Game Day Round 9, 2024: West Coast v Collingwood

[Mulldogg]

He’s 280+ games in. What do you expect?

To be capable of justifying his inclusion.

 

[whatis]

So that Hough HTB an outlier? Seen several similar situations just balled it up.

 

[KERRPOW]

Kelly been poo
Cole poo

Duggo great

Harley exciting albiet a few errors

Ginbey getting involved but disposal lacking polish

Witho doing ok

 

[bzparkes]

They've been the one side going for the ball, why shouldn't they be leading the count? Lazy stat to throw up.

They throw it every time they're tackled. Darcy Moore tackled and throws the ball on our F50, play on, yet Hough gets 0.5 to dispose of it and a free goal to them.

If they're going to pay the Hough one, they need to pay that every time. Won't happen with them in the same situation though, unless it's in our backline.

 

[Goroyals22]

Starting to think Ryan may be trade bait at this rate.

Is it really a surprise when we contract him before the season starts?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[FKASC]

Sheed into the midfield and the backing of Ryan after last week lowers standards.

Quarters like that are the result. It's not good enough.

Both should be traded imo. Doubt we get much out of either of them going forward - not a melt either. Ryan will need a different environment to get back to his best

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Pies gambling and bursting off half back, and more power to them. They know we can’t force the turnover to make them pay for charging out at the first sign of gaining posession.

Umps frustrating as heck but until we can make their HBFs accountable it won’t matter. Backs doing very well against extras and uncontested entries.

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Guys I don’t want to alarm anyone, but we may not be very good.

 

[Shoei]

Painful, Collingwood look like they are in 2nd gear.

We look like are standing on the side of the road with a flat waiting for the RAC.

 

[Magnum27]

Ryan should of been dropped last week. Been shocking since he came back. We are rewarding passengers now.

Let me know when he does that, because all I'm seeing from him at the game is standing around.

 

[BandF]

Score could of been worse, get stuck into them Simmo. Ryan 74% game time for 0 seriously.

 

[wce4premiership]

Ryan needs to get hands on the ball, need to try use him in link up play to get him involved.

We are getting killed at ground balls. We've done well to prevent them getting too many intercept marks but there's never anyone to get the ball after the spoil.

 

[Bender_]

Use quarter time to regroup, get the messages through to the kids and get back out there and put a contest on.

 

[Shuestar13]

Held up (somehow) towards the end there. Getting killed in the ruck and midfield, need a big lift from TK, Sheed and Bailey.

Liking Ginbey’s intent, but disposal has fallen away today. Reid been good.

Get some more ball into our 50 and need to find a way to lock it in there. Still three quarters

 

[Happy Mastenator]

To be capable of justifying his inclusion.

Would you rather maric or Williams had Moore eat them alive?

 

[Shueygod]

They've been the one side going for the ball, why shouldn't they be leading the count? Lazy stat to throw up.

Hasn’t been absolutely awful but it’s been poor, we saw a spin move htb on either side get adjudicated differently for example.

 

[wirra44]

Lol at people saying Ginbey is having a nightmare because he's turned it over a couple of times in a game where the Pies have turned the pressure up. His contested work and hands have been great, doing more than Kelly or Sheed (although Dom's been solid too)

That’s thing his disposal in traffic under pressure has been good buts its when he has had time and space he seems to turn it over

 

[Smotie2]

Umps doing great for Collingwood. Interpretation already favouring coling****s.

Missing yep and waterman badly. Lucky to be 3 goals down only

How bad is it for the bottom team to have the draw we have for the first 9 rounds
Absolute disgrace VFL.

 

[eaglesnutcase]

We are not doing the basics. Not hitting the contest
Not hitting bodies
Nobody waiting down at marking contests.
Not looking short
Kicking shit.Yea you Ginbey

 

[KERRPOW]

Sheed's been ok from what i've seen. Free kick against Pendles wasn't that bad.

More Ginbey's decision making than teh execution.

Brereton summed it up when he said ginbey should have sidestepped and not kick on the wing because that was always going to be a smother.

Unfortunately every disposal by foot will now be scruitinised....like coles turnovers

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Margin is about right. Sure Collingwood didn't kick straight but we botched a few scoring opportunities.

 

[BeornJ]

Some very good defensive efforts from Witho in that quarter. Putting himself in the right spot, not afraid to wear one for the team. Good stuff.

Hopefully we can make some changes to fix up the clearances, hard to do with our best bull out though.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Boys playing like they're still on the morning walk.

 

[squashface]

Sheed pea hearted effort continues to shit me.

Puts his arms out to present himself as an option but he’s about 10m away from the kicker with 2 Pies players around him. Wtf is the point of that Dom? Maybe actually put the effort in to run yourself into a dangerous position.

Finally gets the ball and kicks backwards. Nice.

GTFO you useless campaigner

 

[random260]

I need ginbey to only handpass and not kick