Training Pre Season '23

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Is Dimma still wearing a half hat?
840fd95082f848a8f399f04489f25009.jpg
 
Are you tipping Narkle gets picked up by us? How did he go at the camp?

No. But he’s a much better footballer than Dow and few others on our list. He’s at least shown at his best he’s a good quality league footballer only 25. I don’t get the arguement against taking him because he’d block some spuds from getting games.

My point is, if they aren’t better than Narkle then why waste games on them.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I personally dont see what Narkle offers to Richmond that we dont already have on the list

If we are looking at playing him as a half back the Oleg Markov would have been a better option (not that we need another HBF)
Mansell , Short , Baker , Vlastuin , Smith , Brown , Rioli all listed

Only place i see him having Value would be HF/FP and even there i would rather give the kids we have drafted a shot before Narkle
Campbell , Smith , Clarke


Only value is he is a mate of Shai Bolton
 
O'Gorman was one of the umpires at match sim this morning and there is talk that he never paid a free kick to either the yellow or red team
 
I personally dont see what Narkle offers to Richmond that we dont already have on the list

If we are looking at playing him as a half back the Oleg Markov would have been a better option (not that we need another HBF)
Mansell , Short , Baker , Vlastuin , Smith , Brown , Rioli all listed

Only place i see him having Value would be HF/FP and even there i would rather give the kids we have drafted a shot before Narkle
Campbell , Smith , Clarke


Only value is he is a mate of Shai Bolton
If Blair Hartley and the coaching staff see Narkle as a potential asset to our list, who are we to question them. They are watching him throughout pre season and have a far far better handle on where he may sit. The guy can play, absolutely no doubt, but is he better than what we have? Only the coaching staff can make that assessment based on what they've seen.
I just don’t get the anti Narkle sentiment on here. If the club deem him worthy of an opportunity, them I’m all for it.
 
If Blair Hartley and the coaching staff see Narkle as a potential asset to our list, who are we to question them. They are watching him throughout pre season and have a far far better handle on where he may sit. The guy can play, absolutely no doubt, but is he better than what we have? Only the coaching staff can make that assessment based on what they've seen.
I just don’t get the anti Narkle sentiment on here. If the club deem him worthy of an opportunity, them I’m all for it.
Correct

But it is a footy forum and we can only voice an opinion
 
How is Narkle a better footballer then what's on our list showed glimpses that's all nothing else.Rather give that opportunity to guys like Ross and Dow in the guts or Clarke in that forward role.
Yep Hugo juddy banksy and Dow perhaps could all play role that narkles can
 
O'Gorman was one of the umpires at match sim this morning and there is talk that he never paid a free kick to either the yellow or red team
If the freshness of the castings dont lie, may have burrowed himself back under the topsoil after the first bounce back to his natural habitat.

We should see him breach back up in a couple of months.
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Training Pre Season '23

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top