Not sure anybody's in the mood right now but for posterity's sake, here it is.
Eligible for ROTY:
Curnow
Lucas
Tuohy
Eligible for ROTY:
Curnow
Lucas
Tuohy
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
MVP Round 4 Votes vs Essendon
- Thread starter blues4flag
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Thread starter
- #2
Honestly struggling to come up with 3 names to give votes to, let alone 5 + 1.
5. Marc Murphy: quieter by his standards but kicked a brilliant goal and created a couple others with great vision
4. Heath Scotland: got a lot of the footy and used it well
3. Eddie Betts: kicked the 4 of our 7
2. Lachie Henderson: thought he was our best defender
1. Chris Judd: battled manfully, scored an important goal and tried to lift us
ROTY: Tuohy best of a poor bunch. Lucas started well but burnt the footy
Waite misses out due to misses and poor disposal.
5. Marc Murphy: quieter by his standards but kicked a brilliant goal and created a couple others with great vision
4. Heath Scotland: got a lot of the footy and used it well
3. Eddie Betts: kicked the 4 of our 7
2. Lachie Henderson: thought he was our best defender
1. Chris Judd: battled manfully, scored an important goal and tried to lift us
ROTY: Tuohy best of a poor bunch. Lucas started well but burnt the footy
Waite misses out due to misses and poor disposal.
5. Henderson
4. Waite
3. Simpson (cut and paste from stats sheet)
2. Murphy (cut and paste from stats sheet)
1. Betts (cut and paste from most goals)
...... so we had 2 decent players today.
4. Waite
3. Simpson (cut and paste from stats sheet)
2. Murphy (cut and paste from stats sheet)
1. Betts (cut and paste from most goals)
...... so we had 2 decent players today.
5 - Scotland
4 - Murphy
3 - Simpson
2 - Waite
1 - Betts
Henderson did ok but there is no way I'm putting a defender in the votes
- 5 for Kreuzer and Hampson
4 - Murphy
3 - Simpson
2 - Waite
1 - Betts
Henderson did ok but there is no way I'm putting a defender in the votes
- 5 for Kreuzer and Hampson
Tough to even pick 3 guys that deserve votes today.....
5 - Hendo (Was terrific down back, a shining light today)
4- Murphy (continued his good form, might squeze a brownlow vote if lucky)
3- Scotland (worked hard all day)
2- Simpson (see scotland)
1 - Waite (was decent, terrible kicking though)
ROTY - Tuohy
5 - Hendo (Was terrific down back, a shining light today)
4- Murphy (continued his good form, might squeze a brownlow vote if lucky)
3- Scotland (worked hard all day)
2- Simpson (see scotland)
1 - Waite (was decent, terrible kicking though)
ROTY - Tuohy
Poseidon
Kreuzer Sonata
10k Posts
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2013
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2011 Player Sponsor
5. Murphy
4. Scotland
3. Simpson
2. Tuohy - ROTY
1. Henderson
4. Scotland
3. Simpson
2. Tuohy - ROTY
1. Henderson
Staggered Stamos, not sure I could find room for Robinson and Waite in the votes today but each to their own!
Tough to find 5 good players this week.
5. Murphy - was our best player by some margin
4. Scotland - used the ball well, but was a little off his usual output
3. Simpson - could have been the matchwinner if he had nailed all of his gettable shots on goal
2. Henderson - too good for Hurley, who seems to have plateaued somewhat
1. Judd - kept trying to break the game open, but was constantly frustrated by niggling tactics
BYP - Lucas, best of a bad bunch, could have been in the votes if he used the ball better
5. Murphy - was our best player by some margin
4. Scotland - used the ball well, but was a little off his usual output
3. Simpson - could have been the matchwinner if he had nailed all of his gettable shots on goal
2. Henderson - too good for Hurley, who seems to have plateaued somewhat
1. Judd - kept trying to break the game open, but was constantly frustrated by niggling tactics
BYP - Lucas, best of a bad bunch, could have been in the votes if he used the ball better
5 - Murphy
4 - Henderson
3 - Judd
2 - Scotland
1 - Kreuzer
BYP - Lucas was best of an ordinary lot as he has more upside hopefully.
4 - Henderson
3 - Judd
2 - Scotland
1 - Kreuzer
BYP - Lucas was best of an ordinary lot as he has more upside hopefully.
Only Henderson actually deserved votes, but I had to fill out the other 4.
Robbo had a crack. Waite took some good grabs. Unfortunately he missed his goals.
5 henderson
4 murphey
3 2e
2 simspon
1 scotland
BFYP 2E
4 murphey
3 2e
2 simspon
1 scotland
BFYP 2E
- Feb 18, 2009
- 5,009
- 455
- AFL Club
- Carlton
5 Murphy
4 Henderson
3 Simpson
2 Scotland
1 Judd
BYP - Lucas
4 Henderson
3 Simpson
2 Scotland
1 Judd
BYP - Lucas
aristeas
True Blue since '76
5 Henderson - tireless, fought out every contest till the last siren, would have been much worse without him.
4 Simpson - Worked hard all day
3 Kreuzer - Again, worked hard.
2 Murphy - work rate
1 Judd - never gives up
Tuohy ROTY
Worst:
1 Waite - just missed everything - if you cant kick goals you're a waste of space on the forward line.
2 Robinson - Specialised in appalling kicks into the forward 50, either hit an Essendon player on the chest, or blasted away without even looking.
3Maclean - too slow - if he's in the side we're going to have a bad day.
Invisible Man award to Garlett, Gibbs, Curnow, Hampson and others I just can't remember..
4 Simpson - Worked hard all day
3 Kreuzer - Again, worked hard.
2 Murphy - work rate
1 Judd - never gives up
Tuohy ROTY
Worst:
1 Waite - just missed everything - if you cant kick goals you're a waste of space on the forward line.
2 Robinson - Specialised in appalling kicks into the forward 50, either hit an Essendon player on the chest, or blasted away without even looking.
3Maclean - too slow - if he's in the side we're going to have a bad day.
Invisible Man award to Garlett, Gibbs, Curnow, Hampson and others I just can't remember..
OK, but I thought Murph and Judd deserved a mention but agree it was hard to fill spots!
- Jun 5, 2006
- 546
- 1
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- I'm on Bandwagon..Storm,Victory etc
5. Simmo
4. Robbo
3. Murph
2. Hendo
1. Eddie
Lucas did some nice things. Improving with each game.
PS .. The filth did their homework, and wanted the ball more. Dissapointing performance by our boys.
4. Robbo
3. Murph
2. Hendo
1. Eddie
Lucas did some nice things. Improving with each game.
PS .. The filth did their homework, and wanted the ball more. Dissapointing performance by our boys.
40yearBLUE
Norm Smith Medallist
Lucas -5 Not anywhere near hard enough at it. Would rather Ellard or Joseph having a crack than playing first rounders that lack appetite for the contest.
Bower -4 Rabbit in headlights returned
Yarran -3 (grow a heart kid, amazing how hurt players get when we are being whacked)
Jeffy -2 No Friday night lights so this bloke checks out for the day
Hammer -1 Warnock says thanks.
Crameri Stanton Hocking ---------------------------daylight---------------------------7 other hacks that wouldnt get a run in our team then some of our harder triers get an honorable mention, Laidler, Simmo, Judd, Murph, Eddie not many others.
Bower -4 Rabbit in headlights returned
Yarran -3 (grow a heart kid, amazing how hurt players get when we are being whacked)
Jeffy -2 No Friday night lights so this bloke checks out for the day
Hammer -1 Warnock says thanks.
Crameri Stanton Hocking ---------------------------daylight---------------------------7 other hacks that wouldnt get a run in our team then some of our harder triers get an honorable mention, Laidler, Simmo, Judd, Murph, Eddie not many others.
5. Hendo - brilliant job down back, led the way but nobody followed.
4. Simmo - worked hard all day
3. murph - same as simmo
2. carazzo - didn't have time to be as shit as everyone else was
1. hendo - deserves another as he was so far ahead of everyone else.
waite getting votes? his kicking just about cost us any chance in the 3rd. it's about more than just touches
4. Simmo - worked hard all day
3. murph - same as simmo
2. carazzo - didn't have time to be as shit as everyone else was
1. hendo - deserves another as he was so far ahead of everyone else.
waite getting votes? his kicking just about cost us any chance in the 3rd. it's about more than just touches
