Kegs15
Just a fan
Not even AFL.com could summon up much interest in us - just leave the placeholder for Oscar and Jake's goals tally, nobody will care
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Autopsy Round 16, 2024: Positives and Negatives vs Hawthorn
- Thread starter MeltMan
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Guarding space is ****ing shite if the opposition team continually carves you up - go ****ing man-on-man ffs...
I thought we were supposed to be super fit in the preseason. Not one person in that team gut runs. Yet 75% of the hawks were all ****ing day.
I thought we were supposed to be super fit in the preseason. Not one person in that team gut runs. Yet 75% of the hawks were all ****ing day.
HoneyBadger35
They're not going to pick him, Mitch.
- Aug 11, 2011
- 28,207
- 79,467
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Moderator
- #53
Yep, stellar coaching effort by Sam Mitchell in 2015 too. Give me strength.
And we performed in that gf exactly how? The Simmo way that’s how!
Gov and Barrass good. Reid with effort - to win ball in that situation is commendable. STFU about clangers - there is no support, no structure, he isn’t a magician.
Same thing with guys like Duggan and Witho - they do ok, but ultimately they are always under immense pressure and there is nobody to kick to. They did well today I reckon.
Same thing with guys like Duggan and Witho - they do ok, but ultimately they are always under immense pressure and there is nobody to kick to. They did well today I reckon.
he made sure that he beat us in 2015 to give us the drive to win in 2018
it was all part of his master plan
Get_The_Gaff
Norm Smith Medallist
- Apr 4, 2021
- 5,620
- 13,151
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Witho was shit what are you on about !
Direct kicking turnovers leading to goals under no pressure
Cant keep up with any of the hawks smalls and they just ran around him .
Got a bunch of cheap marks and kicks and 1 good mark at the end .
Well..
+ Barrass and Gov
Waterman came back on after look in big trouble
- Everything else
+ Barrass and Gov
Waterman came back on after look in big trouble
- Everything else
yes its simmos fault we made it to a GF and then lost
if sam mitchell wasn't in the coaches box then sheed would've kicked a behind from the pocket and we would've lost in 2018 i guess
HoneyBadger35
They're not going to pick him, Mitch.
- Aug 11, 2011
- 28,207
- 79,467
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Moderator
- #61
Sure thing mate. Eagles the best team in footy that year and handed Hawks their ass in a QF before having to play an away GF to a club handed it on a platter.
1 coach wins the flag each year, you can’t just sack the other 17.
His time is up but that’s a big spare me on that revisionist crap.
I'm speechless. "Best team we've field in years" according to many and we looked as bad as at any time over the last 3 years.
Think I'm back on the sack simmo bandwagon.
Think I'm back on the sack simmo bandwagon.
Glad I didn't see much of it.
Last quarter is all I saw, not sure why I bothered.
It was good to see Ryan trying hard in the last but he tried to do a bit too much, I don't blame him though at that stage. Duggan also looked good, but again, this was only one quarter.
Allen's set shot kicking needs to improve in a hurry.
Last quarter is all I saw, not sure why I bothered.
It was good to see Ryan trying hard in the last but he tried to do a bit too much, I don't blame him though at that stage. Duggan also looked good, but again, this was only one quarter.
Allen's set shot kicking needs to improve in a hurry.
to be fair the backline is probably our only positive out of this game, and the only reason we didn't lose by 100. gov and barrass specifically.
our mids offered no support which meant our backs had to just bomb it long in hope
our forwards were invisible because there was no midfield to deliver it to them
cacik
Senior List
Oh boy today was bad..
Positives: snakey waterman put in a games worth in a half.. hope he's alright btw.
Ohhhhh boy, other than that yeo did well considering the off field things..
Negatives... Go for it Bigfooty feed brothers and sisters, I'm numb... Go your hardest, go your fastest....
Faster and harder than our list pls ASAP.. love you all
Positives: snakey waterman put in a games worth in a half.. hope he's alright btw.
Ohhhhh boy, other than that yeo did well considering the off field things..
Negatives... Go for it Bigfooty feed brothers and sisters, I'm numb... Go your hardest, go your fastest....
Faster and harder than our list pls ASAP.. love you all
In 2015 we got smashed from the opening bounce and never recovered, in 2018 we got smashed from the opening bounce and then the mids stood up big time and we recovered and won. Wonder who the midfield coach was in 2018 ?
Shit I mean even spuds like Sheed and Redden were tearing up the 2018 finals campaign
it was the best field we've had in years, which is why this is such a significantly shit result
we put out better performances with West Clark and O'Neill
Simmo's done.
- Sep 15, 2016
- 764
- 1,348
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Those campaigners should have to donate their match pay to a domestic violence charity
Not sure Simpson will survive that?
Can Simpson be blamed for the senior mids getting slaughtered?
it's real smooth brain thinking to ignore every other variable between the 2015 performance and the 2018 performance and just go 'nup it was 100% on mitchell'
Sheppard played in 2015 and he didn't play in 2018, using your logic I can make the same claim that Sheppard not playing is the reason we won
yes
simmo should donate his salary to gov and barrass as they're pretty much the reason he's lasted this long
Similar threads
