Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Hawthorn, Changes for Melbourne, Sunday July 30

[Mr Magic]

I think I'd rather kick the easy goal and then back our guys to win it out of the centre. When Cotch and Jack missed those absolute sitters we didn't cause a turnover and then get a goal.

Agree but Cotch's miss was a far bigger sitter than Jack's albeit in play

 

[tigerfan1961]

Mansell

Wouldn’t be dropping him for Cumberland.
Need to pressure up and keep the footy in our F50. Play Coulthard, Mansell and maybe MJR and just tell our talls to either mark it or get it to the turf. Cannot allow easy rebounds or intercept marks.
Cumberland had his arse handed to him last time in that regard, so I’m not sure I’d trust him in applied pressure stakes. He does seem to kick goals mind you.

 

[roacheee]

Agree with Jack, after watching the VFL, I can once again see Biggy being the perfect Townsend, I see a player that gets better the better the players you have around him.

But I think he has to be the medium forward, the third tall, even in the pressure forward role, so you would have to leave out a small, like Pickett or Graham, and when was the last time a premiership player was dropped?

Biggie compared to Towner?

Say that again gif

 

[AstuteTiger]

Last time we played Melbourne we corrected how we entered the 50, which worked. Would have won if lynch and Nank played.

We had 7 players out that night. 100% we would've won if most of them played. Melbourne was at full strength.
In this game coming up we have Nank, Lynch, and Gibcus out. The dees have Oliver, Fritsch, and Grundy out. Petty (ribs) and Hibberd who hasn't played since RD15. Both are tests but wouldn't be at all surprised if both don't play.

 

[Tiges1229]

We will beat Shemons by 10 goals

 

[RFCGloryJC]

The Dees play Pickett through the centre at times.
Marlesy Pickett can run right through.
His hit on Gov was sensational.

 

[Danw0w]

Expected score was 102-68

**** I would have been so pissed off if we lost that

 

[Hoos]

Agree but Cotch's miss was a far bigger sitter than Jack's albeit in play

It was. It actually looked harder to miss than to kick the goal.

 

[tora tora tora]

This clown needs to be called out.
FOUR bloody umpires but nothing to see here…

View attachment 1749768View attachment 1749769

And the 50 not paid for STAND. Hoping for free kicks to suddenly go our way is a wasted endevour.

Like I've said, I hardly ever see Hawks. But watching the replay it also highlighted JR's mis 20m pass into the fwd 50. Lucky we ended up with a goal 4 plays later. Plus Jack's 1 goal 3. (1 goal last week)

Can't really drop Jack, Maybe we need Bauer straight IN ASAP. Another genuine target. Cumbo marks a lot so have to bring him in at least.

Good to see MRJ in the middle in the VFL too, just seeing what Kosi did in the centre for the Dees. We sadly lack a winner in there.


We need a replacement badly.

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

The Spirit of Relton Roberts will flow through him.

In the changing rooms he will smash 2 fried dimmies, 3 potato cakes and a chiko roll and wash it down with a farmer's union. Will lead to a plugger level performance

 

[DeseRigs]

Put Townsend in Lynch's guernsey and get him to give Lever yet another bath.

 

[bradydaw91]

Expected score was 102-68

* I would have been so pissed off if we lost that

where do you get this expected score information?

 

[Sol23]

Cumbo deserved the call up but who goes out??
Maybe kmac and Pickett back to the wing

 

[Roachy8]

Need to pressure up and keep the footy in our F50. Play Coulthard, Mansell and maybe MJR and just tell our talls to either mark it or get it to the turf. Cannot allow easy rebounds or intercept marks.

Yeah - I reckon this is a simple, often instructed tactic but if the player kicking the ball in continues to dump it long - without looking - to a Jack 2 or 3 to one then the tall forward has no hope in marking or equalising most times.

When a defender picks off an intercept it is more often a problem with the entry kick rather than the efforts of one of our outnumbered tall forwards....

 

[tiger_tough]

Cumbo deserved the call up but who goes out??
Maybe kmac and Pickett back to the wing

That'd make sense but you just know Kmac isnt getting dropped.

 

[Vassp]

i said it once ill say it again, we need to get Cumbo back in form and up to speed if we want to do anything this year.

we lack forward potency

 

[Growapair]

i said it once ill say it again, we need to get Cumbo back in form and up to speed if we want to do anything this year.

we lack forward potency

 

[Growapair]

We will beat Shemons by 10 goals

Mate we couldn't even beat West Coast by 10 goals

i said it once ill say it again, we need to get Cumbo back in form and up to speed if we want to do anything this year.

we lack forward potency

 

[Vassp]

By name by nature

 

[All Aust]

i said it once ill say it again, we need to get Cumbo back in form and up to speed if we want to do anything this year.

we lack forward potency

The new improved Cumbo??? Or that one who melted faster than ice cream in the Mojave, the minute that Piggy Hibberd sideway glanced at him?

Remember that? It was all Godees balls going through Piggy after that sideway glance. Can still hear the whimpering from Cumbo. Scarred the dude.

 

[banzai]

Wouldn’t be dropping him for Cumberland.
Need to pressure up and keep the footy in our F50. Play Coulthard, Mansell and maybe MJR and just tell our talls to either mark it or get it to the turf. Cannot allow easy rebounds or intercept marks.
Cumberland had his arse handed to him last time in that regard, so I’m not sure I’d trust him in applied pressure stakes. He does seem to kick goals mind you.

Id still rather Cumberland than Pickett tbh. Also we still have Baker up forward, he wont need to go back with Short likely to play. Coulthard should start, id play MRJ over Mansell with Baker as well. But I doubt we drop or rest Cotchin so we prob cant afford 3 smalls

 

[Rubber Hips]

In case anyone was wondering….MRJ actually took the call….but media slimebags only showed the first bit


facts matter

TikTok - Make Your Day

 

[Noidnadroj]

Riewoldt and Cotch are pretty garbage now. We aren’t relying on them at all

Spot on …. he lists all our 30+ that will retire .. and it includes Pickett, Macca, Cotch and Jack …. who are either cooked or providing limited value.

Yes, we will miss Martin, Prestia and Lynch but it’s not unusual to have a few 32+ players on the list that you rely on .

Has this campaigner ever heard of Pendles, Sidey and Howe?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Vassp]

The new improved Cumbo??? Or that one who melted faster than ice cream in the Mojave, the minute that Piggy Hibberd sideway glanced at him?

Remember that? It was all Godees balls going through Piggy after that sideway glance. Can still hear the whimpering from Cumbo. Scarred the dude.

Nah, the cumbo from last year or the new improved one

 

[guruisatiger]

And a tag. The same guy that kept Josh Kelly to six possessions.

I like it. And the great thing about Young is he will commit to it and carry it out.

Indeed and he has a nice simple approach to goal kicking as well