Game Day Round 18 vs. Geelong, MCG, 7:40pm Friday 12/07

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dean has fallen out of favour, it seems. I get it though.

Ash too after his last game. 5 in the VFL, no Checkers. If he was ever getting a game it was this week.

I’m ok with selections.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

My changes as expected

Friday 12 July
Collingwood v Geelong
MCG, Wurundjeri
7:40pm (AEST)
IN: Elliot, Noble, McInnes
OUT: Mihocek (injury), Howe (injury), Dean (omitted)


COLLINGWOOD V GEELONG
BBrayden MaynardDarcy MooreIsaac Quaynor
HBJohn NobleOleg MarkovWill Hoskin-Elliott
CSteele SidebottomScott PendleburyJosh Daicos
HFBobby HillNathan KreugerLachie Schultz
FNed LongPatrick Lipinski Jamie Elliott
RDarcy CameronJordan De GoeyNick Daicos
INTBilly FramptonJack CrispReef McInnes
Joe RichardsHarvey Harrison
EMGFinlay MacraeLachie SullivanAsh Johnson
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

sen & others making such a big deal about Billy coming straight back in after 10 weeks.

Ashcroft & Melksham came straight back in after a year...!
Someone on the radio today suggested it was desperation, same as McStay coming back. No way they'd be coming back so soon otherwise, etc.
 
Dean dropped is a good move. Sieve

Moore is the sieve

Dean shouldn’t be getting dropped. He needs some consistency.

No idea what we’re doing around selection this season.

Baffling stuff
 
Last edited:
Someone on the radio today suggested it was desperation, same as McStay coming back. No way they'd be coming back so soon otherwise, etc.
Yes, I was listening to that too.

I think that's a regular Saints supporter caller. He'd know all about desperation. And a real 'know all' who gets it wrong so often.

I loved how many called in after him saying they were now more confident about us winning tomorrow night as he he had written us off last year too.
 
it would be nice if reef has some sort of break out game. He's almost due. Reef has a lot of ability but it's time to make your mark
He debuted against Geelong in 2022, good game to have a breakout game
 
I’m not a big fan of him but I don’t get the Dean omission, clearly needs games and confidence bloody just play em
No match up for him I'm assuming, given Geelong only have 2 real talls... they prob feel Moore/Frampton can take care of it.

When you get subbed out the game prior, it leaves you vulnerable to being dropped
 
Match-Ups

Surely it's time that Moore goes to Cameron, and leads by example?

Seems like Cat's most dangerous forward option...

Bruz can take Rohan and niggle until Rohan snaps, resulting in a 6 week ban,,,
JFK can take Stengle, and just run full speed in unknown directions, and at least keep up to speed
IQ to Miers - IQ's will ask if Miers has the same toe injury, causing him to kick like he does
WHE to Mannagh - the Hyphen will explain that Werribee sewage farm is just down the road, and based on the size of WHE's nose, he can't smell a thing
Billy F to take Neale - Same Size - same limitations

It's all about the match-ups,,,,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top