Game Day Opening Round vs. GWS, Giants Stadium, 7:30pm Sat 09/03

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
When nature pairs all the football talent human DNA can take together with the dodgiest knees; and that's her gift to you. FMD
With Walker, I like to look on the bright side about his dodgy knees.

If it wasn't for the dodgy knees, he never would have made it to us. He would have been a WCE great and those ****ers would have won a heap more.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I hope both do well but Markov is the better player IMO.
Faster and with better kicking skill.
That's called personal perception.
Markov had a good end to the year but the stats and data etc. clearly show across the season (both playing about the same amount of games) JFN was ahead in most areas (except, of course, moustachery)
 
With Walker, I like to look on the bright side about his dodgy knees.

If it wasn't for the dodgy knees, he never would have made it to us. He would have been a WCE great and those *ers would have won a heap more.

Yep. That's no exaggeration. A fit & healthy Walker at WCE would have meant more flags for them. He was that good. He was as Careylike as Carey himself at a time when a CHF of that ability was the difference between a flag and 8th.
 
My point is though, that you need to give him exposure if you want him to make it as a forward in our system. Takes time to learn patterns, your place and to build chemistry.
Most of his career has been as a ruck and forward. Performances led to playing reserves, and being delisted.

He showed form when swung into defence, and that is his caper nowadays.

Unsurprisingly he can pinch hit as a KPF or ruck.
 
That's called personal perception.
Markov had a good end to the year but the stats and data etc. clearly show across the season (both playing about the same amount of games) JFN was ahead in most areas (except, of course, moustachery)
And premierships
 
I think we might surprise everyone and go for HH as sub
Why not go one step further? Sullivan as sub would shock the shit out of everyone. Disappointed that you didn’t suggest such a daring move.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The AFL are giving me the proverbials.
They keep raving about how the opening round is stealing a March on NRL, but the NRL is on as well!
And don’t get me started about all the smug faces talking about “sellout” games up there.
We play in a stadium with a rated capacity of 23,500. Did I not see Browne on TV yesterday state we averaged 76,000 at the G?
Even tonight’s game is at a stadium with a smaller capacity than Marvel.
Bloody ridiculous.
 
Disappointed for Finn and Reef, thought they both deserved a spot in the side
Finn and AJ were very unlikely to both be selected

Noble was preferred over Finn.

As much as I’m disappointed for the two who missed out, the two in’s are good news stories too.
 
The AFL are giving me the proverbials.
They keep raving about how the opening round is stealing a March on NRL, but the NRL is on as well!
And don’t get me started about all the smug faces talking about “sellout” games up there.
We play in a stadium with a rated capacity of 23,500. Did I not see Browne on TV yesterday state we averaged 76,000 at the G?
Even tonight’s game is at a stadium with a smaller capacity than Marvel.
Bloody ridiculous.
Let's be honest, It's payback for overlooking NSW for Gather Round. This is their big week of football in NSW with the first two games of the season incl the reigning premier.
 
The AFL are giving me the proverbials.
They keep raving about how the opening round is stealing a March on NRL, but the NRL is on as well!
And don’t get me started about all the smug faces talking about “sellout” games up there.
We play in a stadium with a rated capacity of 23,500. Did I not see Browne on TV yesterday state we averaged 76,000 at the G?
Even tonight’s game is at a stadium with a smaller capacity than Marvel.
Bloody ridiculous.
Collingwood get an extra bye during the season. More chance to be fit and firing for finals and to rest our older players without having them missing games. We also get a road trip out of the way early.

Don’t give a rats about whether or not it wins nrl fans over although agree it probably won’t. It’s good for Collingwood and that’s all I care about.
 
Finn and AJ were very unlikely to both be selected

Noble was preferred over Finn.

As much as I’m disappointed for the two who missed out, the two in’s are good news stories too.

I prefer Reef over AJ, and Finn has been outstanding this preseason. Noble has had a great preseason too, but we really need to get MaCrae into that midfield to see if he is the future once Pendles and Sidebottom has finished. His clearance work can improve us even more
 
Why not go one step further? Sullivan as sub would shock the s**t out of everyone. Disappointed that you didn’t suggest such a daring move.
I realised after I wrote it that you would pick up on it, I was going to say Sullivan but that was too obvious. To be honest, I miss read the teams and forgot that the sub comes from the 5 on the bench. I need to pay better attention, lol
 
I realised after I wrote it that you would pick up on it, I was going to say Sullivan but that was too obvious. To be honest, I miss read the teams and forgot that the sub comes from the 5 on the bench. I need to pay better attention, lol
I wish you had tbh, it would have been funny as **** 😆
 
Are Murphy and Howe injured? We look very skinny for talls at the back without them. Frampton must be back in the pecking order with Dean coming in.
Howe has a corkie. And we all know about Murphy. He's taking his time to build up his confidence & adapt the way he plays.

Dean had a good outing against Tigers. He deserved the call up.
 
I prefer Reef over AJ, and Finn has been outstanding this preseason. Noble has had a great preseason too, but we really need to get MaCrae into that midfield to see if he is the future once Pendles and Sidebottom has finished. His clearance work can improve us even more

Round 1 is a time to pick an extra runner
By winter we will have mitch and finn both in the team
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top