Round 18 Trades

[QS]

Gibbs.

 

[Fitzey]

Gibbs --> Grimes.
Someone to Boomer

 

[Willo #6]

At this early stage:

Swallow (had the douche for way too long)> Murphy
NicNat> Cloke

 

[TedDougChris]

Staker/Clisby/Hrovat - Colquhoun (depending if he plays next week)
S Mitchell to ??? or Gibbs to Malceski..

 

[The Jet]

Right now well for now, Goldstein & Gibbs. Goldy looks absolutely stuffed out there.

 

[Butler]

Sinclair -> 89k ruck
Lecras -> SJ

Had to trade out SJ to bring in both Rockliff and B.Ebert this week rather than taking premiums that I didn't want and I was sick of having premiums sit on the bench. SJ is a must to come back in this week no matter what injuries I cop.

 

[ashley12]

Macaffer - gun midfielder
Docherty blicavs or staker - a rookie

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

KMart to Roughead at this stage. Shame the kid can't get a game (he's not injured, is he?).

Not sure on second trade. Any decent rookies knocking about?

 

[CaptScott]

Back line needs shoring up for me this week, was planning on finally dropping Hart but after Gibbs tonight...

 

[CrowAboutIt]

Swallow > Okeefe?

Goldy > Roughead or trade Cox back in

 

[Jessbek]

Goodes > Grimes
Daw > 89k

 

[pauldrc]

Swallow and Scotland....totally useless!

Wish I could have traded them weeks ago.....

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Lol trad out gibbs,do it do it!!!!

 

[Forward Press]

Who would you trade Gibbs to? I'm keeping him unless there are absolutely zero issues with other players in my side. Back premiums are very hard to find.

 

[Scrotes2000]

Goodes > Grimes

Goodes trade. Will probably do this.

 

[Dan12]

At this stage:
Clisby to Grimes
S. Mitchell to Ablett

 

[LanLion]

Right now well for now, Goldstein & Gibbs. Goldy looks absolutely stuffed out there.

Damn, when he did that interview and said "Well, I'm stuffed"... it didn't look too good... I'm desperate to trade him out too. Kreuzer is far and away the best ruckman in the comp right now, and probably DT wise too.
----

Keeping Gibbs for now. 2 low scores running, but FFS he was tagging last night!! God knows why.. but hopefully it's not a permanent change. If he's in the same role next wk against the Suns then I'm pulling the plug.

 

[Scotland]

I want to get rid of Hartlett and Terlich, and also upgrade Tom Mitchell.

Mitchell keeps getting 100s and his value keeps rising, so for now he can stay.

Perhaps I'll downgrade Kyle Martin to a rookie and upgrade Hartlett/Terlich. Of course I planned to do that this week but Kane Cornes and Steve Johnson decided to **** that up for me.

 

[The Jet]

Damn, when he did that interview and said "Well, I'm stuffed"... it didn't look too good... I'm desperate to trade him out too. Kreuzer is far and away the best ruckman in the comp right now, and probably DT wise too.
----

Keeping Gibbs for now. 2 low scores running, but FFS he was tagging last night!! God knows why.. but hopefully it's not a permanent change. If he's in the same role next wk against the Suns then I'm pulling the plug.

Make it 3 poor scores in a row for Gibbs. Was going to trade Hibberd but he pumped it late.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Who would you trade Gibbs to? I'm keeping him unless there are absolutely zero issues with other players in my side. Back premiums are very hard to find.

Exactly! Who are the top 6 backs from now until the end of the season? I'm going to go with Heppell, Goddard, Malceski, Ibbotson and ??????? Everyone else seems to have good and bad games. I've got those 4 plus Hartlett and Gibbs but no point in trading them as the player traded in is just as likely to spud it up for a game or two just as much as them.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Stevenson -> Rookie
Swallow -> ?????????

Already have Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, ROK, Barlow and J Selwood. Not sure who to consider other than Jack? Any opinions?

 

[Forward Press]

Exactly! Who are the top 6 backs from now until the end of the season? I'm going to go with Heppell, Goddard, Malceski, Ibbotson and ??????? Everyone else seems to have good and bad games. I've got those 4 plus Hartlett and Gibbs but no point in trading them as the player traded in is just as likely to spud it up for a game or two just as much as them.

And tonight Hanley was great (but we know about his tendency for really low scores), Shaw was bad, Hartlett did well (but see Hanley), Grimes is injury-prone etc etc.

It's incredibly difficult identifying a sure thing down back. You just have to put up with their relative spudness this year.

 

[Ball Hog]

Rowe -> Curren
Wines (Finally) -> Barlow

 

[lmach]

Kreuzer is far and away the best ruckman in the comp right now, and probably DT wise too.

Best ruckman in the comp? Nowhere near it.

 

[Dewy006]

Best ruckman in the comp? Nowhere near it.

Right now he is, absolutely, name a ruckmen playing better at the moment?