Reply to thread

Carltons list is shit. People want to over rate it over a run of wins 2 years ago that still produced stuff all.

Their top handful are good, that's it.

Cripps, Curnow, TDK, Weitering and Walsh.

McKay- Soft and can't kick. Mentally weak.

Cerra - vanilla midfielder, usually injured.

Hewitt - tries hard but is slow and average kick.

Saad- has a few flashy plays but doesn't do enough actual defending.

Docherty- panics and turns it over.

Cowan - meh

McGovern- Spud

Young- Spud

Haynes- dud delist

Acres - has some decent games.

Hollands- meh

Camporeale- looks ok but nothing special

Fogarty- dud delist

Motlop- has some talent but is flakey.

Silvagni- has some talent but isn't tall enough or fast enough. Tries hard atleast.

Kemp- meh

Cottrell- meh

Lord - thought he showed signs he's a decent talent. Not sure why he's sub behind so many spuds.

List is more good. Wouldn't swap it for ours.