How is his actual defending? The scout reports were that he could intercept and kick but couldn't stop blokes kicking goals.
2nds Peel Thunder 2023 Season
- Thread starter King Huskii
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Reidy is Luke Valente is a bigger meat suit.
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,429
- 88,109
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
His actual defending is his best trait. His contest work is honestly elite, especially given size. He halves or wins basically every contest
Brodie, Reidy, Hambling and Banners all superb.
Reidy: 19 Disposals, 18 Hit outs, 7 Marks, 5 Tackles, 2 goals
I'll blame that on Smith.
CaseySibosadoHOF
All Australian
- Sep 17, 2022
- 847
- 2,082
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Remembered reading on his draft profile that he used to be a KPF and was good for a goal at VFL level last year, and was confused as to why that wasn't reflected in his WAFL numbers. But of his 7 goals in 13 WAFL games this season, 4 have come in the last 2 weeks. Assuming Smith coming in and Treacy, Kuek and Corbett no longer in the WAFL team is giving him room to show his capabilities?
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,429
- 88,109
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Player write-up
Honestly a great game of footy and if you need a Freo fix during the week, watch the replay. Considering they were missing Wilson and Bell who have been pretty important for Peel most of the year, that was a great win.
Tabs: Long way off what he should be doing at the level but that's understandable. The rest of the year is probably just about building and helping Peel win a flag for him. Would probably still play over Corbett even in his current form.
Banfield: BoG for mine and looked an AFL player playing WAFL. Couldnt quite get through the game without a Banners moment from the top of the goal square though...
Emmett: Man he frustrates the hell out of me. If he could kick he'd be a fantastic AFL player but I'm not sure he had one effective kick today.
Brodie: Like Banners, looked like playing a level below what he should. Great tackling today
Reidy: Ysaye's comparison to Martin is spot on. Best game of WAFL for him against a good opponent. Cant help but feel the speed may always restrict him but there is a bit to like
Stanley: Still very effective whenever he got the ball but found a bit hard to get near it. I was watching closely and he did get ignored a bit. A preseason will do him wonders
O'Driscoll: Fantastic work rate today, felt like he was everywhere. Sometimes took on a bit much but I dont mind that. Level below the best players today but enough to know he's still a good player just needs a preseason.
Williams: Kid has everything you want in a footballer, speed, composure, skills, just the physical size and tank has a long way to go. I hope it doesnt hold him back because it would be a shame given the talent he has. Doesnt lack for attack on the ball either which is impressive given how tiny he is.
Hamling: Monster down back, stopped everything
Davies: I cant sing his defensive growth enough. Has an uncanny ability to know where to be and how to play the contest. His disposal can be hit and miss but importantly is not from lack of composure which I like
Colyer: Better than last week and provided some good run, hopefully helps Peel win a flag
Finally, Dan Curtin is going to be an absolute monster and if we cant get him through the GC pick I hope like hell North take him and we can steal him back in a few years to replace Pearce
Honestly a great game of footy and if you need a Freo fix during the week, watch the replay. Considering they were missing Wilson and Bell who have been pretty important for Peel most of the year, that was a great win.
Tabs: Long way off what he should be doing at the level but that's understandable. The rest of the year is probably just about building and helping Peel win a flag for him. Would probably still play over Corbett even in his current form.
Banfield: BoG for mine and looked an AFL player playing WAFL. Couldnt quite get through the game without a Banners moment from the top of the goal square though...
Emmett: Man he frustrates the hell out of me. If he could kick he'd be a fantastic AFL player but I'm not sure he had one effective kick today.
Brodie: Like Banners, looked like playing a level below what he should. Great tackling today
Reidy: Ysaye's comparison to Martin is spot on. Best game of WAFL for him against a good opponent. Cant help but feel the speed may always restrict him but there is a bit to like
Stanley: Still very effective whenever he got the ball but found a bit hard to get near it. I was watching closely and he did get ignored a bit. A preseason will do him wonders
O'Driscoll: Fantastic work rate today, felt like he was everywhere. Sometimes took on a bit much but I dont mind that. Level below the best players today but enough to know he's still a good player just needs a preseason.
Williams: Kid has everything you want in a footballer, speed, composure, skills, just the physical size and tank has a long way to go. I hope it doesnt hold him back because it would be a shame given the talent he has. Doesnt lack for attack on the ball either which is impressive given how tiny he is.
Hamling: Monster down back, stopped everything
Davies: I cant sing his defensive growth enough. Has an uncanny ability to know where to be and how to play the contest. His disposal can be hit and miss but importantly is not from lack of composure which I like
Colyer: Better than last week and provided some good run, hopefully helps Peel win a flag
Finally, Dan Curtin is going to be an absolute monster and if we cant get him through the GC pick I hope like hell North take him and we can steal him back in a few years to replace Pearce
Last edited:
- Apr 25, 2011
- 8,079
- 19,001
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Naturally.
Old Bull Young Buck
Ysaye is gonna collar you for spelling Curtin wrong.
Yeah really good signs with Reidy’s movement around the ground, marking and hitting the scoreboard. Best game yet comfortably.
Banfield very good outside of the howler and Brodie was big inside in the second half with his hands elite out of stoppage.
Solid games from Hamling and ODriscoll too and Emmett was good albeit butchered it a bit.
Arguably Peels best win of the year given the sides in paper.
Banfield very good outside of the howler and Brodie was big inside in the second half with his hands elite out of stoppage.
Solid games from Hamling and ODriscoll too and Emmett was good albeit butchered it a bit.
Arguably Peels best win of the year given the sides in paper.
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,429
- 88,109
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Apr 25, 2011
- 8,079
- 19,001
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I saw nothing.
You were lucky I was eating dinner.....
- Jun 30, 2011
- 7,132
- 14,658
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Without further adieu..
For those interested:
www.afl.com.au
Banfield a cracker of a game.
Tabs I thought played well.
Reidy did some nice things. Claremont got a run on when Smith was in the ruck. I’d like to see big Knobel get another game before the year is out in tandem with Reidy. Certainly next year the two of them should play a lot more together.
Also thought Emmett was pretty good. Still needs to tidy up his disposal by foot.
Solid game from Brodie what I saw live and on highlights.
I think Tabs having watched more highlights is ready to come in for Corbett if they feel a change is necessary. Banfield to step up to replace Walters. Erasmus can stay as sub.
WAFL Mini-Match, R18: Peel v Claremont
Extended highlights of the Thunder and Tigers WAFL clash in round eighteen
www.afl.com.au
Banfield a cracker of a game.
Tabs I thought played well.
Reidy did some nice things. Claremont got a run on when Smith was in the ruck. I’d like to see big Knobel get another game before the year is out in tandem with Reidy. Certainly next year the two of them should play a lot more together.
Also thought Emmett was pretty good. Still needs to tidy up his disposal by foot.
Solid game from Brodie what I saw live and on highlights.
I think Tabs having watched more highlights is ready to come in for Corbett if they feel a change is necessary. Banfield to step up to replace Walters. Erasmus can stay as sub.
I'd like to see Erasmus play in the wafl finals. He needs to be qualified if he isn't already.For those interested:
WAFL Mini-Match, R18: Peel v Claremont
Extended highlights of the Thunder and Tigers WAFL clash in round eighteen
Banfield a cracker of a game.
Tabs I thought played well.
Reidy did some nice things. Claremont got a run on when Smith was in the ruck. I’d like to see big Knobel get another game before the year is out in tandem with Reidy. Certainly next year the two of them should play a lot more together.
Also thought Emmett was pretty good. Still needs to tidy up his disposal by foot.
Solid game from Brodie what I saw live and on highlights.
I think Tabs having watched more highlights is ready to come in for Corbett if they feel a change is necessary. Banfield to step up to replace Walters. Erasmus can stay as sub.
13:46 of the video, Williams runs from the stoppage, kicks the ball to Banners who nails it from 50.
King Tenz
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 29, 2015
- 9,651
- 15,843
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
He looks good. Definitely needs to put some size on though.
Tonga Bob
Please leave a message after the beep
- Oct 26, 2013
- 32,188
- 80,248
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- SFFC, LFC, ADO, CI Warriors
- Moderator
- #2,471
Know what's a-Peel-ing?
Getting involved in the 2023 AFLW Buddy Draft. Don't make me ask you again.
www.bigfooty.com
Getting involved in the 2023 AFLW Buddy Draft. Don't make me ask you again.
Women's Footy - AFLW Buddy Draft 2023
Well folks the dubs season is finally almost upon us, so it's time to assign some posters to some players and have us a good old fashioned Buddy Draft! Usual format applies: Reply in this thread if you wanna get involved, listing your top three (3) choices for your 2023 buddy, I will fire up...
www.bigfooty.com
wasn't named last night
With the way JL has been speaking, I'm not sure if we know the peel qualifying rules...
Either that or we have exemptions set up already
