw the GIANTS secure a finals berth and a top-four spot ahead of the final game of the home and away season.
The GIANTS take on the Western Bulldogs at Mars Stadium in Ballarat on Sunday at 12:30pm.
Ash was charged with rough conduct for his tackle on Docker Hayden Young in the second quarter of the GIANTS' win on Saturday afternoon.
The incident has been graded as careless conduct, medium impact and high contact, with Ash offered a one-match suspension.
The GIANTS have confirmed they will challenge the suspension a the AFL tribunal on Tuesday night.
The GIANTS’ win over the the Dockers saw the GIANTS secure a finals berth and a top-four spot ahead of the final game of the home and away season.
The GIANTS take on the Western Bulldogs at Mars Stadium in Ballarat on Sunday at 12:30pm.
But you can get fined for having a melee with yourself
Fair enough too. You can't do that sort of thing in international one-day cricket....
hawkman
Hall of Famer
Harley going out of his way to try and get Butters fines record?
Chief
~ Shmalpha ~
- Thread starter
- Admin
- #1,094
The AFL advises the Tribunal will sit tonight, Tuesday August 20, to determine the incident involving Lachlan Ash, GWS GIANTS and Daniel Houston, Port Adelaide.
All players accepted their sanctions for the Match Review of Round 23 of the 2024 Toyota AFL Premiership Season.
AFL Tribunal, Tuesday 20 August 4:00pm AEST:
The incident involving GWS GIANTS Lachlan Ash and Fremantle's Hayden Young during the Second Quarter of the Round 23 match between GWS GIANTS and Fremantle will be determined at the Tribunal.
AFL Tribunal, Tuesday 20 August 6:30pm AEST:
The incident involving Port Adelaide's Daniel Houston and Adelaide Crows Izak Rankine during the First Quarter of the Round 23 match between Port Adelaide and Adelaide Crows will be determined at the Tribunal.
All players accepted their sanctions for the Match Review of Round 23 of the 2024 Toyota AFL Premiership Season.
AFL Tribunal, Tuesday 20 August 4:00pm AEST:
The incident involving GWS GIANTS Lachlan Ash and Fremantle's Hayden Young during the Second Quarter of the Round 23 match between GWS GIANTS and Fremantle will be determined at the Tribunal.
AFL Tribunal, Tuesday 20 August 6:30pm AEST:
The incident involving Port Adelaide's Daniel Houston and Adelaide Crows Izak Rankine during the First Quarter of the Round 23 match between Port Adelaide and Adelaide Crows will be determined at the Tribunal.
Chief
~ Shmalpha ~
- Thread starter
- Admin
- #1,095
AFL Appeal Board Hearing, 6:00pm AEST Thursday August 22, 2024.
Port Adelaide have appealed the five-game suspension imposed on Daniel Houston for his incident on Izak Rankine from the Adelaide Crows during the First Quarter of the Round 23 match between Port Adelaide and Adelaide Crows.
Port Adelaide have appealed the five-game suspension imposed on Daniel Houston for his incident on Izak Rankine from the Adelaide Crows during the First Quarter of the Round 23 match between Port Adelaide and Adelaide Crows.
Has to be a week for Jones
SHOGUN_31A
Debutant
- Feb 24, 2011
- 106
- 94
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Jul 13, 2015
- 37,805
- 42,625
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
The Mares Leg
L.A.M.F.
- Jun 30, 2024
- 665
- 678
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Fixed.
Similar threads
