Competition Rate the Opposition MVP - Season 36 Edition - Winner Announced

[AnUltimateRessie]

After a hostile take over, rate the opposition is back for season 36.

Congratulations to whoever won last season, no one knows.

All players are entitled to vote and rate the opposition's contribution to the thread in the classic 3, 2, 1 format. At the end of the round the votes will be tallied up and consolidated into a consensus vote.

For a matter of simplification. Essentially if 5 players from a team vote, those votes will be totalled with the poster with the most combined votes getting 3, second most 2 and third highest the 1.

Please also rate the whole thread between 1 and 5.

A good template for this would be:
​

Round x vs TEAM

3. PLAYER
2. PLAYER
1. PLAYER

Thread: 1-5 /5​

Thanks luvs, and thanks GWS Goose ​

 

[thewizardmelon]

Round 1 v OOB

3. Elton Johns Wig started his season strong here
2. Mrs Turbo - the OOB are much better when she’s up and about
1. TJohn the BIG DOG had a good start to his Qooty career, getting stuck in

HM: Robertio led from the front all week

Thread: 3.5/5, decent start to the season

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Round 1 vs Royals

3 - Cadsky
2 - krakouers
1 - grumbleguts

I can't believe what I'm writing, and I'll probably wash my keyboard out with soap afterwards but there ya go. Royals definitely better than last season, though it could be due to Cadsky and serial_thrilla finding a common enemy

 

[grumbleguts]

3. Strigoi
2. DragoDelph
1. Pie 4 Life (who doesn't like donuts?)

Thread: 4.

 

[Ocha905]

Round 1 vs Roy FFC

3. TedDougChris An absolute powerhouse performance.
2. Mobbs A wealth of info and legendary minecraft builder.
1. Zevon Got the Roys going early.

Thread: 4/5 (I don't really know, it's my first thread).

 

[Cadsky]

Rd 1 vs Dragons

3 - Lbaddie29
2 - serial_thrilla
1 - T2B_

Slow start but baddie really got the match thread moving. 3.5/5

 

[Strigoi]

Vs. Gold City Royals

3 - Cadsky -
2 - grumbleguts - not all that grumble-y
1 - GreyCrow - it is ruck week, right?

Thread - 4/5 …after a slow start. Could have been because it was the first game, or that it started on Monday.

 

[HARPSichord]

Round 1 v Fighting Furies

3. SplintWhisky - irreverent towards our club greats and piss funny to boot. Classy young poster
2. James Colorado - always a kind and welcoming chap but enjoyed when he had a crack at damicky and defended his club
1. NaturalDisaster - another solid performer. Love it every time he goes head to head with SM

Thread 3.5/5

 

[Gralin]

Round 1 v Swamprats
3 philreich quality dad jokes for days
2 okeydoke7 the build up for 1k
1 jackster83 for foolishly engaging with my banter

Thread 5 popped my cherry so

 

[Falconista]

Round One versus Las Vegas Bears:
3. JoshWoodenSpoon
2. guero
1. Tandy

Terrific week, with many contributors who are quite unlucky to miss out on the votes. 4.5/5

 

[Mrs Turbo]

R1 v ES Phoenix
3. thewizardmelon - I love seeing the integrity shown (its possible even in this fake place)
2. The Majestic - Mrs T's Tavern's profits took a dive this week but all for a good cause. Thoughts still with you
1. por_please_ya - luv the balance between good reason and humour

Thread - 3.5 / 5 Maybe we OOBs were a bit distracted for reasons ideas still unknown

 

[The Majestic]

Round 1 v OOB

3. Mrs Turbo - Good bar experience.
2. Robertio - Always puts on a good show in the threads.
1. TJohn - his sad puppy dog eyes made me want to give him a vote.

 

[philreich]

Round 1 v Demons

3 - Gralin Give him the EKA now - he was excellent
2 - Scythe94 Nice debut for the Dees
1 - Headless The backbone of the Dees put in another stellar performance

 

[Mrs Turbo]

3 - @Gralin Give him the EKA now - he was excellent

Well that saves a lot of work! What do you think Cadsky ?

 

[AnUltimateRessie]

Well that saves a lot of work! What do you think Cadsky ?

perhaps asking Cadsky about their opinion regarding the EKA isn't a wise choice anymore after last seasons hysterics

 

[Mrs Turbo]

perhaps asking Cadsky about their opinion regarding the EKA isn't a wise choice anymore after last seasons hysterics

I thought an early EKA melt would be a good way to finish this week on a high!

 

[Cadsky]

Well that saves a lot of work! What do you think Cadsky ?

my thoughts are irrelevant

 

[Greenery]

Rd 1 vs Dragons

3 - Lbaddie29
2 - serial_thrilla
1 - T2B_

Slow start but baddie really got the match thread moving. 3.5/5

Edit and give me 3 campaigner

 

[Gralin]

my thoughts are irrelevant

Not if you concur.

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

my thoughts are irrelevant

Finally, the truth.

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

Round 1 vs Phoenix

Enjoyed the thread, although I was slightly distracted by some other trivial matter

3 por_please_ya - really good to see her up and about
2 The Majestic - gives it, takes it, a lot of fun
1 thewizardmelon - keeps chugging away, the diesel that never lets you down

Phoenix off to a really good start which is great to see. 3.5/5

 

[Greenery]

Dragons vs Royals

Dragons
3. Greenery great first week as captain
2. serial_thrilla was the MVP of the board this week
1. T2B_ proved himself a capable deputy
5/5

Royals.
3. krakouers funny fella
2. CakeEater krakouers sidekick
1. Cadsky did stuff in the committee

3/5

 

[Scythe94]

Round 1 v Swamprats

3 - okeydoke7. Rooting for goal #1000 next week (immediate retirement pending). Enjoyed spammydoke7
2 - philreich. A pleasure and a connoisseur of the dad joke
1 - BloodySwan. V enjoyable. Hope you get to eat that pizza soon

Thread a 4.5/5. Most involved I've been in SFA so far and had a delightful time

 

[krakouers]

Dragons vs Royals

Dragons
3. Greenery great first week as captain
2. serial_thrilla was the MVP of the board this week
1. T2B_ proved himself a capable deputy
5/5

Royals.
3. krakouers funny fella
2. CakeEater krakouers sidekick
1. Cadsky did stuff in the committee

3/5

krakouers appreciates this

 

[Greenery]

krakouers appreciates this

I appreciate krakouers