Side note: might need more than two blokes if they want to chair him off.
-
Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2025 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
Nic Naitanui Retires
- Thread starter Biggie
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Makes me cry thinking about what could of been if he didn't do that first knee.
He was on the verge of being the most dominant player in the league.
He strode around Subi like a colossus, he had the football and the crowd in the palm of his hand.
He was still a great player after but the hangers dried up and he lost a yard.
Sure gonna miss him.
He was on the verge of being the most dominant player in the league.
He strode around Subi like a colossus, he had the football and the crowd in the palm of his hand.
He was still a great player after but the hangers dried up and he lost a yard.
Sure gonna miss him.
fake tyrone
Team Captain
- Jun 15, 2012
- 442
- 1,386
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Warrington Wolves, ACF Fiorentina
This is sad news even though I don't barrack for the Eagles. Naitanui was one of the most raw talents I've witnessed, his deft tap work and blistering follow-ups just football at its purest. He was so fluid and so natural in applying his craft, a truly creative footballer in an era where that sort of raw creativity is being lost. This guy turned games on their heads in the way most kids aspire to when they play with their siblings in the backyard or their mates at school. Naitanui played the game the way it was meant to be played and I wonder if we'll ever see a ruckman like him again. Honestly, the only downside to seeing the Eagles pip Collingwood at the death in 2018 was that Naitanui didn't take to the ground that day.
I don't think it's a coincidence that we've had a couple of Richmond supporters 'pay their respects'.
I remember that game in maybe 2015(?) at the G where Nic was basically showing off. Worked the full clock face. Just stuff you shouldn't be doing, it was ruck art.
I remember that game in maybe 2015(?) at the G where Nic was basically showing off. Worked the full clock face. Just stuff you shouldn't be doing, it was ruck art.
- Sep 21, 2004
- 39,966
- 30,107
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Norwood & Liverpool.
One of the happiest moments I've had as an Eagle fan was when Benny Cousins got his premiership medal.
He battled for years through crap teams and a Grand Final loss and when that siren went I was mainly thinking of him.
Not many players in our history I would've wished the same for.
Nic, Phil Matera, Pridda and Shep
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
He battled for years through crap teams and a Grand Final loss and when that siren went I was mainly thinking of him.
Not many players in our history I would've wished the same for.
Nic, Phil Matera, Pridda and Shep
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
Might be a neat exercise since we're effectively in the off-season anyway...best Eagles to not win a flag?
1. Nic Naitanui
2. Phil Matera
3. Andrew Gaff
4. Matt Priddis
5. Brad Sheppard
6. Eric Mackenzie
7. Chad Morrison
8. Ashley Sampi
9. Scott Cummings
10. Josh Hill
Feel free to rip into it, whipped up in like five minutes.
- Sep 28, 2009
- 23,878
- 34,393
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Reading FC
I think I did a best 22 to not win a grand final once.
Gehrig and Gardiner are a couple that would be up there.
- Oct 9, 2009
- 12,648
- 14,378
- AFL Club
- West Coast
The Human Cannonball aka Troy Wilson too.
Last edited:
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
Did consider Gehrig but Cummings edged him out, and completely forgot about Michael Gardiner, he would probably bump Josh Hill out at least. Sampi is purely in there for his undeniable talent but had no longevity.
Scott Selwood probably gets in there. Vice captain and was looking pretty good pre-injury.
Jackson Nelson, probably the unluckiest player to miss out on a flag.
10 years ago getting our player to play till 33 was a decent effort but now days it feel Boot/retired sorta youngish if that makes
Always forget Kerr retired at 30 and I struggle to believe he is only 4 years older than Bunga
Always forget Kerr retired at 30 and I struggle to believe he is only 4 years older than Bunga
Woosha had enough of Kerr's shit. Could've easily played on till 2015 grand final if he wasn't a mental basket case.
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
Good call.
And no offence to Ryan Turnbull, David Hynes, Mark Seaby and Nathan Vardy, but two of the best three rucks at West Coast didn't play in a flag.
UseR2006
Premiership Player
- Aug 2, 2020
- 4,337
- 11,902
- AFL Club
- West Coast
If i remember correctly Kerr had Shuey Hamstrings late in his career.
His body was also battered. In 2018 he would have been younger than what Hurn is now.
Not sure if Josh Hill making the list is good or bad but he was an average player
It's good. Most Eagles champions have a flag to their name. The names other clubs would put up would be an insane amount of talent.
- Jul 4, 2015
- 1,459
- 2,903
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Swan Districts
His amazing ruck work, sublime taps 360, athletic ability, crazy speed/tackling/running away..all been mentioned. Incredible.
Off field, one of the best fellas & quite rightly an AFL ambassador...fantastic for the game...talk to the kids that grew up over his time.
I love all the aforementioned.
One other thing I love abut the great man, as a supporter, is that he gave me hope.
Always felt that we were in with a chance, no matter how down we were, that Nic could save us & we would win.
Didn't always fall that way, but man, sometimes it did...and has given me the best memories.
Nic and Buddy....been blessed to watch..olders used to talk about Polly or John Todd or Billy Walker
That's generational, same as Nic, no doubts.
A reason why people love the footy.
and fathers took their sons, cos fortunes used to hide, in the palms of his hands.. Paul Kelly
Off field, one of the best fellas & quite rightly an AFL ambassador...fantastic for the game...talk to the kids that grew up over his time.
I love all the aforementioned.
One other thing I love abut the great man, as a supporter, is that he gave me hope.
Always felt that we were in with a chance, no matter how down we were, that Nic could save us & we would win.
Didn't always fall that way, but man, sometimes it did...and has given me the best memories.
Nic and Buddy....been blessed to watch..olders used to talk about Polly or John Todd or Billy Walker
That's generational, same as Nic, no doubts.
A reason why people love the footy.
and fathers took their sons, cos fortunes used to hide, in the palms of his hands.. Paul Kelly
No doubt missed a few, but it's a testament to our club and its success that the list isn't overly long of champions who missed out.
Other clubs can put together superstar teams of players who never saluted. Freo's best ever team is all in there...
He was never going to last. Once Cuz melted down and Judd bailed teams were double teaming him and literally tackling and scragging him off the ball as he was our only threat.
Was a disgrace and the AFL didn't act until some of the stars for Victorian teams started getting the same treatment.
Woosh didn’t retire him tho I heard an interview where it was said Simmo really tried hard to get him to play on in 2014 but Kerr wasn’t to keen on learning a new style of play and thought it would be a good time to retire.
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
Given subsequent events, someone claiming Kerr was a mental basket case shouldn't automatically be disbelieved though.
He did indeed cop a lot of treatment though when Judd and Cousins departed and still did well.
Would have made 2015 much more interesting if Kerr had played on had a throw back year.
I would have loved to seem him in a forward pocket or on the wings.
