NFNL Div 2 discussion 2024

[Rusted nuts]

Is there any reason we expect Whittlesea to bounce back? Eltham thrashed them in a praccy match last year and besides a couple haven’t recruited a huge amount.

Gary Ramsay

 

[10571z]

Gary Ramsay

No doubt a much better coach. But you still need some cattle. Certainly expect them in the mix.

 

[Rusted nuts]

No doubt a much better coach. But you still need some cattle. Certainly expect them in the mix.

Hobbs will be a strong perf

No doubt a much better coach. But you still need some cattle. Certainly expect them in the mix.

Who has whittlesea recruited outside of Hobbs. Hard to go past Diamo as the favourites.

 

[Thunder1]

Hobbs will be a strong perf

Who has whittlesea recruited outside of Hobbs. Hard to go past Diamo as the favourites.

Get Coen back from Kinglake
Higgins didn’t play last year after doing his knee, not sure when he is due back
I agree though Diamond Creek favourites for me

 

[10571z]

Dunno about these Northern football show rankings… very odd behaviour

 

[lennyhayes777]

Panton Hills Tom Keys to sign with Heidelberg 100%

 

[Rusted nuts]

Dunno about these Northern football show rankings… very odd behaviour

Parks ahead of Leonardis is comical. No disrespect to Parks.

 

[bertybeetle]

Dunno about these Northern football show rankings… very odd behaviour

Where’s Lucas Hobbs… would he not be top 5?

 

[10571z]

Parks ahead of Leonardis is comical. No disrespect to Parks.

My thoughts exactly

 

[10571z]

Panton Hills Tom Keys to sign with Heidelberg 100%

Where do we see them finishing? They last to lower last year. Could they be in relegation contention? I’d think not but you never know.

 

[Eyes_and_Ears]

Dunno about these Northern football show rankings… very odd behaviour

It's embarrassing. Not sure why they just don't stick to interviews for now and maybe do rankings throughout the season.

 

[kickthething]

It's embarrassing. Not sure why they just don't stick to interviews for now and maybe do rankings throughout the season.

Embarrassing, really??? A couple of blokes giving their opinion at the start of the year…It’s nothing but a conversation starter…nothing hangs off it … take a breath.

 

[hfchfc]

Embarrassing, really??? A couple of blokes giving their opinion at the start of the year…It’s nothing but a conversation starter…nothing hangs off it … take a breath.

Exactly right, well said

Opinions are like arseholes, every one has one. Those criticising don’t put up their own lists!

 

[lennyhayes777]

Where do we see them finishing? They last to lower last year. Could they be in relegation contention? I’d think not but you never know.

Hard to get a read as they beat the undefeated diamo but lost to lower so who knows

 

[bertybeetle]

Exactly right, well said

Opinions are like arseholes, every one has one. Those criticising don’t put up their own lists!

Div 1:
Lachie Wilson
Marcus Lentini
Majak Daw
Pat Fitzgerald
Darcy Barden
Brayden Sier
Viv Blackmore Moore
Pete Mcevoy
Sam Binion
Chris Ryall



Div 2:
Lucas Hobbs
Tyrone Leonardis
Jacob Booth
Josh Dintinosante
Nathan Searl
James Lucente
Pat Flynn
Tye Hall
Tyler Barnes
Kyle Green


Div 3:
Sam Gilmore
James Tadd
Jai Burns
Neville Jetta
Matt Williamson
Shane Harvey
Seb Latina
Kain Proctor
Josh Mazzerella
Leigh Judd

 

[Denny Crane]

Div 1:
Lachie Wilson
Marcus Lentini
Majak Daw
Pat Fitzgerald
Darcy Barden
Brayden Sier
Viv Blackmore Moore
Pete Mcevoy
Sam Binion
Chris Ryall



Div 2:
Lucas Hobbs
Tyrone Leonardis
Jacob Booth
Josh Dintinosante
Nathan Searl
James Lucente
Pat Flynn
Tye Hall
Tyler Barnes
Kyle Green


Div 3:
Sam Gilmore
James Tadd
Jai Burns
Neville Jetta
Matt Williamson
Shane Harvey
Seb Latina
Kain Proctor
Josh Mazzerella
Leigh Judd

Pretty fair list and reckon you are close to the money. Unsure why people get upset with someone making a call like this, purely an opinion of the author and you can agree or disagree that's what it's all about, getting upset is just weird. Think MacCaffer could appear in Div 3 though, will take the yella this year.

 

[bertybeetle]

Pretty fair list and reckon you are close to the money. Unsure why people get upset with someone making a call like this, purely an opinion of the author and you can agree or disagree that's what it's all about, getting upset is just weird. Think MacCaffer could appear in Div 3 though, will take the yella this year.

Yeah agree with macaffer my list was based off their criteria of having played nfnl last year

 

[Givemetherock]

Div 1:
Lachie Wilson
Marcus Lentini
Majak Daw
Pat Fitzgerald
Darcy Barden
Brayden Sier
Viv Blackmore Moore
Pete Mcevoy
Sam Binion
Chris Ryall



Div 2:
Lucas Hobbs
Tyrone Leonardis
Jacob Booth
Josh Dintinosante
Nathan Searl
James Lucente
Pat Flynn
Tye Hall
Tyler Barnes
Kyle Green


Div 3:
Sam Gilmore
James Tadd
Jai Burns
Neville Jetta
Matt Williamson
Shane Harvey
Seb Latina
Kain Proctor
Josh Mazzerella
Leigh Judd

Very solid.

I reckon Liam Hunt & Jesse Tardio has a strong case in the Div 1 list.

Div 1
Lachie Wilson
Majak Daw
Marcus Lentini
Pat Fitzgerald
Sier
Sam Binion
Liam Hunt
Pete McEvoy
Hurley
Jesse Tardio

Div 2
Leonardis
Booth
Dimassi
D’intinosante
Flynn
Tye Hall
Lucente
L Hobbs
K Green
T Barnes

Div 3
Gilmore
Burns
Proctor
Latina
M Williamson
Condello
Judd
Ellis
S Harvey
C Barton

 

[illumineer]

Cotter
Ben Young
Jack Bianchin

All should be in those discussions

 

[lennyhayes777]

Cotter
Ben Young
Jack Bianchin

All should be in those discussions

Hahaha come off it. Clearly at st Mary’s supporter.
Cotter possibly, the other two would be in top 10 div 3 discussions if they were in it but certainly not div 2 at this stage of their careers

 

[Brass Tap]

Cotter
Ben Young
Jack Bianchin

All should be in those discussions

Ben Young turn it up

 

[roosterslife]

Cotter
Ben Young
Jack Bianchin

All should be in those discussions

Ben Young? Wouldn’t be in the top 30+

 

[Sticksbradley]

Dunno about these Northern football show rankings… very odd behaviour

The theory of the show is fantastic, keep
Interviewing and highlighting clubs, coaches and players but stop taking wild guesses at ranking players they have never seen, it doesn’t do them any favours.

Before anyone comments, I know they are volunteers and don’t get paid but if you are putting out a product such as this then you have to be open to feedback from the audience you are trying to engage.

Perhaps they could stop talking to there old pals from there old clubs and broaden there knowledge across the entire league?

 

[10571z]

The theory of the show is fantastic, keep
Interviewing and highlighting clubs, coaches and players but stop taking wild guesses at ranking players they have never seen, it doesn’t do them any favours.

Before anyone comments, I know they are volunteers and don’t get paid but if you are putting out a product such as this then you have to be open to feedback from the audience you are trying to engage.

Perhaps they could stop talking to there old pals from there old clubs and broaden there knowledge across the entire league?

Couldn’t agree more.

Rank players but they had to play in the NFNL last season? So Gary Ablett signs at Lalor but won’t be included in rankings? Really….

Regardless if you aren’t watching the majority of games it means basically nothing.

 

[Rusted nuts]

The theory of the show is fantastic, keep
Interviewing and highlighting clubs, coaches and players but stop taking wild guesses at ranking players they have never seen, it doesn’t do them any favours.

Before anyone comments, I know they are volunteers and don’t get paid but if you are putting out a product such as this then you have to be open to feedback from the audience you are trying to engage.

Perhaps they could stop talking to there old pals from there old clubs and broaden there knowledge across the entire league?

It’s ran by nuffies, I wouldn’t lose sleep over it.