NaCl ^16 🧂🧂

Remove this Banner Ad

His uncle would be gay.

not that there's anything wrong with that seinfeld GIF by myLAB Box
 
The ball was thrown up, not bounced, giving Cox the advantage.
Supposedly.
Comment was made on the broadcast as to wether this was a deliberate 6/6/6 break to gain that advantage.
Why then would Brisbane use exactly the same tactic at the next bounce?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Thanks for sharing this m8. This premiership just keeps getting sweeter and sweeter. I left a few laughter reactions in that thread as a way to thank those intellectuals for the entertainment they have bestowed upon us.
Not sure how you held your tongue.
 

So unhinged.
If you were in the police force looking to get the quotas up, that Richmond thread would be your first call.
 
So unhinged.
If you were in the police force looking to get the quotas up, that Richmond thread would be your first call.

lol, a "tainted umpires flag"

Despite Brisbane directly benefiting from at least 3 terrible umpiring decisions that resulted in goals?

  • Goal 1: Bailey encroaching into the protected zone when Cox was taking his kick
  • Goal 2: The 50m penalty against Markov
  • Goal 3: Daniher caught holding the ball, play allowed to go on, Bailey kicks another goal (this one is probably one of those decisions that gets paid in H&A and maybe let go in Finals)

That also ignores all the textbook 50m penalties that should have been paid our way that weren't

Like, all this talk about the umpiring in that Grand Final based on one poor advantage call that would have resulted in.....(wait for it).....a Lachie Neale kick from 65m out that could have literally resulted in anything lol
 
lol, a "tainted umpires flag"

Despite Brisbane directly benefiting from at least 3 terrible umpiring decisions that resulted in goals?

  • Goal 1: Bailey encroaching into the protected zone when Cox was taking his kick
  • Goal 2: The 50m penalty against Markov
  • Goal 3: Daniher caught holding the ball, play allowed to go on, Bailey kicks another goal (this one is probably one of those decisions that gets paid in H&A and maybe let go in Finals)

That also ignores all the textbook 50m penalties that should have been paid our way that weren't

Like, all this talk about the umpiring in that Grand Final based on one poor advantage call that would have resulted in.....(wait for it).....a Lachie Neale kick from 65m out that could have literally resulted in anything lol
It wasn’t even a poor advantage call. Followed the rule to the letter.
 
It wasn’t even a poor advantage call. Followed the rule to the letter.

I mean, the same could be argued about the 50 against Markov

But at some point common sense/"feel for the game" has to prevail no?

It's clear Markov was going back to what he thought was the mark and couldn't hear the ump
It's also clear Bailey didn't know a free had been called and took the kick as he was being tackled
 
Last edited:
If a back pocket didn't score the winner in 1964, if Breen's kick wobbled out of bounce in 1966, if McKenna wasn't concussed in 1970, if Carman didn't get suspended in 1977, If Harmes' kick was called out of bounce in 1979, if Rocca's kick was paid a goal in 2002, if Maynard was paid a free kick in 2018 then Collingwood would have been miles ahead of everyone else on the premiership tally.

But it didn't happen. The salt from opposition supporters is a sight to behold.

We can certainly play that game too.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I mean, the same could be argued about the 50 against Markov

But at some point common sense/"feel for the game" has to prevail no?

It's clear Markov was going back to what he thought was the mark and couldn't hear the ump
It's also clear Bailey didn't know a free had been called and took the kick as he was being tackled
Disagree on Markov, he had already moved off the mark before he was told to stand. I’m almost certain that particular incident was the single error that the AFL conceded in their match review too iirc.
 
Disagree on Markov, he had already moved off the mark before he was told to stand. I’m almost certain that particular incident was the single error that the AFL conceded in their match review too iirc.

My original point still stands.

Even in the event that was a genuine mistake, a Neale kick from 65 could have ended up in anything.

People are acting like it cost them a certain goal that would have won the flag lol
 
Last edited:
My original point still stands.

Even in the event that was a genuine mistake, a Meale kick from 65 could have ended up in anything.

People are acting like it cost them a certain goal that would have won the flag lol
Oh I completely agree. There are several logical arguments to be made, ranging from “no guarantee a free kick and forward entry would have resulted in a goal”, to “what if no advantage had been called immediately and then the ball was marked by a lions player?”

There’s so many ways to refute the impact of that one call but people will completely ignore them because that call didn’t go the way they wanted it to while the game was in the balance. It’s human nature unfortunately to disregard hard logic when passion is involved.
 
lol, a "tainted umpires flag"

Despite Brisbane directly benefiting from at least 3 terrible umpiring decisions that resulted in goals?

  • Goal 1: Bailey encroaching into the protected zone when Cox was taking his kick
  • Goal 2: The 50m penalty against Markov
  • Goal 3: Daniher caught holding the ball, play allowed to go on, Bailey kicks another goal (this one is probably one of those decisions that gets paid in H&A and maybe let go in Finals)

That also ignores all the textbook 50m penalties that should have been paid our way that weren't

Like, all this talk about the umpiring in that Grand Final based on one poor advantage call that would have resulted in.....(wait for it).....a Lachie Neale kick from 65m out that could have literally resulted in anything lol
The final goal that Brisbane kicked looked like it came from a player who took the ball out of bounds.

Nick Daicos kicked a point. At the time, I would have liked for them to have reviewed the touch that made it a point. Never got to look at it.

But we won so I'm happy with every call.
 

Swans have a cultural chip on their shoulder.

Ignoring membership numbers, which clearly point to the claim being bullshit, this is what I found online in a matter of seconds.



ClubInstagramTwitterFacebookTikTokTotal
Collingwood288,000148,600363,00082,000881,600
Richmond287,000109,000289,000117,600802,600
Hawthorn209,000103,500326,000136,800775,300
Essendon230,000140,000345,00055,300770,300
Geelong211,00091,900222,000179,200704,100
Carlton237,000122,700278,00055,000692,700
West Coast228,00099,200322,00023,500672,700
Sydney173,000104,200275,000110,700662,900
Adelaide158,000157,000281,00065,700661,700
St Kilda130,00086,700170,000183,100569,800
Western Bulldogs176,00074,200176,00074,000500,200
Fremantle153,00085,900213,00029,400481,300
Port Adelaide136,000111,600193,00035,900476,500
Brisbane134,00094,500152,00056,600437,100
Melbourne138,00073,700153,00061,700426,400
North Melbourne115,00075,100150,00051,700391,800
GWS98,80060,500108,00033,000300,300
Gold Coast88,90060,800102,00022,400274,100
Data as of August 26, 2022
 
My original point still stands.

Even in the event that was a genuine mistake, a Neale kick from 65 could have ended up in anything.

People are acting like it cost them a certain goal that would have won the flag lol
The good news is……..we don’t need to care, GF banked :collingwood:
 
Crystal ball saying we will slide!

We are bigger and fitter heading into next week's opening round.

When you’re the reigning premier, it’s only logical to predict a slide. It’s like forecasting a market correction after bubble has formed. Even so, we can do some more damage while our reign lasts.
 
Swans have a cultural chip on their shoulder.

Ignoring membership numbers, which clearly point to the claim being bullshit, this is what I found online in a matter of seconds.



ClubInstagramTwitterFacebookTikTokTotal
Collingwood288,000148,600363,00082,000881,600
Richmond287,000109,000289,000117,600802,600
Hawthorn209,000103,500326,000136,800775,300
Essendon230,000140,000345,00055,300770,300
Geelong211,00091,900222,000179,200704,100
Carlton237,000122,700278,00055,000692,700
West Coast228,00099,200322,00023,500672,700
Sydney173,000104,200275,000110,700662,900
Adelaide158,000157,000281,00065,700661,700
St Kilda130,00086,700170,000183,100569,800
Western Bulldogs176,00074,200176,00074,000500,200
Fremantle153,00085,900213,00029,400481,300
Port Adelaide136,000111,600193,00035,900476,500
Brisbane134,00094,500152,00056,600437,100
Melbourne138,00073,700153,00061,700426,400
North Melbourne115,00075,100150,00051,700391,800
GWS98,80060,500108,00033,000300,300
Gold Coast88,90060,800102,00022,400274,100
Data as of August 26, 2022
Pretty confident Swans are ahead on Grindr.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

NaCl ^16 🧂🧂

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top